GaylaCake LLC

Cupcakes

6-Pack Regular Cupcakes

Regular cupcakes may include any of the following flavors with vanilla icing (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): white, chocolate, strawberry, red velvet, yellow, banana, lemon, orange, confetti.
$10.90
6-Pack Specialty Cupcakes

Specialty cupcakes may include any of the following flavors/icing combos (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): strawberry with cream cheese, red velvet w/ cream cheese, yellow w/ chocolate, banana w/ cream cheese, cookies n cream, chocolate mint, chocolate w/ peanut butter, pumpkin w/ cream cheese, cherry vanilla, and more!
$13.53
6-Pack Gourmet Cupcakes

Gourmet flavors may include (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): German chocolate, carrot, coconut, buckeye, lemon supreme, death by chocolate, unicorn, vanilla caramel, caramel macchiato, mocha, raspberry cheesecake, blueberry lemon cheesecake, raspberry lemon, and many more!
$18.15
1 Dozen Regular Cupcakes

12 regular cupcakes may include any of the following flavors with vanilla icing (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): white, chocolate, strawberry, red velvet, yellow, banana, lemon, orange, confetti
$19.80
1 Dozen Specialty Cupcakes

12 specialty cupcakes may include any of the following flavors/icing combos (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): strawberry w/ cream cheese, red velvet w/ cream cheese, yellow w/ chocolate, banana w/ cream cheese, cookies n cream, chocolate mint, chocolate w/ peanut butter, pumpkin w/ cream cheese, cherry vanilla, and more!
$24.20
1 Dozen Gourmet Cupcakes

12 gourmet flavors may include (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): German chocolate, carrot, coconut, buckeye, lemon supreme, death by chocolate, unicorn, vanilla caramel, caramel macchiato, mocha, raspberry cheesecake, blueberry lemon cheesecake, raspberry lemon, and many more!
$35.20
Cupcake Bar

Build your own cupcake with our Cupcake Bar. Pick your cake flavor, filling, icing, and up to 2 toppings!
$4.35

Cake

8" Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

Include your custom message and color requests in Special Instructions. This item requires 1 hour to be prepared.
$13.20
6" Cookies and Cream Dessert Cake

6" cakes serve 4-8. This is a cookies and cream cake with our vanilla icing.
$19.80
1/8th Sheet Cake

This small sheet cake will feed 8-10. Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Icing.Include your custom message and color requests in Special Instructions.
$16.50

Bars and Brownies

Gooey Butter Bar

Also known as chess pie bars, these rich delicious treats are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. They have a buttery, cakey crust with a gooey cream cheese filling on top.
$1.65
Pecan Pie Bar

A shortbread crust with a pecan pie filling baked over the top.
$1.93
Irish Buttercream Brownie

A cocoa brownie with a layer of buttercream made with Baileys Irish cream, and topped with chocolate ganache
$2.15
Cookie Dough Brownie

A chocolaty brownie covered in cookie dough filling and covered in rich chocolate ganache
$2.15
Buckeye Brownie

A chocolaty brownie covered in buckeye (peanut butter) filling covered in rich chocolate ganache.
$2.15

Other Bakery Items

Cream Horns

Golden crispy puff pastry filled with a traditional cream horn fluff, and sprinkled with powdered sugar.
$2.15
Kolaches

Kolaches are a Czech pastry made out of a yeast dough and usually filled with fruit, but sometimes cheese.While we try hard to keep these available, please understand that flavors may vary depending on availability, and substitutions may need to be made.
$2.15
GaylaCake's Choice Goody Box

Let our employees take care of your sweet tooth! We will pick out our favorite items from the case and put a variety goody box together within your budget! Some items may include, brownies, bars, cake balls, or cookies! All variety boxes vary depending on items available. If you would like something specific, please let us know in the instructions and we will try to accommodate if possible.
$5.00

Drinks

Coffee

Standard cup of coffee.
$1.65
Dunkin Donuts Iced Coffee
$3.52
Minute Maid Orange Juice
$2.34
20 oz Bottle
$1.99
Tum-e Yummie
$1.16
Smart Water

20 oz bottle
$1.87
Gold Peak Tea

Extra Sweet.
$2.12
Core Power Protein Shake

Chocolate Flavor
$3.75

a decorated birthday cake

a birthday cake

a table of cake pops

a camera cake

a cake with a family picture on it

Most beautiful, tastiest cake and cupcakes ever. So moist, I would highly recommend Gayla's cakes for any occasion!!

a book and a quilt

a thomas the train birthday cake

a basketball themed birthday cake

food

interior

food

Robin C.

★★★★★

Sep 29, 2019

Square almond flavor cake. Very pleased with the service and how delicious the cake was! Gaylacake is very creative and timely! Thank you. (I recommend order early.)

Alicia M.

★★★★★

Dec 19, 2018

I knew I wanted a local business to make my daughter's 1st birthday cake. I had had Gala's before so I found an idea online and GalaCake brought it to life! It was perfect. Everyone most especially the birthday girl loved it. Can't wait until the next visit

Monique S.

★★★★★

Jun 5, 2018

We ordered a cake for my mother in laws 70th birthday and it was incredibly moist. Beautiful cake and great service. I highly recommend ordering a cake for any occasion from GaylaCake.

Amy G.

★★★★★

Jul 20, 2017

Wonderful cupcakes! I got key lime cupcakes for my husbands birthday from here and they got rave reviews! Grabbed a couple cookies when I picked them up to keep us out of the cupcakes until party time and they were excellent too! Great to work with as well.

Sharon W.

★★★★★

Sep 29, 2023

This is my go to place for cupcakes. She makes delicious cupcakes!! I just had a baby shower and got two different kinds of cupcakes and they was a big hit!! I've only tried a few kinds so far! Our favorite are the Raspberry filled!

Mark J.

★★★★★

Mar 27, 2021

Just happened to stumble across this bakery, after eating at the pizza place next door. I'm sure most of their business involves weddings and events, but their cupcakes are absolutely delicious. Prices for cupcakes are very reasonable during their Wednesday special. Compared to grocery store bakeries, this place is on a different level.

Marita C.

★★★★★

Jan 18, 2021

GaylaCake exceeded my expectations for my birthday cake. Super friendly staff who asked lots of questions about what I was looking for. I ordered a naked strawberry-lemon marble cake with fresh fruit, and it was delicious! Fair price too. Will be ordering again!