Fat Santa's Pizza & More

We almost didn't come here because of the reviews but decided it was convenient so we would try it. Jayda took our order and was very pleasant to talk to and helpful. It took about 20 minutes to get our pizza and it was hot. Not too bad for fresh made pizza. The place is very clean and would come back again. We ordered the Santa Supreme. As you can see plenty of toppings and we left none of it behind!!

No. No no no no no. No. No no Twenty six letters plus this. Cute name never answers a call. Paper thin crust with paper thin toppings. Do yourself favor and go west - away from the park Hoosier land pizza and wings !

I should preface this by saying we were here in the off-season so they may have had staffing issues. It's a great idea, being right across the street from Sanders lodge so super convenient for people staying in the lodge. The pizza however was only "OK". I've had much better, but I've had much worse as well. The crust was thin crust however it was the kind of thin crust that tastes like a saltine cracker if you know what I mean. Again, not horrible, but it's not going to win any awards. We went there a second day to get ice cream and literally had to hunt someone down to do it. There was no one at all in front of the house, looked like it was all staffed by teenagers Who were slacking off in the back. Kind of expensive ones well for what we got. Six dollars for two small scoops of ice cream. Hopefully during tourist season here they are better run

Where do i start!? Parking lot is too small and only had one entrance/exit. Upon entering restaurant, you're not greeted by anyone and you have to walk all the way down to the other end to the desk. Sign says order here, yet there was no on there nor did anyone show up. Three employees behind the counter loooed at us and didn't even offer to ask if we needed assistance.

We waited 50 minutes for 3 pizzas, 2 salads and a sandwich. Sandwich came out wrong, asked for correction, came out wrong again and was brought a cup of cheese and mayo packets. Everyone acts like working here is a big inconvenience. We had to ask for cheese curds multiple times. Other people complaining of wait time and they weren't even busy. Trash cans are disgusting and overflowing. This will not be on our "return to" list.

Great food and great service. Support local! Recommend for sure. Give it a try! It will not disappoint

Fat Santa? More like Skinny Santa because I am feeling pretty frail after waiting what felt like an hour for my food. I'm feeling muy pequeño if you catch my drift ;) Like seriously. We even had to get a refund on some of our food because they forgot about it.

Stopped here with family on a weekend trip. We placed our orders and as the food trickled out, it was beginning to look bleak. Three buffalo chicken sandwiches were ordered " sauce on the side", all three were wrong. We said no biggie to that part. Then, time went on, and I had not received my burger or our cheese curds. We asked a few times as we approached an hour wait, and were told "we're trying", "burgers are backed up". After waiting an hour, we were then informed they were out of cheese curds. Another 10 minutes later, finally received the burger. Obviously, at that point, the entire family was finished eating and ready to leave. During the time there, there were four other tables that had experienced issues and got partial refunds. Another customer had done a call-in order for a burger and stood there waiting for an hour. Also, they were down to one functional bathroom for a crowded restaurant. The pizza is delicious, and the place has potential to be much better with proper management.

This was our 8th visit to Fat Santa's and as a local, we've really tried to give the establishment the benefit of a "bad" day. With that said, during our first few visits, when it was off season, the food was much better (even if alittle long to wait) than the last two visits, which ended with us finally after 75 minutes asking for our money back. The visit in question came when they had at least (5 people in the back prepping/making food and 1 person at the register) they were not busy as there were only, 4 other tables occupied when our order was placed.Finally after 45 minutes, the only thing that was brought to our table was a pizza that over half of the crust was burnt black and the boy that brought it to us simply said "its burnt, but should be ok". The rest of our order never arrived, which was simply fried chicken tenders which go in a fryer. I did pop my head over to the counter because you can see the kitchen in the back just to ask if there was a fryer down. The up side is that they did refund our money when the rest of the order didn't come out after 75 minutes. minus of course, the tip.We really have tried to be patient as this is one of a few close places that locals to the area can go grab a bite, but unfortunately until you figure out how to successfully organize the staff in the back so they are not just talking and laughing at each other, or on their phones, you will continue to get less than favorable reviews. This could be fixed, but right now it is just getting worse.

The food is kind of good, and the service was also kind of good, and the decorations, uhh they didn't really have much decorations.