Plehn's Bakery

Donuts

Chocolate Donut
$1.50
Dozen Assorted Round Donuts

Baker's choice - one dozen assorted round donuts (glazed, chocolate, sprinkle, powdered, granulated, caramel, coconut, cake, and french)
$18.00
Glazed Donut
$1.50
Cake Donut - Chocolate
$1.50
Cake Donut - Glazed
$1.50
Chocolate Sprinkle Donut
$1.50
Dozen Assorted Donuts - Half Round, Half Specialty

1/2 ring donuts, 1/2 specialty donuts. Baker's choice on selection.
$22.50
Granulated Sugar Donut

May NOT request jelly donuts here
$1.50
Powdered Sugar Donut

May NOT request jelly donuts here!
$1.50
Cake Donut - Blueberry
$1.50
Caramel Iced Donut
$1.50
Cake Donut - Caramel
$1.50
Coconut Donut
$1.50

Donuts - Specialty

Apple Fritter
$2.25
Iced Jelly Donut

All raspberry filled ONLY. May request powdered or granulated, but we have VERY limited availability of those due to limited demand for them.
$2.25
Cinnamon Twist Donut
$2.25
Filled Lohn John

These ONLY come iced Chocolate
$2.25
Honey Bun - Chocolate
$2.25
Honey Bun - Glazed
$2.25
Plain Long John

These ONLY come iced Chocolate
$2.00
Pretzel Donut
$2.25
Yum Yums
$2.25

Danish and Individual Breakfast Items

Apple Fruit Strip

Puff Pastry strips with apple filling, drizzled with white icing
$1.35
Apricot Danish
$1.75
Assorted 1/2 Dozen Danish

Baker's choice in the 1/2 dozen - assorted amount today's selection of danish
$10.50
Assorted Dozen Danish

Baker's Choice - assorted amount today's selection of danish.
$21.00
Bearclaw

Peanut Danish
$1.75
Cherry Fruit Strip

Puff Pastry strips with cherry filling, drizzled with white icing
$1.35
Cherry Turnover

Puff Pastry with Cherry filling, drizzled with white icing
$2.85
Custard Danish
$1.75
Raspberry Danish
$1.75
Cinnamon Struesel Danish
$1.75
Kolatchie Danish
$1.75
Apple Turnover

Puff Pastry with Apple filling, drizzled with white icing
$2.85
Caramel Danish
$1.75
Chocolate Danish
$1.75
Pecan Danish
$2.25
Cheese Danish - large
$1.75
Cinnamon Twist Danish
$1.75
Lemon Danish
$1.75
Small Apple Danish

Small Round danish with apple filling.
$1.75
Small Blueberry Danish
$1.75
Small Cheese Danish

Small Round danish with Cheese filling.
$1.75
Small Cherry Danish
$1.75
Strawberry Danish
$1.75

Coffeecakes & Kuchens

Butter Kuchen
$11.50
Cheese Kuchen
$11.50
Chocolate Pan Rolls

Sweet dough with cinnamon rolled up - 6 rolls baked in a tray together then covered with chocolate icing.
$9.50
Cinnamon Kuchen
$11.50
Edelweis

Danish base with Custard and Pecans. Drizzled with white icing.
$11.50
Fruit Pizza

Danish base with sections of apple, apricot, apple, and blueberry. Topped with white struesel and icing drizzle.
$11.50
Runny Butter Kuchen
$11.50

Cookies

Almond Macaroon
$1.25
Coconut Macaroons

Available by the Dozen only
$13.80
Spice Cookies

Available in 1/2 dozen packages.
$6.75
Ginergerbread Men

Gingerbread Cookies with Icing "buttons" and seasonal heads
$3.95
Icebox

Available by the Dozen.
$11.40
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.15
Snickerdoodle Cookie
$1.15
Oatmeal Cookie
$1.15
Oatmeal Cream Pies

Our take on the classic! We sandwich our buttercream icing between two of our homemade oatmeal cookies!
$3.25
Old Fashioned Sugar Cookie

Regular - have granulated sugar on them These are NOT iced cookies and no customizations may be done. To order anything else, YOU MUST CALL THE STORE TO PLACE THE ORDER
$1.15
Thumbprint Cookie

Butter pecan cookies with seasonal colors icing. If you are wanting custom colors, the order must be placed over the phone.
$1.15
Iced Rabbit Cookies

