Mouthwatering Specialty Food in Milwaukee

BUBS SUBS

★★★★★ 4.5 (316) • $

"This place never disappoints, the best sandwiches in the area. The ingredients are always fresh and meats top class. Both the cold and grinders choices exceptional. Always greeted by staff with a friendly hello, kudos their attention to detail while making your sandwich shows. It's as you get the prefect sandwich as though you made it yourself (adding more or less vegetables and condiments) . Your first bite into the sandwich matches exactly what you expected it to taste like.Also the potato salad is very good too. Place is clean tables available. Great alternative to fast food hamburgers and chicken."

The Elegant Farmer

★★★★☆ 3.8 (236) • $$

"I've been here twice now around apple picking season and it is an absolute joy! I have loved every experience here.The parking lot is easy to navigate and while it's on the grass, it's well marked with plenty of spots. They have free entry into the apple orchards and you can pay for added fun like a hay ride or to go into the corn maze. We opted for just apple picking and picked up a 1/2 peck bag and their print out guide of what color ribbons go with which apples.My friends and I had so much fun exploring the grove, trying apples, climbing trees and ladders and taking photos while filling our bag with our favorite apple varieties. My personal favorites are the Cortland and Crispin apples. They are sweet, juicy and beautiful. I ended up mostly getting these varieties but others we enjoyed were the Jonathan, Macoun, McIntosh and Ida Reds. On our visit there were thirteen varieties available. My 1/2 peck was $15- a steal when you include the fun of picking and exploring the grounds.It was really cool to see couples, families, friends and more out enjoying apple picking and there was plenty of space where it didn't feel too crowded.Across from the apple picking is the real shopping, they have an indoor market as well as a smaller food court area that does some items and caramel apples.The store has everything you could imagine from coffee and cocoa to honey roasted ham, fresh pies baked in paper bags and cheese curds. I even bought some dog treats to bring home to Oslo.It's easy to stock up on your seasonal favorites or shop locally for gifts.My friends and I had so much fun and will have amazing memories long after our apples and pie are eaten."

Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli

★★★★★ 4.5 (74) • $

"tl;dr - the shop of your childhood dreams that you can now enjoy as an adult!This review comes from someone who has a very intense/serious relationship with peanut butter (using it with apples, pretzels, for sandwiches and even with mini chocolate bars) so finding a good place with good peanut butter is a God sent. You can choose from peanut butter, honey-roasted peanut butter, almond butter, cashew button or peanut butter& dark chocolate (yum!)For the other part of your sandwich, jellies, jams, butters, salsas and even more line the walls. It's like the "Willy Wonka" site of fruit-based spreads.The nut butters are all made in house at the shop and you can purchase any jars of the butters, jams and jellies to take home.You can build your own or go with the already tried and tested signature sandwiches - my favorite included: The King (PB with sliced bananas and honey and you can add bacon), Strawberry Lovers (PB, strawberry jam and fresh strawberries - I also added Nutella) and PBJ Quesadilla (flour tortilla with choice of PB, jam/jelly, fresh fruit.)The additional toppings you can add gets wild, too - like I mentioned bacon, to jalapenos, to pickles, to Sriracha, to mallow creme is all of the docket. The owner is also super warm and friendly and talked with us for a quiet a while during our first visit. Great customer service.ALERT - it is only open Tuesday-Sunday from 10 am to 3 pm - sorry no late-night PBJ runs, however, it does have free wifi available which is a big draw during the daytime if you have to work remotely."

VOM FASS

★★★★☆ 4.2 (41) • $$

"Excellent quality vinegars, oils, and liquors--can seem like a splurge but an excellent selection for either your home or gifts.Oils and vinegars are decanted into the bottle size of your choice. You can either purchase bottles at the store or bring your own bottles. Using up your cooking oils and vinegars at home and then bringing your clean bottles is a great way to save money here. Staff will label your bottles and gift wrap anything you like free of charge. Need to get a gift in a hurry? Buy a packaged gift set or make your own.You can taste anything in the store except bottled wine. The vinegars can be very creative, I enjoyed the honey basalmic vinegar as a slightly sweeter alternative. Huge liquor selection as well, including an excellent whiskey and scotch selection (the only thing really lacking is tequila). Some Wisconsin products are represented.I bought a cream liquor and it was slightly chunky, which doesn't mean it'll make you sick, but aesthetically unattractive, and the staff immediately replaced the bottle. Replace your oils and vinegars here!"

Carrie's Crispies

★★★★★ 4.9 (12)

"I have purchased Carrie's Crispies on three separate occasions, including this afternoon. They make awesome gifts for coworkers, friends, and families. They have a variety of flavors and the vast majority of them are gluten-free. They often have seasonal flavors, including root beer float, pineapple mai tai, and strawberry margarita this summer. Both Carrie and her husband, Brian, are really sweet people. Support small businesses!"

Crafty Cravings & Cafe

★★★★★ 4.8 (5)

"Love this place. The best breakfast burrito. Ask for it panini style. The sausage gravy is made on site. More than a cafe they also have art and a sweet selection of retro candies. Invite a friend and play a game of cribbage while you enjoy your meal. Great place and the owner's could not be nicer!"

Toy's Ethnic Grocery

★★★☆☆ 2.8 (4) • $$$

"Toy's is an undervalued gem in Sheboygan. The food is very affordable and very good. The restaurant space is tiny, with no bells and whistles, but the staff are friendly and helpful.There are meat and vegetarian options available to suit all. Impressive authenticity can be found here. Check it out."