I had the Lean Spinach, it was great!
Yum!! By the slice is so much fun!
a slice of pizza on a paper plate
I brought in some BBQ sauce from my favorite joint back home in KC and asked them to create magic... i was not disappointed.
Yummy pizza!!!
Ranch pizza
Potato Pizza
two slices of pizza on a paper plate
2 slices of their ranch pizza
two slices of pizza on a paper plate
Randy R.
Mar 29, 2024
I came in during lunch and was surprised to see most of the orders were to-go, so I almost had the whole dining room to myself. Which was nice!The pizza is almost NYC style, and it was great!TVs playing quietly in the back. It was a good lunch.
Read More
Lil W.
Jul 28, 2024
Place of business was not wheelchair accessible. I do like that they sell by the slice (hence the name). I got 4 slices of cheese pizza. No tomato sauce. Good undercarriage. Crust was crispy. Cheese was blah. No cheese pull. If it was cheesy bread, it would have been a 9/10. Lady on the phone was sweet but for $3 a slice, The Slice needs to step it up.
Read More
Mary S.
May 9, 2023
Fantastic owner, darn good pizza! Show this place lots of love. Support your community and enjoy some darn good pizza. I'm a purist, cheese, pepperoni, sausage and mushroom... Soooo good!
Read More
Kevin B.
May 15, 2023
You show great kindness and I hope it returnsIf more people would stand up for this then it would be a much better world. .
Read More
Isaac J.
May 24, 2023
I love coming here for a quick bite to eat. Good beer, good pizza , and the staff is the best. I've been coming here for about 10 years now.
Read More
Melissa S.
Mar 19, 2021
Very cool place...an absolute must when in Evansville for lunch. The dude behind the counter is cool, the book selection is cool, the pool tables, hole-in-the-wall setup is super appealing, laid back, casual, low key, flavorful pizza by the slice, uniquely made by hand with a corner window so folks can watch the making. This seems like the perfect place for feeding your face and your creativity all in one. Go get a slice of life here.
Read More
Matt G.
Dec 10, 2023
We have been coming to the Slice for over 10 years. Up until the last several months we had never had a bad piece of pizza. Our most recent visit was the worst pizza we have had. The Ranch pizza had no ranch, pepperoni pizza had no cheese and the service was not good. The new Owner's son provided very little customer service, had his ear buds in the entire time and he obviously made the awful pizza. The lady that worked for Eric still makes great pizzas, but isn't there full time. The atmosphere is now great, but we come there for the pizza.
Read More
James C.
Jan 1, 2024
As a NYC pizza connoisseur, I feel pretty confident in judging good pizza. While on a road trip I stumbled upon The Slice . Not with any big expectations, I was very surprised at how delicious this pizza was . It was thin and crisp and tasty . A really good choice
Read More
Guillermo G.
Mar 3, 2024
I love the slice and it's delicious. but it's pricy, a little too pricy! for a whole pizza it's about $30-$40 dollars and including drinks and chips and can sometimes go up to $50. and for one slice it $3-$5 depending on what you get. it's definitely not something I get a lot but it still is a great place to get delicious pizza every now and then.
Read More
Erik F.
Oct 7, 2023
New owner is keeping many of the old favorites and adding to the menu as well. They have expanded the seating and put up TV's to watch the games. Great atmosphere.
Read More