Mama Stortini's Restaurant & Bar - Puyallup
Mama Stortini's Restaurant & Bar - Puyallup
thick cut sourdough and italian cheeses, toasted golden brown with a side of marinara
with fresh tomato + basil
with fresh cucmber dill sauce
with marinara + parmesan
with charred red peppers + pesto aioli
marinated chicken breast, cucumber-dill sauce, pita + field greens with balsamic vinaigrette
baked golden brown, served with toasted sliced baguette
tempura-style prawns with a spicy cream sauce
shredded romaine, smoked gouda, roasted turkey, salami, chopped tomato and garbanzo beans
hearts of romaine, garlic croutons and frizzled capers
mixed baby field greens with diced tomato, cucumber, red onion and parmesan
simmered white and green beans, celery, carrot, onion + bacon in a rich beef-tomato broth
caramelized sweet onions, rich beef broth, a hint of brandy and vermouth - topped with a homemade garlic butter crouton + melted provolone
bacon, avocado, tomato, fresh basil, lettuce and pesto aioli on butter-toasted sourdough
brie, tomato, basil, red onion, lettuce and basil mayonnaise on a butter-toasted bun
american cheese, burger sauce, red onion, tomato, lettuce + pickle
bacon, crispy onion rings, american cheese, burger sauce, tomato, lettuce + pickle
Thin sliced prime rib and white cheddar with creamy horseradish sour cream on butter-toasted baguette. Served with natural au jus
served hot on a butter toasted baguette
with italian sausage, ricotta and mama's meat sauce, mozzarella - oven-baked to a golden brown
lasagna noodles layered with tender rotisserie chicken, mozzarella and mama's bolognese, oven-baked to a golden brown
ziti with bolognese sauce and mama's tuscan roasted meatballs
spaghetti, mama's slow-roasted meat sauce and oven-roasted meatballs
sautéed premium white gulf prawns, white wine, fresh garlic + basil, red pepper flakes, extra virgin olive oil and grated parmesan
premium white gulf prawns, bay scallops, sautéed fresh salmon and fettuccine tossed with creamy garlic alfredo sauce
our popular fettuccine alfredo tossed with tender seared chicken breast
oven-baked campanelle pasta, lobster, fontina and cheddar with crispy breadcrumbs
linguine, rotisserie chicken, fresh basil + tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil cream sauce
chicken, mushroom + ricotta filled jumbo ravioli tossed with sautéed mushrooms and marsala cream sauce - topped with crispy garlic breadcrumbs
smoked mozzarella ravioli with fresh basil, slow-roasted cherry tomatoes, arugula and our fresh garlic herb sauce
Served with mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables and housemade creamy horseradish. Our twenty-eight day aged local prime ribs are slowly roasted under a mountain of rock salt forming a seasoned coat to retain it's flavorful juices, resulting in a remarkably tender, flavorful and juicy cut of beef
Always Fresh from British Columbia. See our Features menu for today's salmon preparations
pan-seared chicken breast, fresh mushrooms and marsala sauce served over linguine
pan-seared chicken breast served over linguine with roasted tomatoes, mushrooms, capers and lemon juice
crispy breaded chicken layered with marinara, fresh mozzarella, parmesan and romano, roasted golden brown - served with spaghetti + marinara
pan-seared breaded chicken breast, prawns, prosciutto, and smoked provolone, over garlic herb spaghetti
sautéed premium white gulf prawns, bay scallops, fresh salmon, parmesan + creamy risotto
premium vanilla ice cream with chocolate sauce, candied walnuts, whipped cream + a cherry
mascarpone, key lime and crushed graham crackers
pineapple cake with a caramelized pineapple ring, a touch of cinnamon and vanilla ice cream
topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream
chocolate mousse with a hint of coffee, served with salted caramel sauce + fresh whipped cream
naples' famous ice cream blended with candied fruit + almonds
Your server will describe today's flavor
Your server will describe today's flavor
with lemon-pepper garlic-vermouth butter
with toasted hazelnut butter
with seasoned lemon garlic butter, roasted on an aromatic cedar plank
with vinaigrette
Inside the French onion soup, rich dark beef broth.. so good!!
Goat Cheese Bruschetta
Goat cheese and balsamic vinegar bruschetta
Front Entrance
HH bolognese with red/white sauce and spaghetti in place of rigatoni. Good, could have more sauce.
Bone next to quarter for size comparison.
Half order of Colossal Chicken Parmesan
My order - such small portions, and this cost $23!