Decorated Iced Sugar Cookies - shaped like a rabbit, iced white, then decorated.
$2.50

Individual Treats

Brownie

Iced Fudge brownies
$1.15
Cream Puff
$2.95
Devilsfood Cupcake

Iced Chocolate. Other options available by calling the store to custom order.
$1.45
Spice Cupcake

Spice cupcake with caramel icing.
$2.75
Sprinkle Cupcake

Yellow cake, white icing, Sprinkles, and seasonal picks/rings. Other options available by calling the store to custom order.
$1.65
Yellow (cake) Cupcake

Available iced white or chocolate. Other options avalable by calling the store to custom order.
$1.45
Angelfood Dips

Angelfood cake dipped in chocolate!
$2.75
Orange Blossom

Moist Orange Pudding Cake with a light glaze with a buttercream flower on top. Flower varies based on decorator and may not be specified.
$2.75
Large Eclair
$3.75
Small Eclair
$2.50
Large Flower Cupcakes

6 Large Flower Cupcakes. Yellow Cake. Seasonal Flowers for Decorations. NO SPECIFICATIONS MAY BE MADE TO THESE (COLOR,ETC). To order something specific, you must CALL THE STORE.
$18.00

Decorated Cakes

"Grab and Go" Decorated Cake

8" yellow cake with white buttercream icing. Rose Spray as decorations. NO SPECIFICATIONS OTHER THAN A MESSAGE ON THESE CAKES. May NOT specify color, decorations, size, flavor, etc.
$34.95
12" Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

12" Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake. Sample cake designs are shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Only Confetti and Streamers, Roses, and Polka Dots are available for online ordering - CALL THE STORE TO ORDER ANYTHING ELSE). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$34.95
Confetti and Streamers Birthday Cake - 8" 2-layer (serves 10-12)

Decorated birthday Cake with Confetti and Streamers Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #3&4). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$34.95
Confetti and Streamers Birthday Cake - 9" 2-layer (serves 16-18)

Decorated birthday Cake with Confetti and Streamers Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #3&4). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Confetti and Streamers Birthday Cake - 10" 2-layers (serves 22-24)

Decorated birthday Cake with Confetti and Streamers Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #3&4). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$42.95
Confetti and Streamers Birthday Cake - 1/4 Sheet (serves 15 lg or 24 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Confetti and Streamers Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #3&4). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Confetti and Streamers Birthday Cake - 1/2 Sheet (serves 30 large or 48 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Confetti and Streamers Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #3&4). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$52.95
Polka Dot Birthday Cake - 8" 2-layer (serves 10-12)

Decorated birthday Cake with Polka Dots as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #7). Decorations may vary as we have multiple decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$34.95
Polka Dot Birthday Cake - 9" 2-layer (serves 16-18)

Decorated birthday Cake with Polka Dots as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #7). Decorations may vary as we have multiple decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Polka Dot Birthday Cake - 10" 2-layers (serves 22-24)

Decorated birthday Cake with Polka Dots as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #7). Decorations may vary as we have multiple decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$42.95
Polka Dot Birthday Cake - 1/4 Sheet (serves 15 large or 24 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Polka Dots as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #7). Decorations may vary as we have multiple decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Polka Dot Birthday Cake - 1/2 Sheet (serves 30 large or 48 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Polka Dots as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #7). Decorations may vary as we have multiple decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$52.95
Rose Spray Birthday Cake - 8" 2-layer (serves 10-12)

Decorated birthday Cake with Rose Spray as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #1) Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$34.95
Rose Spray Birthday Cake - 9" 2-layer (serves 16-18)

Decorated birthday Cake with Rose Spray as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #1) Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Rose Spray Birthday Cake - 10" 2-layers (serves 22-24)

Decorated birthday Cake with Rose Spray as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #1) Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$42.95
Rose Spray Birthday Cake - 1/4 Sheet (serves 15 large or 24 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Rose Spray as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #1) Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Rose Spray Birthday Cake - 1/2 Sheet (serves 30 large or 48 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Rose Spray as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #1) Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$52.95
Waterlily Birthday Cake - 8" 2-layer (serves 10-12)

Decorated birthday Cake with Waterlily Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #5). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$34.95
Waterlily Birthday Cake - 9" 2-layer (serves 16-18)

Decorated birthday Cake with Waterlily Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #5). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Waterlily Birthday Cake - 10" 2-layers (serves 22-24)

