5 O'Clock Club

This was our first visit, on a Thursday night. The menu is very different depending on the day of the week so be aware of this and check their online menu when you make your reservation. It also appears they offer a fish fry on more days than just Friday. The location is very secluded, nestled in beautiful trees and a minor view of Pewaukee Lake, and has both inside and outside tables. Unfortunately, we asked for an outside table on this warm night but were told they didn't have the staff to make it happen. On our way out there were people dining outside so that was disappointing. Our server Michelle and busser Tea did a great job and even tho they were both super busy we were well taken care of.Being a Thursday night we had some interesting options including the specials. We decided to try the Ribeye with veggies and a baked potato and it was delicious and a good size serving. We also ordered the full rack of Ribs and that was different. They were well cooked but the sauce was more tomato paste than BBQ sauce taste. While it wasn't bad it was not as visually pleasing and did not taste as expected. This is a personal preference so if you like a hardy BBQ sauce please ask for a taste test before ordering to make sure it will meet your expectations. (The special Beef Ribs roasted had a different and non-BBQ sauce, so be sure to test that one also. It didn't interest me so I avoided it.) The french fries served were all over the place in being cooked, but that's because they were all different sizes from tiny and crispy to large and limp.There is a large drink menu to choose from and the servings are nice. However, we were too full to have one of the tasty-looking desserts. All in all our bill for two women was just over $103 before tips. Not bad for the amount of food served but each dish was a bit of a surprise. We will probably try again because the service was excellent and there are more items we would like to try. But it was not a night to remember, just one to eat out and take home leftovers.The decor is typical supper club style but somehow the room is not too dark. And even tho they have just celebrated their 95th Anniversary, the atmosphere is not old, but more traditional. Lots of windows is nice.One thing to know is that the staff has been here forever; our server for over 25 years, and a long-standing staff speaks well of the owners/management. Many generations have held this Club and you can tell they care. Give it a try and judge for yourself. I think it is worth it.

Came for lunch. It was very busy but all the food was great! Got mozzarella sticks and onion rings were nice and crispy with minimal grease. Hamburger was huge! Got the shrimp and they were great as well. The grandmas kitchen salad was amazing and HUGE! We sat outside on the patio and it was a nice atmosphere. Would definitely come back!

OMGGGG!!!!! What is there not to like!!!!? Drink's plenty keep them flowing. We love this place. Old fashioned Friday fish fry. DELICIOUS!!! SUNSET AWESOME!!! It feels like you are 2 hours north of Milwaukee. Lake county is beautiful!!!! Sun setting over lake Pewaukee...Okay I need to admit I've had 6 old fashioned before I sat down at the table but that's how good the drinks are!!! Baked Cod yum yum yum. You want to know a secret? Twelve old fashioned's two glasses of wine a Shirley temple less than $80 dollars what a deal! Food fast and hot service awesome these people are busting ass to make sure their clientele is happy Happy Happy Ok food has arrived now let's taste test. First grab French fry yes hot out of the fryer no time under the warming lights. Baked cod. Yummy fried cod. Yummy Walleye yum yum All five meals perfectly prepared Grandpa here was going to give them 4 stars because of the popularity wait. But my granddaughter said the butter noddles are out of this world and they need to get 5 stars. Please grandpa. You know i can not disappoint. So 5 stars it is!!!Not a lot of breading and not greasy but definitely a lot of fish!!Great tarter sauce!!! Yum yum yum like Luigi in the packman game gobble it all up

Best perch fish fry in Wisconsin! Get there before 5 or you'll have a long wait! They offer Wed. fish fry also!

Awesome breaded mushroom and Jim was a sweetheart! Great atmosphere Very close to the water!

The best steakhouse in the area in my opinion. Service is top notch and the owner is very friendly and always present. Great to see! I've never had a bad experience.

Was in the area and my cousin invited me for a Friday Fish Fry. The setting is back off the road but has plenty of parking. Friday nights appear to be extremely popular so expect a wait, which we did not mind as we had not seen each other in about 4 years so it gave us time to catch up (noise level allowed this with now problem). We were a party of 8, and when we were brought to the table it was set with the cole slaw (VERY GOOD vinegar based) and bread. Our server was prompt and always Che king if any refills were needed. I was surprised to see Du l Wings on the appetizer menu, and being a lover of wings, we tried them. These were perfect! They had a wonderful crunch to them and served with a sweet chili sauce. I got the cod fish fry, which was amazing. The fish batter was not overwhelming like many places do. Seasoned perfectly. The ambience was true Wisconsin with the winter sports items all over. I especially liked the vintage bars signs hanging around the bar. I definitely recommend stopping by if in the area.

My wife had her baby shower at this venue. We booked this place because of the deck and view, instead, I found out the party was crammed into a back room without access to the outside. It had a savory smell of old mop water. Off to a great start =) The food was mid, after the shower the staff practically pushed everyone out right as the clock struck 3:30 (the end of the event) stressing out half the people. It wasn't cheap per head, and they didn't let anyone take the purchased food... so basically, they watched the staff wheel away our money while booting them out the door. We will not be returning for ANY reason needless to say. I have worked in the restaurant industry, and this is entirely unacceptable for the price. 3 star service3 star food0 star customer careKnow BEFORE you go folks -_-

Its so refreshing to go to a restaurant where you are not gettingripped off by high wine by the glass prices! You see so many placesnow that are charging over $10 a glass for wine. 5 O'clock Club offersnice wine at $7-$8 a glass. I drink at least 3 glasses at dinner andcan't afford these places that charge $10-$11 a glass. 5 O'clockClub clearly is our top 3 best fish fries in Wisconsin. We don't likethe thick beer batter fish fries. Their crusty,thin, tasty batter is the best.It comes out very hot! French fries are like Culvers, but much more flavor! Cole Slaw is always fresh and one of the tastiest. Sure, youhave to wait on Friday night, just like 95% of all the other restaurantsin Wisconsin on Friday night, but its worth the wait. We always havegreat service too. Most of the servers there on Friday night have beenthere for years. Keep up the good work there and thanks!

Best fish fries in the whole area! Staff is the best. No matter where you sit it's always the best place! Eating thete for 50yrs +