Brothers Gyros & Pizza

Was a little confused when I walked in. Some people ordered from counter while others sat and were waited on. I took the counter approach and I think either way works well. The staff were extremely friendly. The chairs and tables felt a little like outdoor furniture and the floors were greasy. I did leave smelling like I cooked in the kitchen. This being said I'm still not sure how I feel about the dine in experience.The gyro was stuffed full of meat and tasted fantastic. The tzatziki was thick but flavorful and the tomatoes and onions fresh.I was hoping for a small side but the only choices were fries and salad. Anything else was listed as an appetizer. I wanted onion rings so had to opt for the larger appetizer option. Onion rings were crispy with a beer batter, a little greasy but not soggy. They were good but not sure I'd go that route again. Overall lots of options on the menu including burgers,sandwiches, salads, and pizza. I'll return to try more and to support the very friendly staff.

So I was told by many people check out brothers for the best gyros in the city and boy let me tell you I was not disappointed. I came on a random Saturday morning and met the owner who talked about how he honored his son by having the restaurant painted purple for his sons favorite color. It was really amazing hearing all about this family owned Greek restaurant. Let me tell you, that original gyro was stuffed to the max with the most delicious flavorful gyro meat that was enough for three separate meals along with a ton of tomatoes and onions and a soft pita bread that truly was a great combo along with some spicy sriracha and homemade tzatziki sauce. It's truly my favorite Gyro place to go to from here on out in Milwaukee and it's a must try! Will have to try their gyro platter next time!

New Favorite!We were on the hunt for fast casual greek eats a few months ago, wanted to try something new, and stumbled upon Brothers Gyros & Pizza. Our experience from beginning to end was outstanding.We entered to find the restaurant neat and sparkling clean. Though they definitely have fast casual vibes (even a drive thru!), when they discovered we were dining there, we were seated and provided menus. So, a nice touch that folks dining in don't have to order at the counter. They also bring your food right to your table--lovely.Their falafel sandwich is ample and bursting with flavor. Their greek fries are spot on perfect--not too much lemon, herbs, and ample fresh and flavorful feta. The service is warm and friendly. Seriously, what's not to love?Get to it!

We got the Special Giannis plate and gyro plate both come with a hefty side of rice, Greek salad, pita and tzatziki! We also got the hummus and pita appetizer. Best fast casual Greek food we have had in Milwaukee. The chicken and gyro meat was tender and the pita was very soft and paired well with the hummus and tzatziki.

Want a gyro? Yes, come to this place. Drive thru, order/pickup or dine in. Clean, so very friendly- and fresh and delish food.The gyros are so good that it's hard to order anything else. Salads are big, nice veggies, great dressing- Fries - hot and so so good. My husband always says we can share- but really, just order your own (the basket is big enough to share- if you're into that).Refills on Coke products (yes!)Can place an order and wait or just sit down and they'll come and take your order.

This place is a hidden gem. Their gyro meat is delicious. I get the Gyro Bowl everytime. It's enough for 2-3 servings. I always have leftovers. My husband and kids loves their Greek Fries. The staff is always polite. Service is quick. This took over the old Honey Dip Donut location so it's a nice spot in a prime location.

I had a craving for Greek food, and yelp showed me the way. This place is off the beaten path, but well worth finding it. Staff is very attentive and accommodating. I ordered a gyro, fries and a Greek salad. It was delicious! The food tasted great and prices were very reasonable. The restaurant and dining area were clean and very well-managed. The service was impeccable. Definitely recommend it. I will definitely be back!

It's "only" been 2.5 years since my initial visit, and I regret that so much. Like last time, I ordered a plain gyro, but unlike last time, the pita was not greasy. The meat is outstanding; arguably the best gyro meat I've had in terms of texture and flavor. Even without ordering extra meat in the gyro I feel like there was a generous amount. I also ordered wonton mozzarella sticks, which are fabulously battered in addition to being wonton wrapped.I've always held Oakland Gyros and Golden Gyros on a pedestal as the best gyros in Milwaukee. Both will need to move over and make room for Brothers Gyros on that pedestal.

I come here for gyros every time I come to Wisconsin. 4th time here and I can confidently say these are the best gyros I've ever had. They should be very proud of their business, the entire family that runs their business is courteous and polite and their Greek gyros are second to none. If you're in the area and craving gyros come here, the portions are huge and quality is fantastic. Would give em 6 stars if I could. Well done and look forward to coming back next time I'm in Wisconsin

I only came in to order to-go, and I felt underdressed, lol! This place is clean, and bright, and has a welcoming vibe to it. I saw what looked like marble in a lot of places and thought, "OOOO, swanky!".The food is delicious. My husband wasn't that impressed, but his loyalties lie elsewhere. He was willing to try this place out, and will eat from here again, but it's not his favorite.I love me some gyros, and Avgolemono! All of it here was sooo good, and my only complaint was that the soup had just a smidge too much lemon in it. That won't stop me from getting it again, as I don't know if that is standard for this place, or just a one-off.The little drive up window near the walk in entrance cracks me up, and I was confused the first time I had to use it, but it makes sense, once you've done so.This place is pretty close to my house, so I am happy that I don't have to drive too far when I need a Greek fix. 5 stars for that alone, but the food is worth it too!31/2024