Cream Of The Crop

I cannot recommend this place enough when I have people visit from out of town. I've had consistently great and welcoming customer service, all the flavors have always WOWed me, and it's trendy enough that it feels like I'm cool, but low key enough that I feel like I found a hole in a wall.The vibes are so chill here and there's plenty of space to walk around and enjoy your scoops! Every person I've introduced this spot to has loved it. If you haven't had the chance, absolutely make the time! I can't imagine you being disappointed!

I visited by the shop today and plan to return! The peixoto coffee flavor is delicious, and so is every other flavor I tried. Lily was our cashier and was so sweet and professional. Highly recommend if you're looking for quick, sweet treat!

Such a cute lil shop and on the day we stopped by the employee was the BEST! He quickly greeted us and told us he would be right with us as he was already helping another couple out. Once our turn, he asked us how our day was going and if we wanted any samples. We ended up getting the cherry lemon flavored one in a cup and the cream of the crop / cookies and crème in a cone. All three flavors we picked were delicious. They were creamy and just the right amount of sweetness.The inside is small but very cute. The décor is one of a kind! We will be back!

Found about this place through a friend and immediately had to try it out! Located within the Barone collective in Gilbert, this is the perfect spot to stop during a night out for some amazing ice cream! We ate it so fast we forgot to take pictures of our actual ice cream. I opted for their OG Cream of the Crop which is reminiscent of a key lime pie. It had a hint of lime but was super creamy and delicious. My husband ordered a double scoop with the cookies and cream and PiextoCoffee. It was a tough spot for #1 in my heart between the cream of the crop and the cookies and cream, but cookies and cream was a close 2nd! The coffee ice cream was a bit strong for my preference, but i appreciated the quality coffee used. The staff was amazing and super patient as we sampled their flavors before ordering. We will be back!

When it comes to ice cream, this spot really is my Cream of the Crop. The best way to top off a relaxing day in Agritopia, which is truly becoming a hot spot in Gilbert, is by enjoying a couple delicious scoops from this Barnone vendor!The Peixoto coffee (no surprise) is one of the best coffee ice creams I've had -- strong yet creamy and made with high-quality local beans. But if you're at Cream of the Crop, you *must* try their unique flavors. They won't disappoint. One of their current rotating flavors is made with a blend of white chocolate, pink peppercorns, and lime, and I was sooo pleasantly surprised at the taste. I had to get a scoop!There isn't a lot of seating, but there are a ton of local restaurants, vendors, and bars to check out, all within a 5 minute walk in the lot while you enjoy your ice cream. I can't wait to come back and try more flavors!

Our go to Ice cream spot! Love the workers, love the combinations and new flavors they add! Always such a a great experience!

Delicious ice cream tucked away in a cool marketplace. Got the cookies n cream and mr. Turtle! The cookies n cream was one of the best cookies n cream I tried - lots of cookies mixed in and creamy texture. Mr. Turtle is great if you love chocolate and pretzels. Had caramel too for a sweet and slightly salty taste. Wish I lived closer!

When I scream, you scream, we all scream for IcE CREAM! What a delightful experience at Cream of the crop this week! We enjoyed it so much we came back for more two times in one week. We visited for the first time on Wednesday and brought new friends tonight.I loved that Romain- the amazing employee that helped us out on Wednesday remembered who we were 2 days later. He was so nice and excited about telling us the flavors. The ice cream shop was small and cute inside Barone. The vibes were super cute! Turns out the flavors change often too. Looking forward to see what new flavors are offered the next time we are back.

I love ice cream! I have been to a lot of local ice creamery's all over the country and this one is my favorite so far.

Our favorite ice cream spot. The ice cream is so rich and creamy and fresh!! It's awesome to support a small local business. Definitely try the espresso coffee ice cream!!