Spankey's Supreme our most popular pizza.
TMNT Pizza with Jalapeños and Artichokes
We have a beautiful dining room
Come visit our beautiful new store!
Westsider and the Supreme
Enjoy old friends in a new unique place!
Our Murals are by Christina Zimmer Robinson
12 Breadsticks
20'' Cheese Pizza
Bar menu
drink
Ben V.
Oct 6, 2024
The entire atmosphere was awesome. Me and my friends enjoyed our pizzas as well as the breadsticks and cheese sticks. Service was definitely on point.
Read More
Lil W.
Jan 12, 2025
Pizza was 8/10Breadsticks 7/10 Nice atmosphere - smelled like a pizza restaurant I'm wheelchair bound and getting under tables was difficult. Nice bar Service was good 2 bathrooms A bit pricey A nice vibe in a great neighborhood.
Read More
Louis-Charles C.
Mar 2, 2025
Staying a hotel close by I needed food and fast. Order a delivery of a small 8" pizza. As this was one of the only locations to offer delivery on a Sunday night I thought I was in luck. Unfortunately, the food arrived 15 minutes later than the hour they gave in the email confirmation. Pizza was cold and cut into four small pieces. I ordered extra pepperoni yet the pizza came with only 3 pieces spread over the slices . Dry cold pizza that is late and missing toppings I paid extra and tipped well for left me sadly disappointed.
Read More
Danny M.
May 3, 2024
Love the pizza here. So many verities to choose from. Are waiter was very attentive and come back multiple times to check on us. The restaurant building is new and nicely decorated.
Read More
John A.
Sep 3, 2024
1st time eating at Spankey's. Went there for lunch w 2 others, it was an awesome experience. - Everyone very attentive. - good draft beer selection & full bar for drinks. - we love a thin crust. It was amazing. They have it perfected. - has several danishes in the case out front. I recommend the German Kuchen !!! - all items reasonably priced. Had such a good experience I came back w 5 other folks for dinner. Ryan (the owner) came by our table. He has been doing PIZZA for over 17yrs. My sister had the Stromboli, it also off the chart. This will be a must stop for us when we visit. John & family
Read More
Jerry S.
Dec 18, 2024
Our waitress was like a personal attendant for our table of 6. 4 adults and 2 young children. She made at least 4 trips to our table. One table wasn't large enough but she said "we can fix that" and added another smaller table. The boys had a pizza with one half bacon and one half cheese. We had the Boss pizza which was OUTSTANDING with a flaky thin crust and amazing ingredients. My son in law said he would have to change to his new favorite pizza place.
Read More
Asha B.
Jun 15, 2024
The restaurant is nice and filled with good vibes. However I've been trying to give this restaurant multiple chances. This evening did it... can the workers not read!? My Strombolis are always wrongly made!! It's frustrating and to think when you aren't feeling great and want a good strom and it's wrong!!!Called and the gentleman was nice and re-made my strom's. I go grab them and ask why does the bag say BBQ? ..."Bc Grippos are BBQ chips." ...(BBQ should not be used when you also sell BBQ Stromboli's).... Therefore that should be clear to all worker's, as I usually see Grip. on my bag. Great location & food, when made correctly!
Read More
Marie D.
Mar 23, 2024
New location in Evansville downtown ,owner is very, very disrespectful. He tells his employees to hang up on customers who are calling with issues with their orders without even listening to what they have to say.
Read More
Brad B.
Feb 8, 2024
I had the best Stromboli here the other night. The staff was great. The decor is beautifully done. I'm glad that a local artist was hired to give this place a really nice vibe. I'm looking forward to frequenting this place.
Read More