Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante
Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante
Not much sausage on that slice
The crust
closed sign
the dining area
two people sitting in a restaurant
The crust, one piece of sausage on the right slice
compact disc machine
a christmas display
Dirty floors
outside
salads, outside
No sausage on the lower left of the pizza
Disgusting pizza
The Bible ... I mean the menu
Menu Sept 2022
Menu Sept 2022
outside
Burnt cheese pizza
Back dining area
Who says Italian food isn't healthy? Italian salad for the win.
Skimpy unevenly placed sausage and cut funny, what's with the one inch slice on the right side. 4 left slices have 2 sausages
outside
outside
Michael M.
Nov 2, 2024
Terrible service. They said whether I ate in or ordered to take out it would take the same amount of time. I'm still sitting here 1-1/2 hours later while people who have eaten have been seated, eaten and left. Very rude. Won't be back.
Read More
Julia A.
Apr 24, 2024
Went to Balistreri's for a little pre-Easter celebration with my family. As always, an absolute delight of a place to eat. Although busy the servers were very upfront with how long food was taking and offered to start with drinks and apps. We all got drinks and I ordered the French onion soup for the first time - wow so delish! Was able to share with a couple family members and we all agreed it was well done. We also shared some Cesar salad and a large pizza. Plenty for all and well enjoyed by all!
Read More
Kerr H.
Nov 13, 2024
I always come here on holidays. I come here for my birthday my children's birthdays I love this place. I love the food. Everything is great. The service is excellent and it is such a nice calm place to be in. I will continue to go here. I give this place A+
Read More
Tim D.
Oct 14, 2024
Absolutely love the Pizza! Always tasty and it has become a tradition to bring guests here to enjoy the pizza, people and the cozy atmosphere! Great crust, good sauce I order extra sauce because it's just so good! Never disappointed and always fill when I leave!!!
Read More
Wendy A.
Apr 6, 2024
Classic Italian, generous portions, good service. My favorite to order anywhere, Eggplant Parmesan, is an excellent choice.
Read More
Steven T.
Nov 5, 2022
I knew a guy who used to always rave about the pizza from this place so I decided to stop by for lunch today. The place is small and cozy looking with a U shaped dining room. It's only tables and chairs by the way so no romantic booths. Service was slow but they were busy for lunch and pizza take out never stopped. I ordered the cheese and sausage which took about 20 minutes and looked good when it finally arrived. It had the quintessential cracker thin crust that was sliced unevenly with this one inch slice on the right side of the pizza. The sausage was on the skimpy side and unevenly placed so it's basically one piece sausage on each slice and a slice or two had no sausage, see my pictures. The crust was thin and crispy and I felt once again it needed a little more sauce and cheese compared to other pizza places around town.Overall the pizza was good but it's poorly executed compared to other places around town In I thought.
Read More
Nabila M.
Jan 19, 2023
Best pizza spot around. I've come here a handful of times and have never been disappointed. Also recommend balistreris on bluemound which is a nice restaurant while this spot is a very laid back small restaurant. Its always extremely busy here a lot of people come in for pick up. I recommend their garlic bread. Seriously the best garlic bread I've had at a pizza joint. For pizza we've had the Hawaiian and traditional sausage mushroom and olives. Crunchy thin crust it's truly addicting. Definitely stop by!
Read More
Kim W.
Dec 27, 2024
Decide to stop pick up dinner after running a few errands and after a very long Christmas week this what got once I came home . For $26 bucks o expect some better than this . Where's to my cheese . I ordered a large sausage pizza with extra sausage . And this what I got thanks a lot Happy New Year !!! Not enough cheese
Read More
Steven B.
Dec 8, 2024
Been going here for 50 yrs,live in neighborhood, and was nvr disappointed until fri dec 6. My wife and I split the Sicilian steak and I had the conch salad. The conch salad had less than half the usual amt of conch on it. The Sicilian steak was way over cooked,almost black,vey dry. Looked nothing like the pic on website.I ate my half of the steak because I was hungry,my wife didn't eat any. Service was good,when I told the waiter abt our concerns,he said he would talk to mgr and try to work with us on the bill. He came back and said he spoke to the Mgr and he refused to help us, or even talk to us, even tho he was at the host station as we pd our bill,shame on you! He nvr even said 1 word to me. Not what I expect and will think twice abt going again or recommending to anyone else.Hope it was worth it for you!
Read More
M H.
Oct 6, 2024
The best thin crust pie in MKE. Old school, family sit down restaurant!My fav. Post Brew Crew stop!
Read More
