J Miller Steak Company

We are from out of town so first time here. We had 20 in our party and they were able to get us in and handle the large party with ease. Melissa was our server and she was great. If we lived here we would most definitely be back. Give them a try.

Great service and great food. Highly recommend. Had a ribeye and it was cooked to perfection. A good place for a great meal

I've visited this new place in town twice now. Once I was with a party of two and the second time I was with a party of twenty two. After both visits, I must say that I am not very impressed. However, I think that there are changes management can make to greatly improve this restaurant. First, the staff needs to be properly trained on how to serve guests and interact with customers. Many of the employees I spoke with simply didn't have the knowledge necessary to help when needed. Second, the menu item recipes need to be reviewed and altered. Everyone in my group agreed the steaks were chewy, fatty and often undercooked. The mixed vegetables were very bland as well. In terms of what we enjoyed, the mixed drinks were all very good and the atmosphere and restaurant decor is very enjoyable.

We just tried this place for the second time....or tried to try it.... The flustered hostess at the front wouldn't honor our reservation, which we even physically presented to her on our phone... the first time was last year and the food was horrible. We just chalked it up to them wanting to close soon but if this is the standard I suggest you go ANYWHERE else.

We really enjoyed our dinner at J.Miller. I had the pork chop, which was on special the night we went, with baked potato and Mac and cheese. Here is where a star was lost. The pork chop had way to much pepper for me and the Mac and cheese could have been a little warmer, but the pork chop was perfectly cooked and very juicy. My wife had the big salad with salmon. Our server did a great job noting my wife's food sensitivities and went the extra mile taking a picture of the ingredients in the salad dressing. The salad came out perfect. And the piece of salmon was HUGE.The inside of the restaurant is beautiful, if you like old exposed brick, which I do. And I have to mention the chairs in the dining room. Simple the most comfortable I have ever sat in, in a restaurant. Well padded with an upright back. We have to get back to see the upstairs space. It sounds amazing. Give this place a try.

Steaks cooked over a hickory fire were amazing. Cole slaw and Mac n cheese sides were good, too. For an appetizer we had sweet potato fries with caramel sauce- don't pass on this b/c it was delicious!! Service was very good, too. Nice rustic vibe. It's great to support a family run business. We will definitely be back!

Was traveling through Aurora to Lawrenceburg for girls basketball sectional and looked for a steakhouse in the area and J. Miller came up. It was so good we came back the next night when we came back through for the championship. Really neat old building with a lot of history, built in the 1870s. Seating was very spacious and comfortable. Service was excellent! My sister ordered her steak well done and it could have stayed on the grill a little longer but other than that everything was perfect!

Our first time here after driving by many times. The atmosphere was fantastic! The food was cooked to perfection! My filet and my husband had the Aurora strip--best steak we have ever eaten out!! Baked potatoes were soo good, you can eat the skin (Not dried out like some other places). The bread was very good as well! This place is much better than the rated 3.6!! Recommendations (which do not reduce my 5 star rating). have servers or hostess give customers the drink menu when seated (we had to ask for it) and would have rather had a salad for an upcharge from the traditional side list instead of the full charge of that item). I do realize as a business owner times are hard to get staff perfect but these are some simple changes that may help receive more positive reviews.

The ribeye was cooked perfectly as ordered and the service was amazing. We had a large party and Melissa took great care of us with fast, accurate service with a smile.

Service, definitely. Ordinary food trying to be elevated, unsuccessfully, to another level.