a tray of decorated christmas cookies
9/18/22, Ham , Bacon & Swiss on Sourdough with side of sausage tortellini soup
a chalkboard with a variety of drinks
9/18/22, chicken salad salad
dessert, food
the logo for the indiana's first beer
9/18/22, dog friendly patio!
donuts
dessert, food
Spinach Red Pepper Quiche
dessert, food
food, steak
food, dessert
crepes, food
food
food, donuts
food, nachos
Our handmade scones pair perfectly with our coffee and wifi.
fresh salads made daily for lunch or dinner
Delicious fresh baked pasties items pair well with our coffee, tea, latte or other espresso beverage!
Enjoy our selection of craft beer, wine, coffee and lattes.
food
interior
Karen S.
Jun 19, 2022
This is the cutest little cafe in the cutest town. I came in for breakfast at about 10:45 but by the time I got to the front of the line there was only one person ahead of me it was five minutes later but they had still stopped serving breakfast.Luckily for me they still let me have the avocado toast which was an everything bagel cream cheese avocado tomato and everything bagel seasoning on the top it was pretty delicious. It would've been even better if they would've toasted the bagel slightly.My husband order the ham bacon cheddar wrap. He said it was good, and very filling. Both of our sandwiches came with fruit which was just one piece of pineapple and mostly cantaloupe and honeydew melon. It was ripe and delicious. Our daughter ordered the PB & J. ITT was pretty standard. I also had a latte which was good. I just loved the decor in their place. Such a great vibe.
Read MoreAllison M.
Sep 18, 2022
We stopped here for lunch on a Sunday when we were driving from St. Louis and Louisville (it's about 9 miles off of 64). New Harmony is such a cute town and this cafe follows suit! The inside of the cafe and bar is eclectic, quaint, and comfortable. There is an outdoor patio with about 7 tables - and it is dog friendly! (It is difficult to find a place to stop and eat along 64 when traveling with a dog.) My husband got a couple of beers which were each about $5 and very good. He ordered the club which is closer to a grilled ham and Swiss with bacon rather than the stereotypical club sandwich; because he didn't read the description and had different expectations for his meal, my husband was slightly disappointed about this. I had the chicken salad salad which was very generously portioned. Prices are comparable to a stop at Panera. Food is fresh and service is friendly!
Read MoreL S.
Aug 6, 2022
Good coffee selection.Good icecream, cookies and scones.Friendly service and charming dining area on the corner of town, might add a cute full of character town to wander about and burn off the sweet calories.
Read MoreDanielle P.
Jun 11, 2022
Sara's has many options and they were all busy on this festival weekend. The patio is beautiful and a great place to sit out the wait with your group if the kitchen is backed up.Options :Smoothies , Coffee, and Ice cream barStrawberry and Banana Smoothie - delightfulFrappuccino- delightful Iced Dirty Chai- delightful Ice cream bar - they closed a few minutes before my arrival when l wanted ice cream , seems the town hours are plus or minus 8am -8pmMeals - you will not go wrong with their menu so pick your favorites. They were sold out of the quesadilla at lunch so I ordered the Ham and Cheese sliders on a pretzel bun with potato salad, excellent! They accommodated my toddler. He is a picky eater and they stopped serving breakfast at 11. They made a side order of breakfast sausage which he loved. Wine Bar- did not partake but the full chilled bottles some had at their tables looked superb.
Read MoreMichael S.
Feb 6, 2021
Sara's is a terrific cafe in the center of town. And it's worth the stop. You need coffee, espresso, or a latte? They can handle it. Salad, soup or sandwich for lunch? Check. A pastry or ice cream for snack or dessert? Choose from have several flavors and varieties. My Reuben was divine. Heavenly. The homemade Thousand Island was on the side so I could add just the right amount. Sandwiches came with a side. Mine was perfectly creamy coleslaw. The Chicken Salad Salad was hand made pulled chicken salad on top of a bowl of mixed greens. It was large enough for two. Most salads and sandwiches were north of $10. That might seem pricey, but with Sara's being practically the only lunchtime spot for miles around of this tourist community we're fortunate they didn't charge more.
Read MoreKyle S.
Sep 16, 2019
Sara's was inadvertently the central point of our entire visit. Culinarily, it is open for the lunch we needed with pretty standard fare expertly executed. The food is on the high end of what I like to pay for lunch, but the sandwiches and quiche were both excellent. Surprisingly, the broccoli salad was the high point with amazing flavor!Geographically, the shop sits right smack dab in the center of town with the trails and photo spots to the north and antiquing to the south. You will pass by the building multiple times a day if you spend time in town. Chronologically, the wine bar is one of the few spots open late. And when I say late, I mean, like 8 p.m. The wine bar pushed it into 5 star territory for me. With decor that carries over the old-fashioned whimsy of the main building and ups it with giant circus advertisements, I really liked the vibe. There is a great little "alley" seating area to the side that is also dog-friendly (Hi, George!). The bartender was helpful, friendly, knowledgeable about the area and just plain fun to talk to! The wine and beer selection (no liquor) wasn't especially deep, but definitely broad enough to meet most tastes.
Read MoreTheresa S.
Oct 15, 2020
Wonderful space and yummy food. We tried the sliders on a pretzel bun and they were fantastic. The Magic Coffee is also a winner - especially if you like sweet drinks.
Read MoreDavid W.
Feb 15, 2021
This a nice cafe and wine bar. They have a nice selection of breakfast and lunch items and a pretty extensive coffee and tea menu. The best thing is the Bliss ice cream. It's the best! We had a sandwich and quesadilla. Their homemade tortilla chips are delicious.
Read MoreJodie S.
Mar 17, 2021
Cute cafe with excellent service. I had an iced chia and the spinach red pepper quiche. The quiche came with a fruit bowl too. The quiche was interesting...Swiss and red bell peppers on the bottom, eggs in the middle and spinach on top. The crust could have been cooked a bit more. The cheese on the bottom and crust kind of blended together. Not my normal experience with quiche but a tasty lunch nonetheless.
Read MoreJ C.
Feb 21, 2024
What a precious and cool restaurant! Wish I lived closer because I would go there weekly or maybe even daily ha ha. Awesome food, great service, fresh menu.
Read More