Hornville Tavern

Hornville is always a great choice! Haven't had a bad dish. Love their twice baked potatoes. Wished they were available daily.

Excellent. Country fried steak, fried chicken, and thick pork chop all great. Beer bread to die for. German potato salad homemade and delicious.

I had heard prior to my visit to Horneville that the new management was awful (some would even say that one of the owners is a bad guy). But I still gave it a shit anyways, and well, it tastes just like shit. It was really good back in the day when I was a kid I remember the family gatherings and this place used to have such a welcoming environment. We started off with some pepper cheese balls, they came out cold and soggy! I'll be honest with ya I probably won't ever be back again just from ordering my starters. Ruined my whole birthday, went home crying!

Very good food! Nice hometown feel. Small but has great service. Their appetizers are delicious. Never had a bad meal

Worst experience ever! What happened to Hornville we used to love? I would rate the food, but we NEVER GOT IT (after waiting 1 hour and ten minutes after ordering). Four tables that arrived after us got their orders.We came for the smoked chicken Monday special: they were out, so we ordered sandwiches.Womens' bathroom has 4 stalls: two were out of order, one was full of sh#¥, only one worked: filthy. Would give zero stars if possible.We'll not be going back any time soon.

What happened to this place? So many menu items were unavailable that it was hard to order! Pork chop "special" was not special and overpriced at $18.99 for chop, instant mashed potatoes, green beans, and beer bread. No substitutions. Plus, my chop came out barely warm and fatty with gristle throughout. Our beer bread and daughter's side salad didn't make it to the table, but we were charged. Such a shame because this used to be a gem! Did management change? We, sadly, won't be back.

We had lunch here last week. Upon walking in, one of the waitresses was clearly put out about our group coming to dine there. Luckily, we ended up with another server who was kind and attentive. Food was ok but some items came out cold. The rudeness from the first employee we encountered soured the overall experience and makes it unlikely we would return.

This used to be one of our favorite place to eat, sadly that has changed. We had reservations for 6:30 on a Friday night. We were before 6:30 we and informed that they were out of Ribeyes, pork chops and chicken breasts. Uh...how could someone let that happen? The waitress told my wife they would let her have the New York strip for the same price, what an offer especially since they were the same price anyway! My wife ordered the strip state medium well, I wanted the chicken fried chicken but that was unavailable as well, so I ordered a cheeseburger, another ordered a cheeseburger as well, and someone else ordered the chicken fried steak. My wife's steak was served rare, my burger was burnt, and the other burger was only partially eaten as he didn't like the taste. The Chicken Fried Steak was the only good meal at the table. Worst meal we've ever had there.

Hadn't been here in a year or two. Like everyone else they are short staffed. Drinks are fine. Ordered Rib Eye Steak dinner med rare - came out well done. Re-ordered and it was med rare but tough. Wife had ribeye sandwich, was really good - had been marinated and was tender. Something irksome, they charge extra for every item you add to your sandwich, Mayo lettuce, tomato - anything you add is between 45 cents and 70 cents extra. Pretty bad when the sandwich is already $12.95. Also restrooms were dirty. The table was cleared quickly.

They have good food and service usually, occasionally you'll get a slow service or your food might not be right, but they will immediately make it right for you!that's the only thing that stopped me from giving five stars. But they're definitely a great place to eat. they even have gator tail if you're looking to try some!