Slice Midtown
Slice Midtown
This was not good. Bland. Not even salt and pepper.
Slice Sampler Box
a row of pizzas with different toppings
Chicken Parm
Appetizer Sampler Box
Cheese Slice Veggie Slice
18" Pepperoni and Extra Cheese Pizza
Appetizer Sampler Box
Mini wings
Buffalo chicken
Veggie pizza
a variety of food items in a box
food, chicken wings and fried chicken
food
pizza, pasta, and salad on a table
food, pizza
pizza, food
drink
Tammy H.
Oct 16, 2024
So, I have been a loyal customer of the previous establishment in this location for a while. I found Slice when I tried to place an order & the number to the previous business was disconnected. Blessing in disguise.I've order the meat lovers a couple of times now & it is just TASTY & not greasy. You can taste the quality in the meat they use. The sauce isn't too much & compliments the rest of the ingredients. For reference, I love a thin crust & theirs is cooked to perfection. Yes, I personally always order the large because it taste that good & warms up well (hint: put in a skillet to crisp up the crust). BUT, it is also good cold. I will eat their pizza either way.If you are ordering from here, be conscience of the sizes. This isn't like order from those other chain places. When you get a large, that is exactly what you are getting.
Read More
Kera W.
Mar 17, 2024
As a New Yorker with high expectations for pizza, I recently decided to try out Slice Midtown for a taste of their offerings. Ordering their pizza for home delivery, I was initially impressed by the appealing presentation of the pizza.The pizza from Slice Midtown certainly looks good. The combination of melted cheese, pepperoni, and the overall appearance is visually pleasing. However, when it comes to taste, I must admit that it fell short of my expectations. As someone who values the quality of the dough, sauce, cheese, and cooking of the toppings, I found the flavors to be lacking. The pizza had very little sauce, and the consistency of the dough was unusual for my preference.While the pizza from Slice Midtown may appeal to those who enjoy bread with melted cheese and pepperoni, it didn't quite hit the mark for me. The flavors seemed to be missing, and the overall experience was average at best. Being a connoisseur of pizza, I have a discerning palate and hold high standards for this beloved dish.In addition to the pizza, I also tried their chicken Parm. Although I had hoped for a more exceptional taste, it turned out to be just average. While it wasn't bad, it also didn't stand out as anything particularly memorable.Considering my personal expectations for pizza and the overall experience I had with Slice Midtown, I don't think I will be ordering from them again. However, it's worth mentioning that taste preferences can vary, and what didn't impress me might be enjoyed by others who have different preferences.In conclusion, Slice Midtown offers a visually appealing pizza that may satisfy those looking for bread, melted cheese, and pepperoni. However, for someone with high standards and a love for authentic New York-style pizza, the flavors and consistency of the dough fell short. While the food was at best average for me, others may have a different perspective and find it more enjoyable.
Read More
Robert T.
Dec 9, 2024
For me, best pizza in midtown. Fresh dough, fresh toppings, lots of mozzarella cheese, great service.
Read More
Monica P.
Jul 26, 2024
I like the idea of the Big Box Sampler but the wings really made me rethink my decision of spending $30 on this. I've never had wings with little to no meat on them and being it was one of 2 proteins in the box, it just wasn't worth the price. Food quality and taste is like any other pizza spot. Very underwhelming to say the least
Read More
Matthew B.
Jul 28, 2024
I really like this pizza New York style is always great. Some of the sandwiches are real good. I love the spaghetti sandwich when it's done correctly.I love the Italian beef, except it would be better if they would dip it. Overall, I love this restaurant they treated everyone well..Just those few things I mentioned probably would bring them down a star it started as a five
Read More
Terry P.
Apr 9, 2024
The food was delicious. The drinks and food came out promptly. Services was excellent.: the ambience is a nice chill.
Read More
Mark W.
Nov 5, 2023
When I tell you beyond disappointed. The pictures look good on social media but let me tell you the taste is not there. Everything is BLAND. Started with Garlic knots which were the best thing. The marinara sauce taste like it's straight out of a can just straight tomato sauce no Italian seasoning no salt etc. Fettuccine Alfredo was the biggest disappointment ever. It had absolutely no flavor. It tasted like they just mixed milk and pasta. The most bland dish I've ever had. Tried to add my own salt and pepper but no helping this. Now the pizza, the vodka slice was decent but again no salt just tastes like they take sauce from a can and throw it on the pizza. The white pizza had no flavor. It was like it was just ricotta only. When I tell you big disappointment I mean it. The pictures looked so amazing and left to go eat somewhere else. 2/10 do not recommend
Read More
Sheila D.
Sep 24, 2024
Ordered several pizzas for a corporate lunch. Kindle, the person in charge of catering, met me and helped me with my order. Asked questions like how many people, what type of people (male/female ratio?/ages (younger to older?) dietary needs, etc. She made great suggestions on what types of pizzas to order as well as how they should be cut (square cut works easier for larger parties) She guaranteed delivery on time and it arrived on time, hot, with plenty of plates & utensils. The pizza was delicious and got lots of compliments from our attendees. Will absolutely order again for future meetings. Thank you for great service and food!
Read More
Simone B.
Jul 8, 2024
Really good pizza and sides. If you're looking for something more authentic NY style pizza in midtown, this is the place to go.
Read More
Suzy
Feb 15, 2025
Great Caesar Salad, pizza was not as expected at all, wouldn't order again. All the toppings we either missing or in the center of the pizza only, no flavor at all. Not what little Italy used to be.
Read More
