Blue Star Cafe

If I could give this place six stars, I would (and I've never said that in a review before)! Everything was absolutely delicious, the service was great, and the atmosphere struck the perfect balance of casual and fitting for the location. Plus, they have menu options you can't find just anywhere in Milwaukee. I knew I wanted to try a sambusa, so I went for the beef one, and it did not disappoint. The peas inside added a great texture, the outside was perfectly crispy, and I'm obsessed with the green sauce they pair it with. Based on the counter staff's recommendation, I also tried the Somali-style steak sandwich. It's like he read my mind--I loved it. The chopped steak was tender and packed with flavor, and the bread--wow! So soft and delicious. I also tried Vimto soda for the first time! My friend thought the chicken Suqaar sandwich was a must-order too. To top it all off, the owner checked in on us and was so friendly and kind. It made the experience feel extra personal and welcoming. Plus, the prices were incredibly reasonable. This is definitely a hidden gem I want to keep to myself but also share with everyone, because no one should miss out on this bite!

Every time i go to this place it does not disappoint!! reasonable pricing and good portion sizes!! my favorite is their salmon sandwich, chai drink, and sambusas of course. the staff is always so friendly and willing to talk to you. my go-to place when i want something tasty!!!

Friendly welcome as we entered, quick and kind service. The food was amazing. Highly recommend the samosas and the beef and basmati rice!

Ordered Lamb with Rice, got two black short hairs, but it didn't look like they were from the head. The food itself wasn't bad.

Small causal spot nothing fancy. But the food is good and plentiful. I had the Goat plate. Loved the yellow rice, meat was tender and flavorful. That Samosa with the Jalapeno sauce was amazing.

Finally made it over to Blue Star Cafe on a Sunday night less than 1 hour before closing but so glad that we did!! Their kitchen had closed so they only had available what was already cooked which was chicken and goat, so we tried one platter of each. Both were flavorful and fresh tasting. I really wanted to try the hummus but they were done making it for the day so I will have to come back. Large portion sizes and quick service from the family that owns it, and they were very kind and apologetic about not having their kitchen open late even though they did not need to be. Great hole in the wall spot that feels comfortable, laidback, and clean to dine in but also has quick service for takeout

A cute and casual little restaurant with amazing food and lovely owners. Super filling and very affordable. I usually have a few meals from one platter so it's a steal. Will be back

Love the ambiance of this small diner and the food is amazing. The Somalian rice dish is abfab and their fish is drool-y delicious.

The staff were so friendly and the food was amazing. Great value !!!I would definitely go out of my way to go back I had a platter meal and the meat was very tender and flavorful

Get a shovel. A fork can't deliver the sublime tastes fast enough. We did takeout and got the Somali-style steak over rice, the salmon over rice and a side of veggies. All were flavorful, perfectly textured and generously portioned. And cheap! It's a joy to discover a somewhat hidden gem. Blue Star really delivers.