The goat cheese bruschetta ( sorry missing one piece) really fresh and delicious. $10.95 HH
Menu as of 08/07/20
interior
Yummy gooey French onion soup, hh $7.95
Crispy artichokes and Goat Cheese Bruschetta
Inconsistent soups same table low QC
Inconsistent to same table, low QC
Side of house bread, colossal chicken parm.
HH Chop chop salad ( split) w/ calamari, all tasty!
Ravioli
Seasonal Menu
Applewood BLTA on sourdough
Crispy artichokes
Burnt orange lemon drop
Clam linguine
Robert W.
Jan 14, 2024
Extensive menus service friendly and eager to assist. Food hot and freshChocolate sundae was good. Best to make reservations
Read More
Mark O.
Jun 23, 2024
This place used to be great but the service is still great but their prices and their food is so tiny for too expensive one tiny handful of for $28 and $8 to add shrimp
Read More
Scott M. C.
May 24, 2024
Driving back to Seattle from our visit to Mount Rainier, our hunger and cravings lead to a Google Maps search for Italian Restaurants, Mama Stortini's was highly recommended and nearby. We were fortunate that our impromptu visit turned out very well! The service was great and the food was excellent! My wife and I shared the Colossal Chicken Parmigiana and they played the food on separate plates and we couldn't believe how much food we received. The side of marinara served with the cheesy garlic bread was delicious but too small for enough coverage for the delicious bread! So it goes as it didn't take away from the fantastic meal and experience we enjoyed.
Read More
Chris P.
May 13, 2024
Amazing meal that left me completely stunned and stuffed. Definitely try the chicken parmesan. Great service.
Read More
Kristen C.
Jan 8, 2024
The food is your typical Italian food. We've been here several times and it's consistently good. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu! Service is usually good, but our last visit was a bit off. It took a while to get our appetizer (over 40 min and the table next to us - same number of people, got and finished their app and dinner before we got our app) and it came out the same time as our food. I don't like this to begin with, but I even made mention of it when we ordered the app and our food at the same time, asking that just the app be put in first. This was definitely an off night and to make up for it our app was comped without us even asking. I recommend making reservations if you can. It's usually a full restaurant and bar, even during the week. People love this place for good reason.
Read More
Sara F.
Dec 31, 2023
Mama Stortini's has the "dance" down. Packed house for lunch on a weekday, yet seated within 10 minutes. Huge menu with diverse options, served fast. The manager is greeting every table and delivering food - so friendly and professional. Toasted cheese bread app - 6 huge portions with a delectable marinara dip. Chicken pear salad and Tuscan chop chop salad - both plentiful and mixed well. Fairly priced!Lazy lasagna (lunch portion) - wow!I would also like to add that Mama Stortini's is extremely charitable, having donated food for a non-profit event in the community. Thank you chef!! This generosity, in addition to their A+ food and service, makes me grateful to have Mama's in Puyallup.
Read More
Chris V.
Nov 25, 2023
So good. Spicy Cajun pastapaata from the seasonal menu. I've never been to this location, but it just became my favorite. The prawns were cooked perfectly, and the andouille sausage had the perfect amount of garlic in it. In fact, it was some of the best I've ever had, even in Louisiana. I'm impressed, to say the least, since my favorite activity in New Orleans is eating. Nice work, Mama Stortinni's.
Read More
Morpheus M.
Jun 3, 2024
I have no idea what the rating is 3.6 - I think it's from a jealous Italiano restaraunt Nextdoor. I've eaten at both and H A N D SD O W N Mama Stortinis is smoking great. Service was unbelievable, the food was out of this world and the ambience was pleasant. It's my go to for Sunday all day happy hour. You need to reward yourself
Read More
Gina M.
Mar 21, 2024
Casual plain interiors able to accommodate large parties and family friendly. Service is friendly and fast. Large parking lot at the back.Lots to choose from and everything we ordered was good. Their small plates/appetizers were very good - must have the goat cheese bruschetta. Burrata salad was ok, but the burrata wasn't very fresh and rather dry as opposed to creamy. Their wild mushroom pizza was also very good. Pastas were just ok, but tasty.In the whole a rather middle of the road commercial Italian restaurant but because their service was better than average and some of their food was very good I can see this as a go-to place especially with family.
Read More
Morgan B.
Jun 10, 2024
Used to order from here all the time Tonight I got a Togo, the crab dip is different (in a bad way) and half the size, the fries with my French dip were still partially frozen and the sandwich was mostly horseradish sauce.
Read More
