Midnight Cookie

Been in this food court a few times recently to get food and bubble tea, and never noticed this place. But then again, I have looked at this spot, and never seen it open, so I didn't know what was here. I came to grab bubble tea with my cousin and was happy to see there was a Midnight Cookie here. I've been wanting to try the place because I like cookies with unique flavors. I tried the Fruity Pebbles, S'mores, Strawberry Shortcake, and Cookies and Cream. My favorite out of those four would be Fruity Pebbles and S'mores. The Fruity Pebbles cereal on the cookies actually didn't get extra stale even days later. The cookies were soft and stayed soft days later; it was so soft, it was hard to pick up the cookie without it falling apart. They weren't overly sweet. I'm sure I'll tempted to try more flavors.

Very difficult to find, you have to take the elevator or stairs up to the children's play area on the 3rd floor in the middle of the giant mall, where the poor person who works there is in a confined space with an indoor children's playground. We stopped by about 30 mins before they closed at night and it was loud, I imagine it is all day. They had a decent selection of cookies for the end of the day. I got one and it was fine but nothing I would go out of my way for.

Midnight Cookie was my go to cookie place in North Seattle before it fell off a bit. I randomly discovered this relatively newer location on the top of Belle Square when visiting the children's play area. Not gonna lie it's hard to keep watching your own kiddo when the cookie stand is just glaring at you from the side. The cookies are decently sized, but I remember them being more flavorful. The s'mores and sweet & salty cookies were the most bland. Although soft, I wish they had more of a crisp outside, while still being pliable and chewy internally. Nevertheless it's a good treat to be had and I'm glad they're expanding more.

Solid cookies. I prefer midnight to crumbl, though I don't really consider crumbl cookies a cookie. Midnight Cookie has a good base cookie, crispy edges, soft middles...it's not overly sweet or decadent and the prices are fair/low for a cookie! Got the s'mores and birthday cake, both had distinct flavors. Birthday cake had a slight almond taste & s'mores wasn't super...s'more-y, still good.

Avoid ordering from this place AT ALL COSTS.I ordered them last night, January 8. I was 1/2 through the milk that came with before I realized it tasted kinda awful. THEY SENT ME MILK THAT EXPIRED IN MID OCTOBER.So, this morning I'm all kinds of sick. Do yourself a favor - pass on this place. The cookies aren't worth their poor safety and customer service.

The girl who helped me was super nice! The counter is hidden on the third floor away from the other food and stores so it was a bit hard to find. Their smores cookie was ok, not bad not great. It's near the mall's indoor playground for children so I took it to go.

Midnight Cookie Company is a cookie lovers paradise! Their delicious cookies will transport you to heaven, especially their mouthwatering cookies and cream cookies!Let me tell you, those cookies and cream cookies are my absolute favorite. I will order 6 or sometimes even a dozen cookies, ALL COOKIES and CREAM. Midnight Cookies has other flavors to choose from. The Snickerdoodle and Fruity Pebbles are two of my runner ups. I love the fact that they are open late and you can get them delivered on a couple food deliver apps. And if you just so happen to be at the mall, head up to the 3rd floor, and will find Midnight Cookie as soon as you step off the elevator.

I decided to head to the mall to try the new location of midnight cookie. It was the soft opening so each person that came got a free cookie. The cookie shop is right next to the indoor kids playground on the 3rd level of the mall. This I feel is a bit of a hidden location as many people, me included, don't even realize there was a 3rd level in the mall. While it is hard to complain about a free cookie, I was not blown away. I went with the s'mores and I likely wouldn't order it again if I was to pay for it. Each cookie normally costs around $3 which is a bit high in my opinion given the size. Hopefully in the future they have a way to warm the cookies, that would most definitely help. The employees seemed nice and polite in our brief interaction so I will likely give Midnight Cookie another try, just with a different flavor!

Come on, Yelpers, this 3.0 average rating is a bit harsh for the Bellevue Square location.Midnight Cookie has been around this region for many years now. The first location I visited was Fremont (4.2 average rating). The second location is downtown in Pacific Place (4.4 rating). Then I tried Kirkland (3.8 average rating) and Redmond (4.5 average rating, this location replaced Cow Chips). And then there is Bel Square at 3.0. Eyebrow raising emoji... What is wrong? We, the reviewers, can be unfairly judgmental. - "Hard to find", "hidden" - It is on the third floor of the mall. Only a very small portion of the mall has a third floor. It is as easy to find as Nordstrom and Macys. There is a staffed information booth on the ground floor to ask if needed. - "Unfriendly staff" - Complained about not getting a free cup. I can understand the policy to buy something and then maybe get a free cup. There are hundreds, if not thousands of kids passing through this third-floor play area each day. Just because Midnight Cookie is near the play area and the only business still on the third floor, they should not be expected to provide for your child. That is your job, child-caretaker person. When I walked up to the counter, I looked at the lady. I turned to look at the kids. I asked her, "Are you ok?" with all the earnestness I can express. She knew what I meant right away. She replied, "This is as loud as it gets." Holy moly. It is LOUD! If I worked there, I would have such an incredible headache by the end of my shift. Bravo to her for even being there! I would not be able to handle that job. Let's face it. That's a min wage job + tips. As for the cookies, I have had them a couple of times at this location. I will say the quality isn't always standardized. Maybe some are a bit crumbly, while others are a bit chewy. It's a mixed bag. For the most part, I am happy with my $3 cookie. The Double Chocolate Chip is a standard purchase. That cookie tends to be consistent with a touch of chew. The Classic Chocolate Chip has been more of a mixed experience - crumbly one day, chewy the next day. I always enjoy the monthly special. The February was a red velvet with chocolate chip. Not bad at all. For $3, I am getting a dessert that will last me two days. If I buy a macaron instead, I'll want to eat two of those at $6. I am quite happy with my cookie purchase!

The cookie quality is similar to what you get at Safeway. Cookies feel gritty and powdery and lack complexity. Cookies fall apart in your hand but not in the good way. I asked an employee what times they were open until and she replied "midnight". I was surprised as this Bellevue location is in the mall and asked how I would be able to get a coffee after hours (9pm) when the mall closes. She told me that the door is always open and, while the rest of the stores close, that they are open and to just come on in. I'm surprised by her answer as I DOUBT a high end mall would be unlocked and completely vulnerable at night to allow once in a blue moon customers in for a late at night coffee. Poor employee seemed quite confused. Cookie quality is not very good. Location is perfect though as it's in the same space as the children play area in the mall.