Newtown Village Tavern

We ended up here on accident because the place that we intended to go was not open. Welp, I'm so happy we did! You can tell that this is a "locals favorite" type spot. We ordered the ranch (chicken and bacon) pizza and it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The jalapeño poppers were good but the RANCH is what made everything over the top. I overheard another patron bragging to a friend about the homemade ranch. The loaded fries were a bit soggy and had an overwhelming amount of toppings. I didn't know that was possible but my husband nor I recommend those. Service was good. The younger bartenders seemed newer or introverted. Friendly enough.

Review: A Cozy Neighborhood GemTucked away in a friendly neighborhood, this local bar delivers solid flavors and great service. We ordered a large extra pepperoni pizza, two bourbons, and six beers, totaling $74.87--a reasonable price for a night out.The pizza was a standout, with well-seasoned toppings and a perfectly crisp crust, earning a top-tier taste rating. While the menu sticks to classic pizzas and sandwiches, the quality makes up for the limited variety. The atmosphere is cozy and unpretentious, making it the perfect spot to unwind.The real highlight? The staff--genuinely welcoming and attentive, creating a "home away from home" vibe. If you're after great service, familiar flavors, and a relaxed setting, this spot is worth a visit.

My Mr. and I passed this place so many times and I was interested! So on a Saturday afternoon we dined in for lunch. They are known for their pizzas but our server Michelle mentioned that the hoagies and their appetizers are also a hit. Their pizzas are best described as your Americana pub but better. The sauce is flavorful and the pizza crust is not thick or thin but in the middle. Trust me it's good.We ordered:16" Build your own pizza 1/2 and 1/2-Ground beef, mushrooms, green peppers -Mushrooms and banana peppers -Jovani Pinot Noir-C.M.S Red Blend-Peroni BeerPizza was amaze balls! Reminds me of the pizza joint in Dayton called Marion's pizza. The style is close. The pricing of the pizzas and drinks are reasonable. You can get 8", 12", 14" and 16" so there is perfect size for everyone. Plus they offer cauliflower crust. They have salads, appetizers, hoagies and burgers. The service was great and Michelle was an excellent server. She can tell it was our first time so she patiently went through the menu. We are fans and I can't wait to come back and try the rest of the other items on the menu.

Add this to the ever endless list of, "We need to try that place sometime" spots. Yes, this started as one of those, and it ended as a "We're definitely coming back" one too. Great pizza, excellent drink menu, fantastic service, and a very laid back local atmosphere.We went in on a Saturday for lunch because we were wanting some good local pizza. We already liked the place itself once we walked in. It wasn't huge inside but still had lots of comfortable seating. Our server, Michelle, greeted us right away, and said we can sit anywhere. We sat nearby the bar at a high-top table. Michelle was very friendly and told us all about the menu. There's lots to choose from too. Here's everything we had:-16" Build your own pizza 1/2 and 1/2Ground beef, mushrooms, green peppers -Mushrooms and banana peppers -Jovani Pinot Noir-C.M.S Red Blend-Peroni BeerWe hardly waited long at all for the pizza and it was as absolute delicious. I honestly couldn't stop eating it and kept going back for more. Plus it paired very well with the Peroni.Great little spot with so much to offer, not just tasty pizza, but the pizza alone made fans of us. We'll certainly be coming back for more. We might try a couple hoagies next time.

We were exploring the city and looking for pizza joint, the first we found was takeout only so kept searching. Glad we found this spot because it was delicious. It's in a cozy house, has a few tables and nice bar. The menu is basic but enough with some appetizers, salads, pizza, sandwiches. Only downfall I wish I had seen the review of ordering it well done because my favorite pieces were the crisp corners.

If you're in the mood for some thin crust pizza and don't feel like dressing up to impress anyone, you might want to make your way over to this hidden gem. The renovated outside seems welcoming, but the charming old-world bar interior and friendly staff just add to a great experience. No frills- just simple, good pizza in a neighborhood bar setting.

This little gem has great service and prices! Salads fresh and large. We had the antipasto salad and it was very delicious. Order your pizza crispy or well done and you will not be disappointed. We had the cauliflower crusty and built our own pizza it was so yummy. The jalapeño poppers were served crispy and hot. Cold brews too. Awesome place which a lot of outdoor seating to bring your furry friend.

If you're concerned about my photo attached, I ordered my veggie burger with no bun, but was absolutely delicious anyways. The whole table agreed that the fried pickle appetizer was the best we ever had. They have a variety of beers and seltzers. The waitress was extremely kind and bubbly and was so polite when we asked a bunch of questions, while most waitresses get annoyed with the bulk of ingredient restrictions we inquire about. Next time I come back here, I'm looking forward to ordering a pizza with a cauliflower crust!

Great food, nice atmosphere, excellent service. Just a nice place to get away too. Nothing fancy, but always comfortable!

Had dinner here with a couple of friends on a Sunday evening. Karly and Sammy were on duty behind the bar and as servers. They were both on top of their game during our entire dinner and our food was well prepared and tasty. Fully satisfied and highly recommend!!