Piece of Cake

Delicious! Their fresh baked cinnamon rolls with homemade icing they're baked fresh every day cookies so good! Very nice staff and every cake we have got from there has been delicious and beautifully decorated!

I was enjoying a pleasant stroll down Main St in downtown Evansville this morning when I happened to pass Piece of Cake. Fortunately for me, the door was open and the delicious aroma of their cakes, cookies, and cupcakes seemed to jump out and grab me. I honestly can't remember a smell tickling my senses in such a delectable way. It was heavenly and I had to step inside. I met a kind young woman who told me all about the family owned business and the pride they take in everything they back. I'll just say this-every city in America should have a locally owned bakery that sets such a high standard. This place is an Indiana gem!

The ono mikomiko cookies are some of the best cookies I've had. Also got carrot cake, cheesecake, pb cookies, snicker doodles, and chess bars (it was my birthday and I have no regrets on living my life this way).Carrot cake could've been spicier for my tastes but the icing was A+. All the cookies were all good, my husband thought the pb cookies were a little dry, but honestly just get as many ono mikomiko as you can afford.

Our daughter just received her cake & she was very excited. She said it tasted amazing and even though it was not made by mom - it was the closest thing to her favorite. Again thank you so much for helping a mom/dad make their daughter's birthday special even with the distance

I'll start off with the cake was very good and I say this from someone who came from a family that ran a bakery. We ordered a cake online since we were coming in from out of town, process was easy and prices were reasonable. They really missed the mark the moment I walked in the door, they had 4 people behind the counter and not one person greeted me, it was very awkward. (I considered ringing the bell for service) After a couple of minutes I was acknowledged and the search for my order was on. It was brought out and put on the counter that was it, no "Thanks for shopping with us", "Have a nice day", just nothing. Not even asked if I needed something else, I was eyeing the cupcakes. So Good Cake, Poor Customer Service.

Undoubtedly, THE BEST bakery in the Evansville, IN tri-state area. The variety is amazing from cupcakes, pies, cakes and cookies to specialty items such as chess bars and various brownies.My favorite choices are their jumbo strawberry cupcakes with strawberry icing and the chocolate peanut butter cupcakes. Their iced butter cookies are amazing as well.You can get 2 jumbo cupcakes for $5- a real steal for such deliciousness!The strawberry cupcakes have pieces of strawberries in both the cake AND icing and the chocolate cupcake with peanut butter icing is like eating a Reese's peanut butter cake. Mouthwatering!!!Don't pass up their chess bars which are really delicious. It may not be something you would necessarily consider initially but after you try one, it will become one of your regular selections.Piece of Cake also offers specials. Today when we went in, they had generous slices of their cakes for $1. Now that's a cheap sugar fix, right there!They are located right on Historic Main Street in Evansville so it's a really cool area to explore but parking can be tricky unless you can snag a parking place on a side street.Don't forget the name. PIECE OF CAKE. One amazing place, I promise!

Those chess bars are just a liitle slice of heaven. The no bakes are perfect in every way. The brownies are always a party in the mouth. The cup cakes are pure pleasure to eat. I always buy these by the dozen for office parties and they are always abig hit.The cake are pretty awesome too. They have made me a special raspberry and chocolate cake for my anniversary in the past that is my favorite of them all. That being said, their vanilla and chocolate cakes are the bomb dot.com.

Oh my God! I gave Piece of Cake another try again several years later after not liking their cupcakes' frosting in 2013-their frosting, greatly improved. Moreover, their cheesecake! Holy heck! It is the creamiest thing I've ever tasted. I pride myself on making a mean cheesecake (I love to bake) and also being a bit of a cheesecake connoisseur I will try a cheesecake anywhere out of curiosity and this is the best I've ever had ANYWHERE hands down! It is sooooo goood! I immediately thought I'd love to order a whole one for a party or Christmas instead of baking myself. While the strawberry pie was not for me exactly the crust was so delicious I imagine I could find a pie she made I would like, such as the peanut butter pie we originally inquired about, which from other reviews sounds to die for! Yum! Highly recommend this place.

This place has fantastic treats! I am obsessed with their cupcakes, especially the jumbo ones! My only complaint, is that it is impossible to find parking! I was out just now, and drove by there, but because it's on a tiny one-way street, downtown, I just came home, because I don't want to walk in the rain, or two or three blocks just to get a treat. Their location is not great.

The organizers of our event had a cake made from this establishment and I tell you right out of the box it was a sight to behold. It was the most beautiful cake I had ever seen. I believe some shed a tear when it was cut into slices. Upon tasting this magnificent creation I couldn't believe how wonderful it was. In all honesty, it was absolutely the best slice of cake I have ever had. I love cake and I have had cake from my travels around the world, but to me this place has the best cake ever.