Cheese pizza
Our order
Interior
Decor
Interior
Interior
Menu with lunch specials
Entrance
Specials menu
Decor
Exterior
Small pepperoni and banana pepper pizza
Best pizza!
Menu front
Menu
App menu
Interior
Chicken strip salad
Burnt. Pizza. Like they had to see the pizza they put in the box right?
Pizza menu
Sub menu
Supreme pizza with banana peppers.
Large cheese
Veggie supreme & added pepperoni on half
Denise S.
Dec 2, 2024
The pizza and wings were hot and delicious. The pizza reminded me of years ago when Godfathers Pizza was around. The wings were big and sauced just right. We are new fans of JT's. The lady that answered the phone and waited on me was very nice.
Read MoreWendy F.
Dec 18, 2024
Nice staff, pizzas, subs and your typical bar food. Neighborhood bar atmosphere with good spacing of tables so conversations can be kept private. TVs to watch the games. Nothing to write home about but I've eaten here a few times and I'd go back.
Read MoreRenae D.
Oct 28, 2023
Loved this little low key casual pizza spot. If you're in the area it's definitely worth the stop. Great service & great food.
Read MorePatrick F.
Aug 27, 2024
Good pizza, has gluten free crust for those looking. Service is great and inside is nice and relaxing.
Read MoreSteve C.
Jun 28, 2023
I am traveling through, found this spot for a relaxing dinner. Loved the pizza. Had some cheese sticks too. Also very good. Will define come back the next time I am near.
Read MoreJohn W.
Nov 22, 2023
Some friends and I ordered 3 large pizzas: cheese, veggie, supreme. Within fifteen minutes, all three pizzas were basically finished. Personally, it was some of the best pizza I've ever had. Fast, too. Highly recommend.
Read MoreAdam J.
May 20, 2023
This is a great little place. It's the only pizza place in Simpsonville but it would be the best even if there were. Friendly folks and good food. What more could you want?Also you have to grab the cheese bread or cheese sticks. Whichever they call it, it's the cheesiest and I love them. Also see if you can spot the 7Mary3 memorabilia on the walls. It's nice for this of us that loved that band.
Read MoreDanielle D.
Jul 30, 2023
Lived in Shelbyville for a while and always drove past this place without thinking much of it. We randomly decided to try it one day, and their pizza is so good. We've ordered both online and over the phone: service was so simple and helpful both ways. Crew pie is a must try if you aren't a pineapple hater. My one tiny complaint- I get a slightly different combo of topping amounts every time I order. Sometimes there is barely any crushed red pepper, and other times, my eyes are watering. Delicious either way, and my husband's consensus is that the subs are equally great.
Read MoreAudrey W.
Feb 9, 2025
The best pizza I've found around this area. Delicious pizza, great service and wonderful staff. The only pizza I get now!
Read MoreJanice K.
Nov 29, 2024
My family and I stopped here on the way back to Indiana after Black Friday shopping. We were beyond pleased and happy with the food. It was the Absolutely best pizza we've had in a long time. The Staff were extremely kind and checked on us often. We will definitely be back when we come back down this way!! Thank you J T's pizza.
Read More