Decorated birthday Cake with Waterlily Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #5). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$42.95
Waterlily Birthday Cake - 1/4 Sheet (serves 15 large or 24 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Waterlily Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #5). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$38.95
Waterlily Birthday Cake - 1/2 Sheet (serves 30 large or 48 small pieces)

Decorated birthday Cake with Waterlily Design as decorations. Sample cake design is shown on our website (under birthday cakes - Sample design #5). Cake decoration style and size may vary due to numerous decorators. Cake available in a variety of sizes; yellow or devilsfood cake ONLY (please call the store to order other flavors). White buttercream or chocolate icing only (please call the store to order other flavors). NO OTHER DECORATIONS MAY BE SPECIFIED, please call the store to order any other design.
$52.95

Cakes

7" Black Forest Cake

Devilsfood Cake with Cherry filling, Whipped Icing, and Chocolate Shavings around the sides. Other sizes available by calling the store to special order.
$25.95
7" Carrot Cake - Single Layer

Available in a single or double layer. Other sizes available by calling the store to order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$17.95
7" Carrot Cake - Double Layer

Available in a single or double layer. Other sizes available by calling the store to order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$25.95
7" Devilsfood Cake Iced Chocolate

Devilsfood cake with chocolate icing. Other sizes available by calling the store to special order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$16.95
7" Yellow Cake

Available iced white, coconut, chocolate, or caramel. Other sizes available by calling the store to custom order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$16.95
Orange Pudding Cake
$10.95
Poppyseed Almond Pudding Cake
$10.95
Spice Cake

Spice cake with caramel icing. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$17.95
Sprinkle Cake

7" Yellow Cake iced white, top and sides covered with Rainbow Sprinkles Other sizes available by calling the store to order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake. To order a decorated cake, please call the store.
$21.95
8" Red Velvet Cake

Red velvet cake with cream cheese icing. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$25.95
7" Italian Cream - Single Layer

Available in a single or double layer. Other sizes available by calling the store to order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$17.95
7" Italian Cream - Double Layer

Available in a single or double layer. Other sizes available by calling the store to order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$25.95
German Chocolate Cake

Other sizes available by calling the store to custom order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$25.95
7" Shadow Cake

One layer yellow cake, one layer devilsfood. Iced white buttercream with heated chocolate icing poured on the top. Seasonal small flower on top - color MAY NOT BE SPECIFIED. Message may be added. Other sizes available by calling the store to custom order.
$25.95
7" Oreo Cake

Oreo cake (devilsfood cake with white buttercream icing, with oreos on the sides). Other sizes available by calling the store to special order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$16.95
7" Lemon Torte Cake

Yellow cake, lemon filling, whipped cream icing. Graham cracker crumbs on the sides. Alternating rows of whipped icing and lemon on top. Other sizes available by calling the store to order.
$25.95
7" Brownie Supreme Cake

One Layer of Brownie, one layer of yellow cake, raspberry filling, whipped icing, and chocolate shavings around the sides. Other sizes available by calling the store to special order.
$25.95
Devilsfood cake with Chocolate Icing

7" Devilsfood (chocolate) cake with chocolate icing. Other sizes available by calling the store to special order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$16.95
7" Truffle Torte Cake

Devilsfood cake, fudge and light chocolate filling, chocolate icing, chocolate curls on the sides. Tubes of light chocolate icing with fudge drizzle. Other sizes available by calling the store to custom order.
$25.95
Fudge Cake

Devilsfood cake, fudge filling chocolate icing. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$17.95
7" Devilsfood iced White

Devilsfood cake with white buttercream icing., Other sizes available by calling the store to special order. NOTE: This is NOT a decorated cake - decorated cakes can be ordered by calling the store!!!
$16.95

Pies

Apple Pie

8" Apple pie with Lattice Top
$14.95
Cherry Pie

8" Cherry Pie with Lattice top
$14.95
Chocolate Meringue Pie
$11.95
Coconut Meringue Pie

Coconut Custard Meringue Pie
$11.95
Dutch Apple Pie

8" Apple pie with Cinnamon Struesel Top Drizzled with Caramel Icing
$14.95
Pecan Pie

8" Pecan Pie
$15.95
Triple Crown Pie

8" Triple Crown Pie - Chess-like filling with chocolate chips and pecans
$15.95
Lemon Merinue Pie
$11.95
Pecan Tarts

