Cinder's Charcoal Grill West

A great spot for char broiled burgers and steak sandwiches. Straight forward menu with burgers, steak sandwiches and other simple fare. Speedy service in a casual setting. Clean bathrooms and on site parking lot. Good value

Came here after not getting service from the Milwaukee Burger Company. Had to wait a few minutes, not a big deal. Seated at about 5:40. Next couple came in two minutes later and seated across from us. 6 minutes, waitress walked by us, and took the drink and app orders for the table that arrived after we did. If your front of the house lead isn't able to keep track of who came in first, then they don't need to be managing the front of the house. Again, another disappointment.

What can I say everyone knows about Cinders. Friendly service really good food. It's a excellent place to take the family to eat. Stop in get a steak sandwich. It's really nice and clean place to go to.

I've been here a couple times before with my other half while visiting his family in Wisconsin. Honestly, this time Cinder's was not as good as I remember but I gave them an extra star because the staff were all still wearing masks, gloves and sanitizer was available everywhere. Also because the other half's steak sandwich was reported to be pretty darn good. I was not so happy with my fish fry plate which should be stellar in Wisconsin. The perch was tasty but ridiculously minuscule. The shrimp tasted just OK but the haddock was good. The drawn butter and sauces were spot on. We will be back and I'll try Friday Fish Fry on an actual Friday.

Back in the early 90's my best friend in High School worked as a cook at Cinders. Unfortunately during that time period he passed in a fishing/boating incident. I moved from the area and 25+ years have passed since I've visited Cinder's. I returned to the area for a work conference and visited Cinder's once again. I so vividly remember spending an occasional evening at Cinder's with my friend after closing having a pitcher or two and just enjoying the particular time in our lives. He never wanted us to have too many because he didn't want to get in trouble with the boss. Miss my friend and those simpler times.On this visit the steak sandwich was as good as I remember from back in the day. They also now have bottomless fries with their sandwiches. (Bonus, the statute of limitations has most definitely passed on the few after hour pitchers I enjoyed with my friend while 18-19 yoa.

Perfectly filling It was a little weird that they put the lettuce/tomatoes on the side instead of directly in the burger haha, but the pattie was deliciously buttery! Heard that the steak burger is particularly good, so I'll have to try that at some point. Fries were great as well

We ended up stopping here after a night of errands and exhaustion that led to not wanting to cook. We spotted it on the side of the road while driving.Atmosphere: You seat yourself when you walk in. It kind of feels like an old diner vibe? A lot of booths and they can accommodate your group size, large or small. They have a grill station where you can watch the food be made.Service: REALLY great server. Super personable and heck, I just wanted her to sit down and hang out. I can't remember her name, but young with thick framed black glasses and short hair to her shoulders. Kept our water glasses filled and brought drinks over promptly.Food: COME HUNGRY. I seriously was ravenous when we arrived, and I STILL could not clear my plate. I ordered the chicken tenders, they hand bread them to order. They were alright, nothing that floored me. French fries were well cooked, could have used more salt. I loved the coleslaw that came on the side, great texture. The cheese curds are fresh, and you get a good portion size. My fiance got a burger and it was a really good size (a 1/3 lb.), he did not leave hungry either. The waitress hooked us up with extra pickles because I am obsessed with eating pickles.Good experience that we weren't really expecting since neither of us had been to a Cinder's before. 1 star for the food, and 2 stars for our amazing server

My dad and I sat down on a Friday afternoon at 2:15 and was not attended to by the server for 10 minutes. We got up and left, even after I to flag down a server by waving a menu, but I could not get her attention. There were, maybe, eight others in the restaurant at the time, spread out on three tables. Okay, there may have been only one server but that is the managements fault for not covering their business with enough personnel. Although I did see two cooks behind the lunch counter, not particularly doing anything at the time.

First let me say that I have been going to the several Mr. Cinder's Charcoal grills since the 1970s, 1st in Oshkosh. This is my first review of Cinder's, or any other Restaurant. I am 93 years old, so I have been eating fish for a while. Today at Cinder's, was absolutely the biggest disappointment I've had in many years. I ordered the seafood platter which ended up including popcorn shrimp, 1 miniscule, butterflied Pearch, 1 small piece of cod, and Potatoe salad. I did not eat the Pearch as it had strong, strange taste. The rest was tolerable, but far from what is normally expected. The price $27.59 + tax and tip for the platter and coffee. I did have an excellent waitress however, by the name of Heidi.

Steak sandwich and fries were great. Chicken tenders plate was not. The 4 tiny tenders were wayyyy overcooked, tasteless. The rye bread was stale. Fries and coleslaw good.A waitress ( not assigned to us) came to our table while we we were still eating, with food visible on her plates. She hovered over and said " Come on finish those fries so I can take your plates." Total turn off to be told what to do, and then rush us out of a nearly empty restaurant.$35.00 for 1 soda, 1 water, sandwich/fries and a lifeless chicken tenders plate. Multiple flies buzzed the table.