Day One Pizza

Great Pizza! Consistent service and quality.BUT YOU FOLKS NEED TO GET AN ONLINE SERVICE FOR ORDERING. IT IS AGONIZING TO ORDER FROM YOU. I have been calling in for many years and I have to give my name, address and telephone EVERYTIME!!! Don't you have caller ID? Couldn't it be a little simpler please!!!

Tried their pizza for the first time. It did not disappoint. The crust was delicious and all the toppings for the Works were generous and fresh. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese. I definitely will be ordering again.

First time we tried it was just a pepperoni pizza, nothing special. The BBQ chicken and the chicken Alfredo pizzas are amazing!

Love their pan style pizza, and their breadsticks are awesome! One of my favorite pizza places ever.

Their pizza is low quality and unbelievably over priced- Dominos quality at Salvatore's prices. They only stay in business because they're the only pizza place in town. Not to mention the staff is poorly trained and the owner is rude at best. It's well worth it to drive to Sun Prairie for better pizza (or make your own at home).

We've always done carryout here and have never had a bad pizza. The sauce is what I love the most of D1P. The sauce is just different, maybe it's saltier? IDK. The crust on the pizzas is nice and chewy and never tastes old. The place is always clean inside and you can get a good deal here.

Best pizza in Columbus. Always arrives smoking hot. Recently they added some new items to their menu. I highly recommend the Mac and Cheese pizza and cinnamon bread sticks if you are looking to carbo load! They do have a small sit down area but I always choose delivery.

Always kind fast and consistent the delivery for the pizza is great. Accurate kind and tasty.Ordered a pizza was easy and paid via cc on the phone and added the tip. It was a snowy night . . . I have a good tip. I am assuming that the driver gets that tip. I hope. Should I do cash next time?

Absolute rip off. Ordered a medium size pizza with 4 toppings. Over $30 with tip. Skimpy ingredients. Definitely will never give them my money again. Sure hope they're not taking advantage of the covid19 crisis to make an extra buck. As a truck driver my options are definitely limited right now, guess it's an empty stomach tonight, unpalatable

Delicious pizza! Worth the trip from out of town (50 minutes). Nice selection of specialty pizzas. Would like to go back any time.