This is the Fatman's stuffed pizza
Dinner Salad (no meat)
Fatman's Special Pizza
Mystery Juice on top
Fatmanspizza The best pizza ever and even better for breakfast next day. Thank you Fatman's from Christopher Metcalfe
Where's the pepperoni and sauce that's usually top?
Cheese not melted
food, pizza
We love pizza and NASCAR!
Small, deep dish SMOG with black olives added. YUMMY
Just a local joint
Stuffed Pizza SMOG (Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion, Green Peppers) minus 1 slice
We won!
Meat lovers medium pizza
Stuffed Pizza SMOG (Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion, Green Peppers)
The art of pizza
Menu side 2
menu
Counter
Medium pepperoni thin crust, rigatoni pasta side, salad & garlic bread.
Deep Dish Pepperoni Pizza minus 1 slice
Menu side 1
pizza, food
Stuffed Pizza. Amazing sausage!
Diele K.
Feb 8, 2025
Fatman's Pizza has been a local establishment for a while, but I don't frequent often. My friend loves their gluten free pizza, and we order when at Cat Wagon. Not a huge fan of their pasta, but their salad was great. Love that they will deliver next door to Cat Wagon, and always very friendly. There is space for dining, but seem like more of a takeout place.
Read More
Joseph D.
Dec 23, 2024
The pizza is terrible. The Chicago deep dish pizza they serve is a joke and a disgrace. The old owner, who started fat man's pizza, knew the business and served really good food. These people could not care less. The owner is never there and management Don't know anything about pizza. It's a shame becaus at one time it was really good
Read More
Thomas H.
Oct 27, 2023
I really liked the pizza - it's one of the best Chicago-style pizzas I've had! If you like lots (and I mean LOTS) of fresh toppings and cheese, you have to try the Fatman's Special Pizza. Each slice is a meal in itself. Typically, I can eat 3 slices, but with this pizza, I could only manage 1 1/2 slices. I enjoyed the toppings right up to the 1/4 inch of the crust. Deliciousness to the last bite!
Read More
Bec S.
Aug 13, 2022
Super sad. Use to love this place. Got our pizza and it's not cooked all the way through. The cheese isn't melted and there is literally only 1/4 of the pepperoni they normally put. I can't really find the sauce either. I'm pretty sure it's not thick crust. Maybe just thick cheese? We won't be going back unfortunately because I should have read the other reviews again. There's also juice on my pizza. Question: do they even look at thier pizzas before boxing??After calling Fatmans, the manager said she would take care of it next time. I might give them another chance to see if it's better.I'll post the update for next time.
Read More
Kyle H.
Feb 12, 2025
really good pizza. awesome atmosphere especially on Friday nights when the music is going.
Read More
Stewart G.
Aug 27, 2024
The meal we had here last month was worse than dreadful. It challenges the diarrhea at Cobb's (which has since been torched and razed) and the village at Vomit Inn... er, I mean the vomit at Village Inn.What they call lasagna amounted to two 3"square, tissue-thin sheets of pasta, welded to the bottom of pre-formed aluminum foil, with a few tablespoons of some kind of bland tomato sauce splashed on it. There was no cheese, no meat, and wasn't worth anywhere near the $16 this gourmet shit cost. For dessert [sic] we ordered something called a cannoli, which was supposed to be a cream-filled cake. The ones we were served must have been in the back of someone's freezer since 1983. The oxidized creme filling tasted like scraps of freeze-dried wet toilet paper. The cake portion was so old, it was petrified into concrete. You could chip your teeth trying to bite into this ancient fossil.We had a fairly large number in our party. All of us were disgusted with the useless garbage we were served and we left no tip. Apache Junction is not exactly a well-spring of cultural opportunity when it comes to restaurants, so it's no wonder so many people, who should know better, think this rubbish constitutes acceptable Italian food.When the previous owner ran this place it was fantastic. He served real pizzas, not take-out pizzas with skimpy cheese and sawdust crumbs for toppings. Judging by so few people ever seen in here, its reputation speaks for itself. Never again!
Read More
Bobby And Amy F.
Jul 16, 2024
Hidden gem in the East valley. Fresh salad was delicious, pizza is off the chain, we tried the fried mushrooms which were delicious, as well! Sampled the soup of the week, unbelievably good; Zappa Tuscan! Give them a try, you won't regret it! Amazingly nice owner, to boot! This is a nice atmosphere with a good vibe!
Read More
Kathy E.
Jan 16, 2024
We ordered the stuffed pizza. The ingredients and flavors are delicious. The only problem I had with the pizza was the crust was a hunk of dough. I would recommend that the use more ingredients and less dough for the crust.
Read More
Robert L.
Jun 15, 2024
Delivery or at least allow one of the services to do it and after selling the business it's not Fatmans anymore so I guess losing long time customers is their new theme
Read More
Tony G.
Apr 6, 2024
Food was way too greasy. One person working, I get it's Fatmans but food just wasn't good.
Read More