Cedarburg Popcorn Company

I had the pleasure of meeting the owner at the Grafton Ladies Night Out Pajama Party Event tonight. She and her team were one of the vendors in Main Street right near Colectivo. They came ready for business! They had a variety of products and could accept any version of payment your pajama clad self offered -- including Google pay!I had a good time laughing and exchanging jibs about Garrett's popcorn in my childhood hometown -- Chicago! I was told to try the "Chicago" label from this shop. I warily agreed and promised to write what I discovered!First, let me say! Garrett's is my all time FAVORITE!! I am one of those people who would stand in the line that wraps around the block for hours in the sub zero weather just to buy a bag of the cheesy caramel mix!I have to report, with a heavy heart ...I will not be driving to Chicago for Garrett's again! As the owner promised, this popcorn is wonderful! It was WI cheesy and the caramel made me feel all Christmasy sweet and buttery inside (and I don't celebrate Christmas)! I only wish I could have had this cheesey popcorn warm right out of the kettle. I can just imagine what THAT tastes like!I will definitely have to make a trip to Cedarburg to find this shop. In fact I'm going to have to walk there from Grafton so I can burn enough calories to earn the right to eat a bag of that popcorn right in the shop!

I love this adorable little popcorn shop! Tucked away behind Sal's Pizza, is the best popcorn in the Midwest!The staff is always so friendly and sweet. They are helpful and personable, which makes me feel appreciated. They sure know how to fill the plastic popcorn bag to it's fullest!They offer a ton of fun flavors and flavor combinations. I happen to love their plain, simple buttered popcorn. If you can make plain popcorn exciting, you are doing something right. And they certainly do that here. I don't live in the area but when I visit Cedarburg, Cedarburg Popcorn Company is my first stop. Then, when I'm leaving I pick up another bag to take home.

I am a total popcorn fan! My whole life I've loved popcorn and this popcorn is the absolute BEST!!!! Nothing compares to the Smash and Chicago blend! Taking my besties from Chicago here this weekend so they can experience the delicious popcorn made right here by the awesome owner! THANK YOU Cedarburg Popcorn Company!!!

FREE SAMPLES of all the flavors. Must go to place if you're in the area. Staff is very nice and they have very good prices for different sizes of popcorn to enjoy.

I loved all the fun flavors they had. There were samples of every flavor which was nice to try. I loved the banana pudding- taste just like the real thing! The owner (I believe) was very kind and told us about different flavors they were trying to make and suggestions. Glad we stopped into this shop :) prices not bad either for the unique flavors & yummy tastes!

What a gem of a popcorn store in Cedarburg! I was delighted to find this sparkling modern shop in the middle of Cedarburg's historic district. I will be ordering more online!The concept really sold itself, which let the owner concentrate on hand crafting small batches of popped perfection while helping customers, and a cashier running a checkout off an ultra-cool tablet/square point of sale system. In the center was a serve yourself popcorn bar, so visitors could sample different flavors. Then, you could travel over to the walls, make a selection from an assortment of savory and sweet samples, and head back to ring up your purchase.Savory included the standard cheese, in many flavors (I bought smoked cheddar and it was delicious) to the unique (make mine chili lime, I also saw a flavor with sriracha). Sweet? Think caramel corn on steroids. There were flavors ranging from chocolate, to root beer, to salted caramel (holy yum batman). At the checkout was the standard that set this popcorn shop over the top - a movie-theater style popcorn bar where you added the toppings! Fresh, hot liquid butter flavoring and seasonings. I put a shot of liquid gold on mine and topped it with a garlic salt. Amazing.Thanks for a terrific popcorn experience!

We stumbled off the beaten path and ended up on this adorable street in Cedarburg. They have a sea salt caramel that was very good as well as a puppy chow flavor that tastes like the real thing. I sampled a few (they have so many different kinds you couldn't try them all...some very unique...all very fresh) and had to go with the classic and get the mid sized bag of the orange and white cheddar cheese. I love the concept of self serve samples, they all tasted fresh and helped in the decision making process as there were very many flavors. They were grouped together...savory, sweet, etc. The man working who I assume was the owner said I could get warm and fresh if I was going to eat it right away. Well, why not? Although I didn't even make a dent because we then headed to Creme and Crepe Cafe, he even gave me a twist tie for later. My partner and I had such a good experience in this town we have added it to our list of potential weekend getaways.

Great, little popcorn shop. Love the fact that they have samples of all their flavors for you to try. Besides the standard types they had a few unique flavors, some worked and some not so much, but much of that was personal preference on my part-not a big fan of the overly sweet, "candied" popcorns beyond your standard caramel corn. I do laugh seeing all these popcorn shops imitate Garret's, in Chicago, by offering up their own "Chicago" mix-a mix of cheese and caramel corns. But hey, if it works (and boy does that combo work, as weird as it sounds) why not imitate it. Owners were really friendly and we enjoyed our experience in this fun, little shop.

Visited here while walking downtown with my family. While some of the flavors are "fun" some of them seemed a little too out there. Felt a little overwhelmed at the variety of flavors and felt like not all were made to the same standard. Wasn't greeted when i walked in which wasn't a big deal but made the worker seem lazy. A suggestion to the owner: Less is more. That being said love the decorations! So festive and cute. I however felt like this business seemed eerily similar to Broadway Popcorn which is not too far from here and is considerably cheaper

The Chicago Blend is better than Garret's in Chicago! Free samples let you try before you buy. Great place to visit in Cedarburg!