Caradaro Club

By far in the top 3 pizza places I have had in Milwaukee. The crust was perfectly crisp throughout and didn't have any sogginess in the middle. The pizza was perfectly seasoned. We were going to only eat half of the pizza and ended up eating the whole thing in one sitting because it was so good! I can't comment on the atmosphere of the restaurant since we got take out, but our pizza was ready right on time when we expected it to be.

Caradaro Club, the first pizzeria in Milwaukee is still making one of my top 3 picks for thin crust pizza in Milwaukee!I love the flavor of the sauce, cheese, and other toppings, I love the sound the crust makes when I take a bite, literally like biting into a cracker!The mozzarella Marinara is made with wonton wraps, and they are amazing, too! Note: the prices on their menu are outdated, so call to confirm prices when you order, or stop in to dine inside and you'll see the current prices posted.It's across from Wick Field and has a tea cup on the roof, and open Wednesday through Sunday evenings. Check them out!

I have literally tried to go here multiple times over the last 2 years and they are never are open. I check the website, I go during those hours. I call and they never answer. Mailbox is always full. There is never activity on Facebook so I'm not sure if when are closed or not but then I see others write reviews recently so they must be open.This was my dad's favorite pizza growing up and he's not been there in over 20 years but he still talks about it. He's 80 now and I just want to take him here one more time before it's too late. What gives!

Best thin crust pizza in MKE . Crispy flaky crust top with SMO - Sausage Mushrooms Onion, that's MKE style pizza. It so good. If your into thin crust , it's a must try when in MKE . Not only you'll learn a little bit of Pizza history but also leave satisfied.

This place was incredible! First and foremost the employees were amazing to chat with, Gary was so much fun. Also met the owner who came out to say hi. This place is a little small but can still hold 20 people inside. You can tell this place has been their for a long time and they know exactly what they are doing. The pizza was fantastic! This pizza made it into my top 5 easily of the best I've had. You need to try this place if you're around the neighborhood.

They have the best pizza and are always so welcoming. Prices are reasonable and the food and service are excellent.

Four stars for a pretty darn good traditional cracker crust pizza that they make at this Vliet Street store front. The location has both a front door and a patio style wide double-door store front that folds open to make the restaurant an open air experience during the summer.Honestly, the place feels and looks kind of divey, but in a good way. Yep, this is not a fine dining place, but it is kitschy and comfortable. It is a walk-in-with-shorts-tee type of place that you can take your kids.Seating wise, there are enough tables for about twenty-five dine-in patrons but, as I suspected, we noticed more take-out/to-go business than dine-in patrons.Parking is hit and miss on Vliet street depending on how busy the other businesses are.

Writing on behalf of my disabled father: absolutely delicious and the staff is amazing. They always bring out my pizza to my car since it is impossible to carry a pizza with a walker. Recently I had a health scare and when I told them that, the employee bought my pizza for me. I am a fan for life. HIGHLY recommend.

I haven't been to wyeast yet, but I think this is the best pizza in the uptown, Washington heights area. We started with Balestreris, which is great, but it gets a little soggy in the middle and it's definitely pricey. We had Bibis, which was not memorable. We like Lisa's but that's all the way on the east side. But my whole family prefers caradaro club: it's just great Tavern style pizza. The crust is thin, but stays crunchy! The sauce is just the slightest bit sweet, but still savory. They put the right amount of toppings, and the pepperonis are especially delicious. And... I like the guys who run it: straight up, no nonsense, Pizza OGs! I love the red and white decor, again old school status. If you visit, definitely get the fried breadsticks, everyone from grandma to my 2 year old loved them, who doesn't love fried dough with butter and garlic

Outstanding old school pizza !!! The the sauce is to die on the pizza !!! Great service order from them 3 or 4 times a month !!!