Craig's Cake Shop

We ordered this cake for my daughter's golden birthday! I sent them an inspo pic and they NAILED it! I was soooo happy when I picked this up! They were so accommodating and answered all my questions! They were friendly and the lady at the front counter was so sweet! Will definitely be ordering from them again! The carrot cake was amazing!

I ordered a birthday cake from here. It was a carrot cake with whipped cream and dark chocolate shavings. The cake was beautifully done and was delicious. The shop was neat and quiet.

cupcakes were ok. Cake was not what I asked for at all. Was hoping to be happy with what I got but very disappointed. Next time I will take the one hour drive to actually pick up something worth the money. Instead of driving 30 mins for something that really wasn't worth it.

Craig's has been a staple in our house for years, beginning back in 2014 for our wedding. Since then, we've ordered many birthday and other celebratory cakes. Craig's cakes are not only delicious, but also beautifully decorated! I love the many different flavor options to choose from. My favorite is peach, although any other choice is equally as yummy. The best part about getting a wedding cake from them is that on your first anniversary, you can call and get a fresh top tier made, instead of trying to freeze the original as is tradition. For my son and daughter's 1st birthdays they also received a free smash cake with the purchase of a standard size. Hard to beat that!

If you dream of cake this is the place for you. Cupcakes, small cakes, wedding cakes and everything in between. Our favorite is the carrot cake with white chocolate frosting. Incredibly moist and flavorful frosted with cheesecake mousse and white chocolate curls! Mini cakes are available frozen for the spur of the moment indulgence all others are made to order.Covid rules mean you call when you get there, stay in your car, they bring out the cake, pay and go.

Ordered a baby shark themed smash cake and what I ended up with was coked out-meth shark.We paid over $100 for some cupcakes and a 6" single tier wack cake. When we picked the cake up, the employee commented that they have been getting a lot of baby shark requests lately, but I can't tell by the horrible composition.The women on the phone who took the order sounded harried and mentioned that they could do the cake, but they had 2 weddings to do the same weekend which begs me to think 1) sounds like a personal problem and 2) that our cake was a sloppy, rush job. They are not open on Sundays and I wanted to confirm that I had to pick up my cake the day before, to which she replied, "I already told you twice, we're not open on Sundays".Seems like they won't need future business from me ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

If you love Bluey as much as we do you'd understand how the duck cake was a must. Since my strong suit is certainly not baking Craig's Cake Shop made the perfect rendition for us! Not to mention they accommodated a last minute cupcake order add. If your looking for custom cakes in the Madison area we definitely recommend them. Not to mention how tasty it was!

We wanted a special cake for my baby's first birthday. We were hosting on a Badger football Saturday so we really wanted a Bucky cake. We found Craig's has the official licenses to reproduce the UW copyright images like Bucky and the motion W. Got a round red velvet cake and everyone said it was moist and delicious. Baby got a free Smash cake that was plain vanilla with whipped cream frosting - it was huge! Very happy with my purchase.

Got my 18th Birthday cake from here. It was yummy and beautiful!! The layers are lemon poppyseed cake, raspberry cheesecake mousse, vanilla cake, lemon curd, vanilla cake. I was disappointed with the frosting. It should've have been a huge surprise because I'm not that big of a buttercream fan but the vanilla buttercream was way too sweet for me and my family (and it was very thick). I wish we'd gone with the signature whipped cream frosting but the ombré sides design wouldn't have worked out with that. Will have to try a 4" or cake push up pop with the whipped cream frosting because the cake taste was great!

We had a carrot cake for a birthday party with over 200 people attending and everyone raved about how great the cake was. even my sister a professor baker said it was awesome‼‼‼