Pecan Tarts (mini-pie)
$2.95
Pumpkin Pie

8" Pumpkin Pie
$14.95
Triple Crown Tarts

Triple Crown Tarts - mini-pie, Chess-like filling with chocolate chips and pecans
$2.95

Buns/Bread

Butterfluff Dinner Rolls

Sold in packages of 6. Flaky rolls baked in individual paper cups.
$4.00
Cloverleaf Dinner Rolls

Sold in packages of 6 dinner rolls. Soft yeast rolls, that pull into 2 parts.
$4.00
English Muffin Bread

English Muffin Toasting Bread. Denser bread ideal for toasting!
$6.95
Iced Raisin Bread

Iced (sliced) Raisin Bread
$6.95
Large Butter Buns
$6.50
Pumpernickel Bread

Round loaf of pumpernickel bread
$6.95
Six Grain Bread

Round loaf of six grain bread.
$6.95
Wheat Bread
$6.95
White Bread
$4.50
Hamburger Buns
$6.50
Medium White Buns
$6.50
Small Butter Buns
$6.50

Sandwiches

Benedictine Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$7.50
Chicken Salad Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$7.50
Country Ham Salad Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$8.95
Egg Salad Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$7.50
Ham on Bun

Ham on Bun - comes plain - DOES NOT INCLUDE LETTUCE OR TOMATO
$4.50
Ham Salad Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$7.50
Ham Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$7.50
Pimento Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$7.50
Sliced Country Ham Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$8.95
Turkey Sandwich

Comes with chips & pickle.
$7.50

Soups

Bean Soup

Soup is only sold frozen in pint containers.
$4.00
Chicken Noodle Soup

Soup is only sold frozen in pint containers.
$4.00
Chili - PINT

Chili is always available frozen in pint containers. Seasonally we will offer refrigerated (not frozen) quarts - based on availability.
$5.50
Vegetable Soup

Soup is only sold frozen in pint containers.
$4.00
Beef Barley Soup

Soup is only sold frozen in pint containers.
$4.00

Spreads

Benedictine Spread

1/2 Pint Carton
$6.95
Chicken Salad

1/2 pint carton
$6.95
Country Ham Salad

1/2 Pint Carton
$6.95
Egg Salad Spread

1/2 Pint Carton
$6.95
Ham Salad Spread

1/2 Pint Carton
$6.95
Pimento

1/2 Pint Carton
$6.95
Potato Salad --NEW

Pint Carton
$6.95

Easter Items

Tiny Eggs - Chocolate - each

Individual sized Egg cakes. All yellow cake (ONLY). Available either in chocolate icing, or pastel icing (white, pink, yellow) When ordering online we only allow specifying PASTEL or chocolate.
$2.50
Tiny Eggs - Pastels - each

Individual sized Egg cakes. All yellow cake (ONLY). Available either in chocolate icing, or pastel icing (white, pink, yellow) When ordering online we only allow specifying PASTEL or chocolate.
$2.50
Iced Rabbit Cookies.

Decorated Iced Sugar Cookies - shaped like a rabbit, iced white, then decorated.
$2.50
Hot Cross Buns

Seasonal Favorites! Sweet buns with cinnamon, candied fruit, and pecans. They have a "cross" of white icing on top. Sold 6 buns to a package.
$7.50

Emily H.

★★★★★

Dec 29, 2024

I ventured into Plehn's recently to get some cupcakes to celebrate my daughter's birthday with family, and Plehn's was just perfect for this.First, it celebrated its 100th birthday this year. How cool is that!?!?And it's clear when you step in that it has accumulated a wealth of baking expertise during that time. Its cases were FILLED with all manner of sweet treat, from cookies to cakes to pastries to bread to my aforementioned cupcakes. The air was sugar-filled and beckoning. Plehn's makes beautiful cupcakes with a flower design in icing on top. These were what I originally intended to buy, but they were a little outside of my budget at 6 for $19. Not complaining about that -- I imagine each cupcake takes time and skill to craft. So I looked for something else, and I found Christmas-themed cupcakes for much cheaper. And bonus: Each was topped with a plastic Christmas ring! These cupcakes were intended for several kids (and adult-like kids), so this was a great option. I purchased a dozen of these, and they stayed moist and delicious until we ate them a couple of days later. Don't sleep on this Louisville bakery mainstay. They definitely know how to make sweets that sweeten any day.

Holly A.

