Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette

My second trip to Allie Boy's was even better than the first. My dining companion opted for another bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on an everything bagel, while I went for an iced matcha latte with almond milk and chocolate babka. The quality of everything we ordered was outstanding. My remarks about the bagel sandwich from my previous review still stand, and the chocolate babka was tender and decadent without being overly sweet. The matcha latte isn't quite coffee house quality, but it was still refreshing with a touch of sweetness to nicely balance the earthy taste typical of matcha. Service was quicker this time around. Our order was ready within just a few minutes. It was a little crowded in there (still not a place I'd hang around to try to get work done), but we found a comfortable spot by the windows again. If you're looking for a quality breakfast sandwich and a solid pastry, definitely give Allie Boy's a try.

I thought I already wrote a review because I knew I loved them after the first time there. I hadn't been to NYC yet and my bestie took me here for lunch. She said, they are just as good, probably better than any bagel place in New York. We both got pastrami on rye bagels and holy shit was it so good. Not only do I love sandwiches but I also love bagels. And brining those two together was perfection. They have amazing toppings, great specials, and delicious cream cheeses. Since then I have ordered a few times to go. I have never eaten inside however I have been in there. Seating is limited but I think people get a lot of to goes anyways. They have two locations now, I have yet to go to the farwell location so that one could be bigger! Service is fast and friendly. And after visiting NYC this past month, I can say, for myself anyway, that Allie Boy's is better than any bagel I had in NYC. We had bagels every day and tried the hot spots and waited in long lines for bagels. Allie Boy's really knocks it out of the park. I'm taking two of the NYC girls trip tomorrow and I can't wait to see them fall in love!

5 stars all the way. Don't be alarmed by the wait because the food will be well worth it. If you're a local there's a few ways around the wait but you'll have to figure those out. Everyone is always kind and friendly.

Came here for the first time on a Saturday morning. Have been trying to find the best bagels in town! Place was very busy. We ordered coffees and a sesame bagel with the labneh spring herb cream cheese. Price: expensive. I paid 17 dollars for a regular coffee and a bagel.. a little disappointing. The sesame Bagel itself was tasty however the cream cheese filling is extremely thick and excessive. Honestly a waste. We ended up taking over half of it off. Also the labneh spring herb was extremely salty.. I couldn't tolerate it. I would come back if having the cream cheese on the side is an option or asking for it light. And i would hope to try another spread that isnt this salty... Also keeping in mind if i want to splurge for breakfast since it is a little pricey.

Still 5 stars for sure. Had to update this to say that I've really been enjoying trying new things when I go here. This weekend I went TWICE bc I loved the gingerbread (bagel of the day) was so amazing. Also tried the tahini black and white cookie - WOW. I was most blown away by the yogurt of all things - really creative toppings and beautiful flavors.

Just a touch off the beaten path in Walker's Point, this place proves you don't have to go to Chicago or New York for a great bagel sandwich. The vibes in this place is one where I could see myself working the day away and stuffing myself with bagels. I looked around for something to complain about and... I can't find it.

Allie Boy's popularity speaks for itself. If you go on a weekend morning, I hope you aren't in a hurry because lines are typically out the door. Luckily, you can place an order online ahead of time, so you don't have to wait in line and then wait for your sandwich to be made, which can sometimes mean 30-40 minute waits (still worth it, but something to keep in mind). Something unique that Allie Boy's does that I love is offering a hashbrown in your bagel sandwich--to which I'd recommend always saying yes! They also always usually have a special bagel or cream cheese to choose from, such as this weekend's Hot Buttered Shrimp Toast Bagel or last weekend's Caramel Apple Swirl cream cheese. Seating is limited inside of the National location, but there's a patio out back with a few fires to sit around if it's a chilly day.

What an amazing bagel shop! It's very cute and it has seating inside although not that big but I noticed a good amount of people order to go. They have a great selection of breakfast sandwiches and bagels with spread I had an everything bagel with plain cream cheese and it was so delicious. I will definitely trying their breakfast bagels next time.They do not have a parking lot so street parking will be your best option.

Great stop on a Friday morning. I had a City Tin burning a hole in my pocket and have wanted to try this place for a while. I ordered a breakfast sandwich on an everything bagel with sausage and it was delicious. It was also plenty for 2 with the portions. Also got the pickles and they tasted fresh and homemade. Perfect vinegar kick. The iced coffee wasn't anything special but the barista made everything with care. Their everything seasoning has a little something different to their blend so recommend trying it for a new experience. The staff were friendly and doing their best to get the orders out. Probably waited about 5-10 for my sandwich and 1/2 dozen bagels to go, but again, worth it.

You know a place is good when the line is out the door. Went on a Sunday morning and did have to wait around 30 minutes before getting our food but I now know you can order ahead! Bagels were phenomenal, my friend and I got the bacon egg and cheese and the sausage egg and cheese with the added hasbrown on both. Everything bagel was very flavorful and crispy too. Their bagel of the day was blueberry and I would definitely come back for one of those.