Classic Slice
Classic Slice
Our regular cheesestix (pizza dough, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, herbs) with fresh habanero peppers. VERY HOT.
Bacon, Brussels sprouts, goat cheese, spicy honey drizzle (no red sauce)
Feta, chive, habanero peppers, chicken, spicy honey drizzle (no red sauce) SPICY!
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, and Soppressata (Spicy Salami)
Served with toasted ciabatta bread.
Fresh-made and at least 5 to an order. Drizzled with olive oil, dusted with herbs and garlic and served with red sauce.
Beef meatballs, red sauce, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese and ciabatta bread.
Beef meatballs, spinach, ricotta and bacon. Served with ciabatta bread.
Cheesy artichoke dip served with ciabatta.
Sprouts covered with cheddar and chives.
Goat cheese mashed potatoes with white cheddar and chives.
Arugula, edamame, crushed pistachios, mint, roasted golden beets, and avocado with red pepper dressing.
Kale, chickpea, red quinoa with shaved parsnips, radish, roasted cauliflower, and micro greens with balsamic vinaigrette.
Spring greens with seasonal veggies, your choice of ranch or balsamic dressing.
Romaine, Pecorino Romano, Croutons and Caesar dressing.
Mixed greens, sliced Roma tomatoes, fresh basil, mozzarella and balsamic dressing.
Includes red sauce, grana padano (really good parmesan), and mozzarella.
includes red sauce, grana padano (really good parmesan), and mozzarella.
Tomatoes, red sauce, garlic, fresh mozzarella and basil. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Red sauce, feta, spinach, black olives, artichokes and shredded mozzarella. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Pesto, pine nuts and shredded mozzarella. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Blend of ricotta, fresh and shredded mozzarella, caramelized onions, and parsley. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Green peppers, pineapple, bacon, red sauce and shredded mozzarella. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Bacon, goat cheese-mashed potato, and chives. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Sausage, mushrooms, mozzarella, feta, peppers and onions. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Bacon, sausage, mushrooms and pesto. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Meatballs, pepperoni, sausage and bacon. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Chicken breast, garlic, mushrooms, tomatoes and feta. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Sausage, pesto, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Red sauce base, bacon, Alfredo sauce, spinach, ricotta and shredded mozzarella. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Red sauce, Bacon, Kim Chi, Chives, Mozzarella
Red sauce, Bacon, Jalapeo, Cheese Curds
Red sauce, olive tapenade, sun-dried tomato, spinach, mushrooms and baked tofu. No soy cheese. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Curry sauce, fresh tomato, broccoli, spinach, mushrooms and tofu. No soy cheese. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Red sauce, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, choice of tofu. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Basil, pepitos and olive oil sauce with house made tofu based soy cheese. Topped with pine nuts. Hand-tossed traditional NY crust.
Yellow curry sauce, kim chi, spinach, broccoli, crimini mushrooms, curried tofu (no cheese).
Served with 4 toppings.
To guarantee the best quality bake on Detroit-style pizza we do not allow additional toppings or alterations to this item.
To guarantee the best quality bake on Detroit-style pizza we do not allow additional toppings or alterations on this item.
dough filled with a ricotta and Parmesan cheese blend, garlic, herb and red sauce. Choice of 2 toppings and comes with an extra side of sauce.
Hand-tossed traditional NY crust with choice of base.
Cut into 6 slices.
Cut into 6 slices.
House-made meatballs, shredded mozzarella, roasted red peppers, giardiniera peppers, spinach, red sauce and Italian herbs on our fresh baked ciabatta. Includes a bag of chips.
Slow roasted beef, ricotta, giardiniera and mozzarella on ciabatta bread. Includes a bag of chips.
Local bottled root beer
Local cherry popo
Wisconsin made!
Served with an ice cold fountain drink.
Served with an ice cold fountain drink.
Served with an ice cold fountain drink.
I'm Feta Up Pizza with sausage
Look at the cheese side... oh wait. There isn't one.
Exterior
Cozy spot, friendly Bay View service.
Menu board Aug 23
the outside of a restaurant at night
Fun atmosphere
a stack of pizza boxes in front of a mural
Cheesy potatoes
Single monster slice
a half eaten pizza in a pizza box
Pesto Pizza
Garlic knots
I had no idea! Holy calzone Batman!
