Still dry bread on the bottom, no oil and spices like the menu says ???
The cooked bacon cheeseburger.
The dry po boy.
The raw bacon cheeseburger pizza.
the front of the store
Fresh Italian
Pizza of the month.
Meatball Sub
This is why the take and bake pizza is awesome, no skimping on the toppings.
Packer
shelves of food and beverages
WI CheeseSteak Sub
Rueben
a display of food
Taste of Italy
Why frozen when you can fresh take and bake.
Badger
Skimpy toppings compared the the menu picture with no oil. Dry with next to no spices.
interior
California Chicken
Looks nothing like the menu, skimpy toppings, no oil and dry with next to no spices.
Hawaiian
Julie S.
Sep 12, 2024
We order the take and bake pizzas and have always been very pleased! I have tried the vegetable pizza and it is loaded with lots of fresh veggies and cheese. The macaroni and cheese is also very delicious. Check out Eaton's - you won't be disappointed.
Read More
Steven T.
May 11, 2020
After have a great experience with the pizzas from another location I thought that I would get a sub because the other location just did the pizzas because of the virus and I like subs.The place is known for its outrageous amount of fresh toppings on the fresh take and bake pizzas that have so many great choices that you can't get from the average pizza place. They also have frozen pizzas but why??? and coolers with various other take and bake items and subs/wraps etc. I thought that I would try the Po Boy sub with hard salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, green olives with oil and spices.First off my sandwich looked nothing like the the web photo with tons of fresh toppings which is why I ordered it, my sandwich had skimpy fresh toppings and not all the fresh crisp toppings I thought I was getting and I wanted.Second after my first bite was all dry bread and bland I opened it up and all the skimpy toppings were in the middle and no oil and spices WTF did they just charge me for because it's not what the menu advertised at all. This sandwich sounded so good but they F'd it and J/M subs was not far away and a better choice.WOW this sandwich had so much potential because like the pizza you will not find one like it but they just couldn't execute it properly or just didn't care.The bottom line is that I'm going to just stick with the pizzas because they are the best take and bake with tons of fresh toppings.
Read More
Greg B.
Dec 30, 2014
Eaton's has the best take-and-bake pizza in the world. The combination of their crispy thin crust, tangy sauce, loads of toppings, and fresh cheese is to die for. If you want to experience heaven, figuratively and literally, order the Cheese Lovers and prepare yourself for cheese bliss.Eaton's also has very good sub sandwiches. In addition to ordering subs with pre-selected meats, cheeses, and veggies you can build your own sub. It's not often you find a sandwich shop that allows you to build your own sub AND offers you premium choices of meat like Italian beef, corned beef, and capicola.Eaton's is as good as it gets. Make sure to sign up for their rewards program before you order.
Read More
Ashley O.
Jun 9, 2014
Food is mediocre at best. Service is average. Customer service is well below anything you would expect for a small Pizza and Sandwich shop. I am surprised that there are more than one location. I would say that if you decide to order something from Eatons, that it would be a good decision to go there in person and order so that you are able to watch them prepare your order. The employees have a reputation of running fast and loose with what it is you have requested. I will not return again because of the lack of professionalism and the out and out lack of customer service. If I had a choice I would have given them no stars so please take the 1 star rating with a large degree of generosity.
Read More
Julie S.
Mar 10, 2019
Awful experience. Worst customer service. How could All three of them been having a bad day. Dont expect your sandwiches to look Anything like the pictures on the computer.LAME. Never again.
Read More
Isabella R.
May 14, 2019
They make excellent pizzas. They make them fresh as well for you to take home. A bit more pricey, but totally worth it! I prefer to take and bake at home.
Read More