Crumbl - Pleasant Prairie

Crumbl Cookies Pumpkin Square: New for 2024 from Crumbl is the Pumpkin Square. It's advertised as "a moist, fluffy pumpkin square marbled with brown sugar cinnamon butter, smothered with a light vanilla cream cheese frosting, and topped with a sprinkle of warm spice". I almost didn't buy this because it was my first "square" from Crumbl and I didn't know if it would be worth the price tag or not (an additional dollar to their already questionable base price). For starters, it is relatively large and heavy. Cutting a piece out of the tray, it was even thicker than it initially appeared. Even though it's thick, I found it to be somewhat light and airy/fluffy. Its texture is a cross between cake and pumpkin pie. Sort of hard to imagine, it's a cake, but a little gooey like pumpkin pie. The square is intended to be served warm and when done so, it practically melts in your mouth. As for the flavor, it's a mild pumpkin with hints of cinnamon without too much spice or burning. I feared there might not have been enough cream cheese frosting since the layer on top is thinner than a skeleton, but the intense sweetness of it more than makes up for the amount. Hidden by the cream cheese is a layer of gooey brown sugar cinnamon butter that also ups the sweetness. I looked like the quintessential jack-o'-lantern after eating my pumpkin square as I had a larger-than-life grin on my face. Doughboy approved Doughboy_Food_Reviews My Top Crumbl Cookies:1. Caramel Popcorn 2. Salted Caramel Cheesecake 3. Blue Monster4. Cake Batter/Birthday Cake5. Mallow Sandwich ft. OREO*Pumpkin Square (favorite non-cookie from Crumbl)

What a staff member?!! For my daughters birthday, my husband and I were traveling with our son and arranged cookie pick up. I placed an order on the app and when I called to inquire if I could change the time the lady assisted, but then also advised that I could utilize the app to place an order for my birthday cookie as well. I believe the person who assisted me was Taylor. Thank you very much as you made the process a whole lot smoother.

Good service, great reward program. Cookies are often too rich to finish but we still enjoy tasting.

Crumbl has become by goto for a quick and delicious dessert. The menu of six cookies changes weekly but has thus far never disappointed. We have several luncheons and birthday parties where I work and Crumbl has never disappointed. Easy to preorder and pick up or have delivered. Please note this is comfort food and except a high calorie treat! They do have nutritional facts about each cookie on their website for those "counting calories".

These are one of the best cookies I have tasted in a very long time! The cookies change weekly but the have chocolate chip every week! To me the buttery cookies taste the best ! I had the Reese's Peanut Butter one today it was so delicious . They are the new and up coming cookie delight ! So go for it then take a walk!

Crumbl is the best place to ever get cookies from they taste amazingly good always fresh and delicious and located in Pleasant Prairie and the prices are pretty good as well.

Oh my gosh!!! These cookies are so addicting!! Have you tried them yet?! :) I visited in September of 2021. That week, they had Sugar cookies, milk chocolate, churro, original with peanut butter M&Ms, cornbread and chocolate crunch. Chocolate crunch is my favorite out of them all. Very chewy with a bit of a molasses texture. I love it! I can probably eat two of those in one setting. If you want to try all the flavors they have to offer that week, I highly suggest getting the smaller size cookies. Their regular sized cookies are very filling just trying to finish one. They are very sweet, rich and buttery. I can't imagine the calories in one of them lol. Great to bring to parties or get togethers. They are made fresh and you can definitely taste a difference. If I were to rank the cookies I had that week, first would be chocolate crunch, sugar cookie , milk chocolate, cornbread, original with M&M and lastly Churro. I'm a huge fan of regular cinnamon churros but churro cookies just didn't exactly hit the spot. I was a little disappointed. I did notice a couple employees not wearing a mask while indoors back in Sept 2021... since they are serving "food," hopefully they have gotten better at reinforcing their employees to wear a mask. Excited to return to try out other flavors!

love the cookies! sksjsjbsnsjdhshshshhshshehehshshshhehehehehebshshdbehhsyehehebehehwhebrbr service was awesome loved it

Cookie was to doughy for me needs to be done a little more! Otherwise they are good! Service was good

Delicious cookies every time! When ordering curbside, delivery is quick and easy!The staff are always friendly! The store is always clean!