Blue Bay Restaurant

Only have had breakfast/brunch here. Was very good. Staff is friendly & attentive. Seating consists of booths or tables. Reasonably priced. Came here for Easter brunch last year and was excellent! Very accommodating place to come with children.

(Make that 2 1/2 stars.) Our local favorite--Fork in the Road--happens to be closed on Sundays and Mondays, so we implemented "Plan B," namely Blue Bay. Their George H. W. Bush-era décor begs to be updated, but otherwise this family-friendly diner appears reasonably neat and clean. Blue Bay's enormous menu features unapologetically retro diner classics that hark back to the era when a 1/2 lb. burger plated with cottage cheese was actually considered healthy. The wonderful servers and remarkably inexpensive prices are the obvious draw. But, you literally get what you pay for--average quality food. Our sandwiches were okay but did not rise above ordinary. Cooked-to-order items, e.g. breakfast dishes, deep-fried, and grilled or griddled items, seem to be the best bets here. Some entrées looked and tasted as though they had been prepared in large batches much earlier in the day. The kitchen has a heavy hand with the gravy ladle. Swedish meatballs--described by a server as "one of our most popular items" arrived ... brace yourself ... drenched in a dreadful gloppy Alfredo sauce (Italian/Swedish fusion?). Spaghetti & meat sauce was proportioned 1/3 pasta to 2/3 sauce. Mashed potatoes were awash in a sea of insipid beige gravy.Dessert? You guessed it ... tapioca or rice pudding, ice cream, and cheesecake. We ordered the cheesecake and spumoni (dessert came with our meals). Both were forgettable.

The servers are always decent and the food portions are quite large! It's exactly how you would imagine a classic American diner. I go with my family when I come back from college and we enjoy it every time. Would recommend their breakfast stuff like the skillets, eggs benedict, and swedish pancakes

I always enjoy the food when I come here. They have a very large selection of food. The service is always amazing. Not to mention the interior design is elegant and very beautiful. It has a very nice consistent theme to it as well. I would recommend this restaurant.

How do I give ZERO stars.Food was absolutely horrible, for a greek inspired menu/restaurant who serves a gyro in tin foil, to be honest I wouldn't even call this a gyro, it looked like processed package meat (most likely frozen) not sliced off the spit. Not served with tzatziki, I had to ask the server multiple times for it. When I got it looked curdled and tasted disgusting. Soup was served cold, wifes chicken wrap was rubbery...the service was one of the worst experiences we've ever had in a restaurant. We make it a point to tip very well and take care of our servers however, we had to get up get our own napkins, hot sauce, flag down another server to order drinks. we will definitely not be back! Were enroute to the Elegant Farm for lunch and decided to stop here. Mistake!

Great breakfast spot! Skillet was amazing, fast and fabulous service!! Typical breakfast spot.

Don't judge this place on the outside or the inside because the decor is out dated and so is the inside. It's like walking into grandma's living room. The food however is a wide variety of classic breakfast foods and everything was good. It is a large restaurant and have never had to wait. Able to accommodate larger groups as well!

Best pancakes I've ever had! Also the service was wonderful. Everyone who works here was so welcoming.

Food was OK. Best service ever! My waitress obviously had trouble walking, but gave me much better service than a lot of other servers. What a joy to spend a half hour with an attentive waitress.

The service isn't always the best, but the food is decent. It's a good stop for a quick breakfast.