Falls Firehouse Pizza
Falls Firehouse Pizza
Great Pizza
Kids cheese pizza, spaghetti with meat sauce
outside
pizza, food
pizza, food
Decorations on the wall
When in Sheboygan Falls, WI, stop here first. Great thin crust pizza and old Sheboygan Falls ambiance. Muriel is on west exterior wall!
Great atmosphere in a historic firehouse setting
a red leather coat hanging on a wall
a fireman's hat hanging from the ceiling
Mozzarella Sticks
Dining room
Place with pizza and bikes must be good
Place with pizza and bikes must be good
Thin crust galore
Chris S.
Jul 26, 2015
I have no idea why this place was so dead on a Saturday night. The food was awesome; pizza delish and our server, a young lady, was phenomenal, attentive and friendly. I am new to Sheboygan Falls and am from NYC; so I am always up for good pizza. It's not NYC style pizza but it is still good thin crust and was awesome in my opinion. The decor is very cool and it looks like they put a lot of attention to the styling and ambience (it is a former firehouse!). I'd say this place is a tightly held secret in Sheboygan Falls. Maybe the Sheboyganites and Kohlerites will discover this place soon and it will not be so secret anymore. ;)Support local businesses and try this local gem!!
Read More
Tanya K.
May 25, 2023
We came here based on the solid reviews and the menu. My daughter wanted a cheese pizza and spaghetti, so she got the kids cheese pizza meal ($5) for the pizza, drink, Oreo and applesauce and I got the spaghetti meal. It came with a salad and 2 breadsticks and was big. Was it the best spaghetti and cheese pizza I've ever had- no, but it was good and cheap. I also got a beer and all of it together was $20. I'll take it. The place is neat too. Lots to look at. Service was really good also.
Read More
Mike V.
May 4, 2023
Did a takeout order, appetizers, soups, salads, pizza and entrees. The guy taking our order was friendly, helpful and made suggestions. The restaurant is a very comfortable place. When we got home, everyone really enjoyed everything. They did a great job preparing everything just perfectly for a takeout order. Check them out.
Read More
Deb V.
Jun 28, 2023
Unfortunately, getting decent food or service is a thing of the past. Very sad that everything has gone downhill. Their hours also keep changing. They are no longer open for lunch.
Read More
Bailey M.
Dec 5, 2020
I had the spaghetti with meat sauce and pretzel sticks. It was pretty average/good. My husband had a pizza it was average as well. Prices were very affordable and staff was friendly. Lots of good options on their menu.
Read More
Lisa M.
Apr 30, 2023
Both the food and the ambiance are great. We've had trouble lately finding the business open. Service has been good every time we've been there. It's worth traveling to Sheboygan Falls just for their food!
Read More
William S.
Jun 30, 2019
Very tasty pizza and pretzel sticks. The pizza was thin crust but loaded with cheese and toppings. The pretzel sticks were soft, chewy and buttery. The restaurant is in an old renovated firehouse. Very nicely decorated. Good service.
Read More
Viridiana V.
Mar 9, 2024
So the food was amazing. Had a delicious taste and we might consider coming back.However, server was sub-par. We placed our order. We kept calling the server to get refills and he did not Come. After like 30+ minutes the hostess came by and she had to get our refills for us. Mind you he kept stopping by the tables around ours but not ours. He wouldn't even look at us. After the hostess took our drinks he comes and asked if we need refills....30+ minutes later!! All the tables around us ate, left and new people came in and our food was nowhere to be seen. After an hour we asked how much more time it would be and he said it should be a few minutes. We finally got our food and saw that the new people around us got their food about 10-15 minutes after we did, yet they arrived 20-25 minutes prior to that. I think he just forgot to submit our order and our table in general. Did not tip due to this bad service.Gave the check out our feedback and hope he takes it into consideration.
Read More
K. A.
Apr 11, 2023
Have tried to eat here several times and always seem to catch them closed. It's a long drive, but finally caught them open. I was very surprised. Pizza was GREAT. Thin crust, crispy, very tasty. Thought the price was a little high for the size of the pizza, but I don't mind paying for really good food. They even had Diet Root Beer. Waitress was very polite and attentive.Hope to come back soon :-)
Read More
Holly D.
Aug 12, 2023
Good pizza, fast, delicious. Get the bread sampler. Their speciality pizzas a awesome
Read More
