NY Pie
NY Pie
18" pepperoni, mushroom, and banana pepper pizza
Large (18 inch) half pepperoni, half mushroom.
menu
We got a large pizza with banana peppers, pepperoni, and sausage. It was absolutely pressure! Definitely bring your fam here!!!
18" NY Cheese
Undercarriage
Pepperoni and sausage pizza
NY Special and 2 Cannolis
Horribly undercooked pizza
Garlic knots
food, pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian style
pizza, food
pepperoni, sausage, and cheese pizza
the front door of a restaurant
interior
Menu - back
Menu - front
pizza, food
interior
Deserts!
pizza, food
food, pizza
Grumpy G.
Jan 13, 2025
We are pizza freaks not snobs. Stopped in to grab a few slices before heading to the movie theater. Pizza was good. And service was good. Based on what we had we would come again. We didn't get much cause you have to save room for popcorn
Read More
Terry B.
Aug 15, 2024
Since pizza is my first language, had to try this place I found coming home from work. Nice little interior and clean bathrooms. The staff was friendly and helpful as they could be with a to-go order. I got a large cheese which was $20. Higher end of the acceptable price scale, but since it's an 18" that's acceptable. Good crust not snap to speak of but a nice chew. Good flavors on the sauce but the cheese is a little greasy. Overall nothing to snub a nose at. Best family Friday night pizza I've had in the area. I would never call it the best in New York, but it definitely has that NY vibe and for middle TN you can't really ask for more than that. 7.5/10 3.8/5 stars rounded up to 4 for yelp.
Read More
Foodie R.
Sep 24, 2024
What a gem! When relocated NY/NJ people have a need for authentic NY pizza, NYPie in Hendersonville is the place. Fresh, thin, crispy and quality ingredients. Nick & Mike are gentlemen and def know how to make a great pie. Voted by two relocated NY/NJ transplants. A MUST!
Read More
Grace L.
Mar 21, 2024
I've been going to this place for years and in the beginning it was good. For the past few years it hasn't been as good, but I go to because I miss NYC style pizza and want to support a local business. If you plan on eating at the restaurant, you order at the front and then take a number and they will take your order out to you. The staff are friendly.
Read More
Cuno W.
Jul 21, 2024
I'm a pizza lover and just moved to Hendersonville, Tn.So far, I've found three places I really like. This review is for "NY Pie"The pizza there is really good. By the slice (lunch special) or bring a pie home, you won't be disappointed!Great pizza sauce, lots of cheese and every topping you could ever want. The crust is perfect. I had the lunch special and had two different slices and a soda and got a cool discount too. Clean, and well organized. They're located in a small strip center just off the highway. Parking might be tough during football season, but you'll survive. I have a buddy from New York and he really likes it too. If you're in the Hendersonville area, go check it out, you won't be disappointed!
Read More
Chelsea C.
Nov 30, 2024
NY Pie Pizza is fantastic! I always order takeout, and the pizza never disappoints. The staff is super friendly, and the service is quick and efficient. Highly recommend!
Read More
Phil M.
Nov 5, 2023
I've had this place in the past and it was halfway decent. Now.... Totally inedible.Couldn't pick up a piece without the middle completely falling apart because the dough was raw. Cheese was barely cooked. I was so tempted to ask for it to be cooked well done, but I wanted to give them a shot at their normal cook. Crust tasted like it is from a frozen dough ball, and the sauce seemed like it was straight from a can. Really disappointed that we spent our money here. The decor is drab and outdated as well. Staff was friendly, but that was our one bright spot about the whole experience.
Read More
Steve R.
Mar 26, 2024
Excellent New York style pie. Excellent ingredients & sauce. Definitely give them a try !
Read More
Bobbi Jo R.
Feb 4, 2024
Stopped in for a quick bite. Classic NY style pizza similar to what you'd find in a mall up north. Service was quick. The sauce had good flavor, the toppings were fresh, pepperoni did lean a bit on the greasy side. We will stop in again if in the mood for a NY style pizza.
Read More
Craig B.
Jul 19, 2024
Consistently good pizza. Lots of other options that are delicious as well.They also have ridiculously huge homemade cookies, lol
Read More
