Coletta's Italian Restaurant

Ordered six pies for a group. One was completely incorrect, but they were all so horrific that we didn't even eat more than one slice per person. The "bbq pizza," which we didn't order, was like two inches of dried out chicken on top of congealing barbecue sauce. Oof. It literally tasted worse than the pizza in truck stops that lives under glass. It was so awful that I was actually surprised to discover on Yelp that it's a real restaurant. I had assumed that it was a ghost kitchen reheating factory frozen pizzas. Avoid at all costs.

Barbecue pizza is amazing. Love the thousand island dressing and the Italian spinach. We have been coming to this location for years.

Food was good. That's the only thing good about this restaurant. The building was old and run down, service was slow, bathroom was dirty. I couldn't believe my eyes when I saw there was no electronic register and the waitresses had to hand calculate the bills!!!

Whoever gives this place 5 stars needs to have their head checked. The food was awful. The service was awful! Ravioli, spaghetti, manicotti all tasted like they had skyline chili on it. You scrape the sauce off and it didn't taste any better. The spaghetti dish tasted like the burnt part of the pot. We were also missing food. The lady who asks for names at pickup is rude. There was nothing nice or good about our experience! Avoid at all costs. Gas station sushi would have been a better option!

Great Italian restaurant! Small and cozy with great food and service. A lot of history too. Highly recommend! Check out the Elvis room too.

First time ever trying Coletta's, we ordered a medium 3 topping pizza and linguine with alfredo sauce and chicken. The pizza was great. Amazing flavor, cheese and pepperonis tastes great. The alfredo was NASTY. I paid $15.50 for pretty much just noodles and sauce. ( sauce tasted bland no flavor ) just seemed like original jar sauce. As for the chicken, i got 4 pieces. The pasta to chicken ratio was very much off. If i wanted just noodles and sauce i would have ordered that. The chicken was very tough, the flavor was ok but overall the worst thing i ordered was the alfredo. I would go there again for the pizza only.

I have been coming to Coletta's my entire life! I'm now 25 years old and we still get the best service, hot food and a lovely time.

The food was straight up nasty. The spaghetti meat sauce pasta tasted burnt. The meatball spaghetti was absolutely non edible. The meatballs were crumbling and dry yet somehow moist. For being an Italian restaurant, the only thing worth getting is the wings. The chicken aldredo was only decent. Alfredo sauce from the jar would've been better to eat. My daughters said their garlic bread and cheese are worse than the cheese bread they get for school lunch. The only thing this restaurant has going for them is the atmosphere.

My favorite pizza in Memphis. Never disappointed. It's the way a pizza should be. Those wonderful old ovens make it extra good.

I would give this place no starts if I could....this was absolutely terrible do not go and get any food at restaurant want to vomit after leaving!