Castaway On Phantom

We wanted to try someplace new on a recent trip to the Elegant Farmer. We ate in the dining room which was nice. There was a separate bar room and it had a crew of people in their 20s and 30s who seemed to be having a great time. The bartender took our food order and another employee brought out the food when it was ready. I had the Italian beef sandwich which was tasty but the bun they used was one of the best I've ever had. My wife had the ribeye sandwich which she liked and our daughter had the cheeseburger that was huge. All of our lunches included crinkle cut fries which were delicious. The only downside was that there was a weird smell in the place.

It used to be called Oak Valley Resort back in the 1960's - I know because my family built it and I lived upstairs. Heard good things about the place now, but I have never been there.

Food was great.we had the fish fry. Drinks were very good. Service was great and they were very busy. The veiw of the lake and sunset was amazing.

One of the best Italian beef sandwiches I've ever had! Located right off Phantom lake, this seems to be a nice little local bar that's serving up some good food. Stopped in for some drinks and ended up ordering dinner just based on some of the plates I saw coming out of the kitchen. I had the Italian beef with cheese and mushrooms. Usually I'll order this without the au jus just because it can be sort of salty, but their is delicious and not overwhelmingly riddled with sodium. Bar area is pretty typical, it's nice that they have a parking lot and boat slips outside. Staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. Everyone from the bartender to the cook, who came out of the kitchen and chatted with me for a bit. Can't wait to go back!

Friendly new find in Mukwanago! A definite repeat visit for great food, live music on Sunday afternoon and warm atmosphere!

Stumbled on this lakeside fish fry and it was amazing!! The baked cod wasn't on the menu but they accommodated. They also have Mahi-mahi and seared tuna. The owners are from Hawaii...relaxed...surprising retreat from the midwest.

Wow ! Fantastic food. blackened mahi maji wrap was so good ! Service was exceptional- bartender was really cool & chef came out to check on us. Lasagna special was better than just about any place including a recent stop at a new place. Personal service- came out and checked if we wanted cheese on the garlic bread or just butter. And offered one piece of each. Would 100% recommend. The ambiance is really casual, bar / pub. Not fancy or pretentious. Best way to eat great food while hanging with good people. Castaway gets our vote for awesome place.

Great atmosphere with a low key vibe. Went in a Friday with acoustic music being played that wasn't too loud and great songs. We ordered the mani mahi wrap and cod sandwich and everything was amazing, especially for the price. I will drive the 30 minutes back to go eat again.

Our new favorite place for food and a good drink! The bartender/waitress, Amanda is a 10 out of 10! We walked in and she remembered us from another place and said "New Zealand" to my husband who is from New Zealand. She remembered meeting us and everything about us. The place overlooks the lake and has a relaxing vibe. The menu is amazing! I'm a vegetarian and my husband loves a good burger. We ended up having a great appetizer and shared a pizza. Everything is homemade and amazing.One of the owners, Barbara, came out and introduced herself and couldn't have been more welcoming! I feel with a lot of local places closing down...this will be the new place to go. Had a lovely evening and great meal at Castaway. Can't wait to bring my Ma and Grandma for a fish fry!Well done Castaway Team.. you have new locals. See you later for a fish fry.

Very bad drinks and food, fish fry very greasy and they were out of so many things. Drinks were very watered down