Yum. Stuffed slice
Yum!
Yankee fan favorite..not me, but it feels like NYC.
interior
Meat Stuffed Slice
The Front of the Restaurant. It faces the side street and not Airways.
Menu 5/2024
interior
Calzone. Yummy
Menu 5-2024
Calzone was ok.
Pepperoni pizza pocket
sushi and sashimi, menu
Sausage Calzone
Regular cannoli
Sausage Calzone. Gosh damn, it's good
They need one girl, that's all.
Pepperoni Pizza Pocket
Calzone
Reference the hand to the slice. It's got some size to it.
Slice of pepperoni pizza
Side salad is a good size
interior, sushi and sashimi
Sausage Roll !!! Too much sauce for me.
Beth S.
Dec 7, 2024
I deeply regret that it took me so long to try this pizza joint. Legit New York Style pizza at its best!! I've eaten it twice now. First time I dined in. This time I picked it up and ate at home. Both times, wow, wow, supremely delicious thin crust NY pizza. Highly recommend!!
Read MoreKacie H.
Sep 3, 2024
I love their lunch deals! They also have other deals throughout the week that give you a good bang for your buck. It's a nice place to sit for lunch, but isn't really the place to go if you're looking for a nice, sit down dinner. This place is more quick and casual, and the service is ALWAYS good and fast.
Read MoreSarah P.
May 28, 2024
Great pizza by the slice! Awesome lunch deals for two huge slices and a drink. It is kind of a hole in the wall place, so not the most aesthetically pleasing. It isn't really a place with waiters, more of an order at the counter.
Read MoreMike A.
Jul 3, 2024
We came here for dinner on a Friday night I'd say we arrived about 530pm or so. Place was not busy at all but we did have a slight wait while workers behind the counter realized we were there waiting to order. The menu is pretty simple (not saying this in a derogatory way, just saying it's a straight forward pizza joint) and the decor is very New York. And somewhere specific - Yankees, not Mets. Giants, not Jets. Rangers, not Islanders. I'd worry for someone who wore gear from the wrong team in to this place. We got an order of garlic knots and 2 18" pizzas, a cheese and a deluxe. This was New York pizza done the best I've had in the area. Pretty close to the original in my humble opinion. Let me tell you we did a number on those 2 pizzas, I was thinking "oh man we ordered way too much food" but nope. Having 2 active teenage boys really helps with the hike "finishing off the pizza" chore. Good crust for folding, gooey cheese like a NY Pizza should have. I honestly don't know why we haven't tried Milanos before but we will for sure go back. Actually I think I may know why - I truly detest the intersection of Airways and Goodman.
Read MorePooja S.
Sep 14, 2024
The best NY we have had in a very long time! The large was big size- and can't forget the cannoli. Best place for family. Don't forge to try the garlic bread! Service was awesome!
Read MoreJoe D.
Feb 26, 2024
If you know NYC style pizza then you'll like this place. Several large sized pies, reasonably priced, and tasty. I had the meat slices which was plenty for any adult. It also has a NY feel inside. If you're a Yankees fan this is your place. The employees were helpful but some could not speak English very well. Overall, we would definitely go back. This a is a great alternative to the Pizza Hut, Papa John's or Dominos everyone runs to.
Read MoreTarshe C.
Nov 9, 2022
This was my first time trying Milanos Ny Pizza. But if this is what New York pizza is, I'm no longer excited to eat pizza there. We had the Calzone (basically a lot of cheese with small sausages) the sauce was served on the side, I'm definitely not of fan of their sauce. Then we tried the Sausage Roll, I was very disappointed . The presentation sold me , but is a stuff supreme pizza with way too many veggies and a lot of pizza sauce ( and this sauce has a sweet taste. ( so again, I'm not a fan of the sauce either) Now the services is great; and the young lady at the register was very helpful and friendly as well. But I don't think I would return for the Pizza unfortunately ....
Read MoreTara H.
Aug 17, 2022
My family and I went here for the first time last night and it was pretty good and the girl that took our order was very sweet. We got a deluxe pizza and a side of pepperoni breadsticks. For dessert I took home a tiramisu and it was delicious! One of the best tiramisus I've had.
Read MoreJ. F.
Apr 26, 2024
As a native Pennsylvanian who loves New York-style pizzas, subs, and pastas, Milano's is as good as it gets. Hands down. The food has an exquisite mouth feel and quality to it, in my opinion.
Read MoreSteve J.
Dec 29, 2023
Very good pizza. I believe the crust is a little tough when eating but overall good pizza. Service very good show a lot of appreciation in purchasing pizza.
Read More