Poplar Street Tavern & Restaurant

We both got the large cod special for 1199. The fish was impressive inside it was all well done. It was a little bit salty. It seems like it might be kind of like green river style. It was breaded. The fries, however, were a bit chewy they were crinkle cuts, she said the slaw was too sweet although they gave her a lot of it they let me have cottage cheese instead since I don't eat slaw it was OK. They also have apple sauce as an option and that's about the ketchup It was less than stellar was less than stellar. They do have big red as a bonus and Coke products. Beware the price on the menu is for cash. I believe the surcharge is 8% for credit. As I always do I just took that off the tip. I know this isn't far but I won't pay this so someone has to.

Slow after order! Nice atmosphere and clean. Nice neighborhood and friendly staff. Patty melt was good with generous beef patty. Could use more cheese but nice overall. Fish and chips (Frys) were big portions and cooked well! Frys were perfectly crispy and delicious!

Wonderful little 'hole in the wall' tavern, waitress was exceptionally nice and the food tasted great (and it was affordable)! I can see why people love this place!

P Street is the place to be! They have all of your standard bar food, as well as steaks,, fish platters, pizza, and usually a daily special that will have some yummy home cooked dishes. The service is always great and food is served hot and plentiful.

This was my first visit here, and I won't be coming back. The outside seating area was packed, and the staff was obviously extremely overwhelmed. We waited 2 1/2 hours for our food (and never got our salads). When it finally arrived it was cold and barely edible. I'm not sure if that was a normal experience or not, but it was incredibly disappointing.

GREAT PIZZA!!! A couple co-workers wanted to try a different place to eat that wasn't on the main drag, so I yelped a couple restaurants and we decided to hit this place due to its reviews. You definitely cant judge this place by the outside, its off the beaten path and looks pretty shady, but this little mom and pop place has some GREAT Pizza and some down right good home cooked meals. I had the breaded tenderloin sandwich with just pickles. I decided to eat this off the bun with mustard as I do most of my breaded tenderloins. It was perfectly cooked and tasted great. The rest of our group split pizzas as it was Half Price Pizza night (Tuesday). They shared a couple slices with me and I totally regret not getting the pizza. It was delicious!!! This Homemade Pie was perfect!!! I am definitely going to try and hit this place again the next time I am in town.Thanks for the Hospitality, cold beer and great eats!!

Ate dinner at the Poplar Street tonight. The waitress was efficient, but it took close to an hour to get our food. My wife ordered a breaded tenderloin and it looked like, and tasted like a dried up chicken fried steak. I ordered a club sandwich and a baked potato. The club sandwich was decent but I never got the baked potato. I would not recommend this place as a restaurant to get service or a decent meal

The food and service are great! They have outside setting and a band on the weekends weather permitting.

their website pictures are nothing like you get when you order and when I asked about why my deluxe pizza looked like a cheese pizza they said that is from the old poplar st and that they now have a new website but when I pulled my phone out to look there is no other website and they couldn't show it to me either. the first picture is from their website the second is what you really get I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone

What a little gem in Seymour tucked in behind the hospital. A 100 year old bar, just what you'd expect inside, and a typical bar menu (sometimes normal and typical is just what you want), something for everyone. But the real plus is outside; a patio and covered tent area to make perfect outdoor dining. Well behaved dogs are invited and given little water bowls. They even provide little fans for each table to scoot away the flying things that come with summer outdoor dining. But the real stars of the place are the wait staff: friendly, efficient, and genuinely give hospitality.