The Yummiest Candy Stores in Milwaukee

Very inviting place with colorful decorations. Eighties music in the background. Great place for both adults and kids. Serves homemade ice cream, candies, cookies and malts. Delicious flavors and generous portions. Server was helpful and efficient especially when there was a line. If I'm ever back in town, I'd be sure to stop by.

Can't believe we waited almost a whole year to check out this little sweet shop. They have homemade fudge, ice cream, truffles, and loads of other goodies.We tried the heath and cookie dough fudge and it was amazing. The flavors were spot on with a creamy velvety texture. We had some self control when we stopped in today and didn't purchase any fudge but definitely will in the future.The ice cream we got was very good. I really enjoyed the spumoni. The peach I tried was light and refreshing. My husband loved the moose tracks.The best part about this shop was the service. Both women working today were so kind and friendly. They were eager to help and provided samples. Excellent all around. I can see why they've been in business 20 years.

The best ice cream you'll ever have! The first time I was here, I had the Elvis ice cream, which was banana & peanut butter. It was fantastic. The Mint Chip is also outstanding! If you like rich chocolate, they have award winning chocolate ice cream! They have homemade fudge & chocolate goodies too. The peanut butter cups are definitely worth a second look. Everything is priced really fairly! Their staff is really kind & always willing to give samples of everything! They also have food recommendations!

WOW! We stopped in here after spending an hour or so at the Lake Geneva museum today. My 2 young kids were indecisive like all kids are, so the young lady making the popcorn let us all try any flavor we wanted to help us decide. We had a lot of samples! In reading some earlier reviews about the cleanliness and professionalism of the staff. We were greeted very warmly the minute we stepped in and my 3-year old was a bit on the cranky side so she dealt with that well too! We had a completely different overall experience than the person wrote from earlier this year. The walls were perfectly in order, stocked with all bagged popcorn flavors and candy. Floors and counters were clean. They also had a beautiful display of gourmet candies to the side of the check-out counter, above it which listed also their ice cream offerings and prices. They had all their various tins with many patterns to choose from on the top shelves. My kids enjoyed watching fresh carmel corn being stirred up behind the counter. She even let us sample the fresh/warm popcorn. The lady was a great sales person, that is for sure. We walked in thinking we'd buy a small bag for the kids to share and we ended up walking out with a 2-pound tin tub, plus an extra bag of cheesy bacon pizza popcorn. We paid around $30, which really was a good price if you look at Garrett's prices! Plus, the lady told us that we could bring the empty tin back anytime (no expiration) and get it refilled with a discount - I think she said 15%. I liked that we were able to get 3 different flavors to fill up the tub. She filled it to the rim too. The tub seems to hold at least 7 of the large bags that were sold individually. My favorite was the 3-cheese that had white chedder, parmesan and I 'think' just regular cheddar. It melts in your mouth. So good! We were just there a couple of hours ago and I think I am half way through this third of the tin. We might need to refill the tin before heading home from Lake Geneva in a couple of days. My kids liked the carmel/cheese that was seedless (tastes like Cap N' Crunch cereal) and a white chocolate one. I might need to have some shipped to me during the year as this popcorn is seriously addicting! My mom is sitting in front of me as I am typing this and she is eating some of the popcorn, and she just said this stuff is so addicting. Agreed!

Stopped in here while waiting for dinner next store at Balistreri's. We were thankful that Ultimate Confections was open later on a chilly Saturday night, as there's no shortage of amazing confections here!Picked up some cashew clusters and fairy food for dessert. The cashiers were delightful, and were very respectful and helpful to some smaller kids they were helping. Ice cream on hand, too. There's a wait at Balistreri's? Alright!

What a great store to discover in a small town outside of Milwaukee. It is worth a trip up to Teresa to visit this place, and to visit the city itself. Teresa was also founded by one of the founders of Milwaukee. This store has such a variety of Confections, but it also has great food and ice cream. Service is quick and the staff was really friendly and positive. I look forward to visiting again, and they have a great listing of menu sandwiches and more..

Very cute shop! Have been twice, once to eat in and another time to carry out. Food was delicious! While waiting for your food you can ponder the ice cream selections, paletas, cheesecakes and candy offerings to figure out what you will get for dessert!

Bought a Groupon for Becky's Blissful Bakery a few weeks ago. Stopped by the other day to notice they are only open from 9am-1pm on Saturdays or by appointment. Stopped in today to buy some caramels which is their specialty. A tiny little place - mainly just the space to make the caramels. There were samples to try and the employees were extremely friendly.I ended up with the Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels and the Champagne Caramels. Super yum to both of them! They are soft and delicious. I will be going back for more. Quite a few more flavors to try as well.Looking forward to the business doing well and opening up for more hours in the future.