★★★★☆

Sep 10, 2024

Stopped in after an early dinner. Just peeled in the windows and couldn't help going in and purchasing the we didn't need. The store is clean and extremely bright and light inside. We were welcomed by multiple staff when we opened the door. You are immediately on heightened alert to the smells, colors and spectacular creations. The homemade cakes are beautifully decorated and reasonably priced. We took home snickerdoodles, chocolate chip cookies, sugar cookies with smiley faces and thumbprint cookies. We will definitely be back to get a cake for a family

Gypsy G.

Mar 6, 2024

Our favorite bakery on this end of town, the oranges blossoms are the most perfect creation and I love them. Service is always fast and friendly... everything is fresh, and they sell out of a lot quickly. Place your orders the day before or morning of so you do not miss out. It's a very cute shop and the displays are always stunning. Have gotten several of my kids birthday cakes here, so so so tasty!!Chefs kiss hit em 5 times!!

Chris S.

Jan 17, 2025

The place is easy to find and has great selections and each one I picked was great! I will be coming back for sure. The staff were friendly, not ready for a lot of new comers it seems but didn't hurt the service at all

Michelle S.

Oct 14, 2023

What an amazing bakery!! It's 99 years old!!!! Amazing chocolate eclairs and delicious UK football cookies!! Our friend grew ip in PeWee Vally KY and took us here for the best chocolate eclair ever!! He stops in every time he's in town! Wow!!

Allison R.

Nov 19, 2024

It's my go-to for all things sweets. The variety of butter kuchen's makes the selection easy. Stop in for a sweet treat!

Julian B.

Nov 25, 2024

Great food, friendly and helpful staff! Always a pleasure stopping in before work for a treat

Mary L.

Mar 3, 2025

Everything and I mean everything was fantastic cookies, eclairs, something like a beignet lol forgot what it was called and also a danish with Custard is my new favorite

Mike T.

Feb 16, 2025

Amazing baked goods of all kinds. Cakes, pastries etc. Nice to find an old school bakery that is top notch!! And nice people too!

Cheri S.

Dec 6, 2024

Louisville legendary donuts, cakes and pastries. Delicious and everything baked fresh. The dinner rolls are legendary. Have not tried their lunch but I hear it is also tasty. If you are a cheese danish fan grab a cheese kuchen for the house you wont regret it!!

Plehn's Bakery

Menu

Donuts

Chocolate Donut

Dozen Assorted Round Donuts

Glazed Donut

Cake Donut - Chocolate

Cake Donut - Glazed

Chocolate Sprinkle Donut

Dozen Assorted Donuts - Half Round, Half Specialty

Granulated Sugar Donut

Powdered Sugar Donut

Cake Donut - Blueberry

Caramel Iced Donut

Cake Donut - Caramel

Coconut Donut

Donuts - Specialty

Apple Fritter

Iced Jelly Donut

Cinnamon Twist Donut

Filled Lohn John

Honey Bun - Chocolate

Honey Bun - Glazed

Plain Long John

Pretzel Donut

Yum Yums

Danish and Individual Breakfast Items

Apple Fruit Strip

Apricot Danish

Assorted 1/2 Dozen Danish

Assorted Dozen Danish

Bearclaw

Cherry Fruit Strip

Cherry Turnover

Custard Danish

Raspberry Danish

Cinnamon Struesel Danish

Kolatchie Danish

Apple Turnover

Caramel Danish

Chocolate Danish

Pecan Danish

Cheese Danish - large

Cinnamon Twist Danish

Lemon Danish

Small Apple Danish

Small Blueberry Danish

Small Cheese Danish

Small Cherry Danish

Strawberry Danish

Coffeecakes & Kuchens

Butter Kuchen

Cheese Kuchen

Chocolate Pan Rolls

Cinnamon Kuchen

Edelweis

Fruit Pizza

Runny Butter Kuchen

Cookies

Almond Macaroon

Coconut Macaroons

Spice Cookies

Ginergerbread Men

Icebox

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Snickerdoodle Cookie

Oatmeal Cookie

Oatmeal Cream Pies

Old Fashioned Sugar Cookie

Thumbprint Cookie

Iced Rabbit Cookies

Individual Treats

Brownie

Cream Puff

Devilsfood Cupcake

Spice Cupcake

Sprinkle Cupcake

Yellow (cake) Cupcake

Angelfood Dips

Orange Blossom