Mad Batter Bakehouse

Delish "Milk" cookie, nice staff, great ambiance for a rainy afternoon. The milk cookies are really great, moist with nice chocolate chips and a hint of salt.

This place was randomly recommended to us at the candle shop a few doors down. Wow what an experience! When we went, it was a Pirates of the Caribbean themed bakery & we loved it! Decor was outstanding and even dark & eerie in there to follow the theme. They did a great job! Cookie flavors were also linked to the theme and I ordered a yummy sparkling watermelon lemonade. How refreshing! Highly recommend this fun bakehouse!

My new favorite cookie/dessert spot! Each of their cookies/treats is to die for. I highly recommend trying their Slow Burn (s'mores type cookie) and their Golden Hour (Carmel pecan cookie) if it's on their weekly rotating menu.

An exciting addition to the downtown Oak Harbor lineup. Stopped in after they've been open a few days, and was greeted with a clean cafe/bakery/creamery. Ordering was a little chaotic and confusing as there was only a menu for drinks, with a few cookie options set out (though no prices). Ordered a lavender lemonade and a blue lagoon energy drink, and both were quite good. The vibe is good and very unique to the area. There are a couple seating areas for maybe six people in total. More of a grab-and-go type cafe right now. Overall a good place! They still need to work out their flow and some kinks, but I think there is good promise for a fun bakehouse.

My daughters 3rd birthday was over the weekend. Being busy with grad school, working in the yard, and trying to prepare for family coming up to visit, I didn't have time to bake a cake for her. She specifically asked for a Unicorn Cake. I happen to walk in to Mad Batter during a walk I had with my sister, for some sibling time and catch up, and I nonchalantly asked if they happen to bake cakes too. They sure did, and they were willing to make the cake even with the short notice they were given. It just happened they didn't have any orders at the time. Definitely best to give advanced notice. I am beyond grateful for the generosity and time it took to make this amazing cake! The beautiful cake, the flavor and love that they put into it, honesty, made a happy birthday girl even more surprised when she saw it. Mad Batter Bakehouse makes the best cakes here in Oak Harbor hands down. I recommend buying a cake from them due to their creative ability, the quality in baking ability, and their hospitality. Definitely the best in Oak Harbor!

So excited that this place opened up! It's in downtown Oak Harbor and it's just what that area needed. I've gone two days in a row and found that they had different flavors each day. I'm not complaining though, each cookie I've had was delicious! I should mention that my ideal cookie is crunchy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside - which all of these cookies were. They have a few drinks (coffee variations and lotus drinks) and ice cream scoops available (I didn't see any cones, but they offer cups). The decor is modern and inviting and there is enough sitting space for about 10 people at a time. Not sure about wifi because we got out good to go. I will definitely be back!

Just finished up our Thanksgiving dinner and the family can't stop raving about the pumpkin pie from Mad Batter. So delicious and fresh!! We pre ordered it and they were ready and easy to pick up. The place is so fun and cute inside, I can't wait to visit again!!

On Thursday 4 May 2023, when I was visiting my Grandma in Oak Harbor, she suggested we come and try a cookie from Mad Batter Bakehouse. She had received a birthday coupon from an acquaintance for a cookie, so we came and I got to pick out the item. The parking area is shared and we were fortunate to find a spot as Grandma said no to walking a block or more to get a cookie.The baked goods are on display just inside the entrance and footprints on the ground show the path to follow to place one's order. I went with a Star Wars-themed Jedi cookie, which was blue velvet and white chocolate. At payment/turning the coupon in, a couple that entered the store after me ignored the footprints on the ground and tried to cut in front of me in line. The worker had been paying attention and helped me next, not the people trying to cut in front of me. She took a name for the coupon redemption, I gave her my Grandma's name.We took the cookie back to the house to eat it for dessert at lunch. The inside of the cookie was soft and the outside golden/browned and perfectly lightly crunchy. White chocolate chips were still melty, and the blue velvet flesh of the cookie was not too sugary and did not stain our teeth. It was a hearty dessert and a perfect portion for both of us.

The baked good were good and the coffee was "okay" and the Pirate theme was fun. For a nightclub. Not for a coffee shop/bakery. The windows are covered in black fabric so it is ridiculously dark in the shop. Very few lights left my husband asking twice where the sugar was. The decor and theme is cute but we wondered about what we could NOT see in that dark space. Keep the theme but light up the shop so it will feel welcoming. This was NOT welcoming!

This place is Okay. Everyone says they were the best cookies, so I went and tried them. It wasn't anything special. They were cookies....Its a small area. Cute. I like they do different themes.I haven't had anyone super upbeat wait on me. They just seemed "meh"