Meaty or non (vegan) slices!
Calzone!
Garlic Knots. So darn delicious.
Meatallica and Spicy Soppressata
Gluten free Top Gun pizza. Sooooo good!
The best gluten free crust! Soooo good!
Shippee Ahoy Pizza
I could NOT finish this! And I came on an empty stomach!
Take home slice!
Dina E.
Nov 16, 2024
Great pizza for vegans and vegetarians! This local Milwaukee neighborhood spot is a great place to grab a slice or a whole pizza. We stopped in and I was thrilled to see the vegan toppings offered which included soy cheese, vegan Italian sausage crumble and a huge vegetable selection! The restaurant is casual, offers wooden long tables, 4 top tables and window bar stool seating. The prices were reasonable and the pizza was thin and crispy and served hot. I would recommend Classic pizza for a quick lunch, dinner or to take a pie home for friends and family. They also serve salads which looked tasty. Street parking is available just outside of the restaurant.
Read More
Jen J.
May 20, 2024
Tried classic slice for the first time and it was pretty good! It was a great thin crust slice and they had plenty of options to choose from. I got my slice to go however they did have seating inside for dining in. While the pizza was good, it didn't have as much flavor as I would hope for. Additionally, it was a little expensive as this slice came in $9 for one slice. The slice was pretty big though. Not a top pizza place for me in Milwaukee but would recommend trying this place out!
Read More
Ophelia M.
Mar 25, 2024
Recently wandered into Classic Slice again and had to update!It's pretty much a pizza by the slice kinda place but you may not immediately realize this as there's not the typical case of visible pizza to choose from that's standard in most pizza by the slice spots. The good news is they make your slice fresh! The other good news is they have Detroit style pizza available. For the Detroit style, you'll order a full pizza (not a slice). It's delish! We got the cheese and it was all cheesy (with a nice bit of sauce above and below the cheese!) deliciousness.I also ordered their avocado salad which comes with golden beets, avocado, greens, and pistachios--it was fresh and delicious.The service is really lovely. Dig Detroit style pizza?Get to it!
Read More
Jessica G.
Nov 16, 2024
Amazing food. Amazing customer service. Late night hours. Delicious homemade ranch. Quick local delivery. I've never, ever had even a slightly bad experience here. Goooooo!
Read More
Amber B.
Aug 24, 2024
Such a fun little spot in Bayview area! Lots of options on the menu so even my kiddos were happy! Slices as big as their heads! Food was made fresh so there was a bit of a wait which was perfect because we had time to play some of their old school games they have. For being busier place they still answered all my questions and were friendly. The outside area is cute and inviting as well!
Read More
Char D.
Jun 20, 2024
Classic Slice will always be my "home alone and scary movie night" dinner! The Shipee Ahoy is one of the most flavorful pizzas that have ever blessed my taste buds. I have ventured out a few times, but can't stop from going back to my favorite! Love their homemade ranch!!The service is great- always on time with deliveries and have never messed up my order! It's done right and delicious every time. It's a typical and cool neighbor pizza place- and also a great stop for a late night snack for all the pizza cravings.
Read More
Allie E.
Aug 28, 2023
Hands down, best pizza in Milwaukee! Made fresh to order, with obvious love, don't skip this spot! Their garlic knots are so good it's almost sinful. From the hot handmade slices with all the toppings you could imagine, to the freshest burrata salad, nothing on this menu should be off limits. Great stop after any night out in Bay View. And the servers are always happy to see you. We'll be regulars for life at this one.
Read More
Ellie A.
Oct 5, 2024
Pizza was very greasy and cashier and expo people were downright rude. They had custom sodas (no Coke or Pepsi products) and the only hot sauce they had was sriracha. They had interesting appetizers that were good.
Read More
Alessandra V.
Oct 20, 2024
Ordered the golden beet salad, very yummy and pretty filling. Also got the square Sicilian slice and it was so good! Wait time wasn't bad either
Read More
Lincoln O.
Dec 17, 2024
Terrible service and pricing. $20 for 2 slices of pizza??? I thought it must be amazing pizza... nope. Very average. Took about 40 minutes for those 2 slices. All of the employees were moping around, no sense of urgency at all. Really pathetic service. Will never be back.
Read More
