Cincinnati's Goodfellows

This is by far my favorite bar to go to when I'm in Cincinnati visiting from NYC. The selection of whisk(e)y is incredible and perhaps only eclipsed by the vast selection of bottled/canned/beer on tap. The employees are very personable, make a habit of learning your name and can always be trusted to recommend a great beer (especially Nick). Highly recommended. Great pizza/bar food as well!!

I enjoy their pizza, but I ordered directly from them for pick up, not using DoorDash or a delivery app. There was an online surcharge on the receipt. Why is there a surcharge if I ordered for pick up directly from you? Left a bad taste in my mouth.

Some of the best bartenders in Cincinnati shout out to the Kyles. Great food you can't miss with anything you order. Weekend nights is kinda fratty and it's not cheap to go here but overall highly recommend it!!

We had a pleasant experience last night at Goodfellows. There is a very friendly atmosphere and it is typical of a sports bar. We went in around 5:30 on a Friday and we're seated immediately. Our waitress was with us promptly. We ordered a large house salad and the Turkey Sub. The food came out quickly and was very good. The prices were very cheap and it's a perfect place to go if you want some good food without breaking the bank!

I never really gave this place a fair judgement because it's a strip-mall bar, that Oooo, serves pizza, how original! I'd been a couple times in the far distant past and kind-of forgot about it. Occasionally I'd see pix or reviews touting the pizza, and I finally went back tonight for a take-out pie. I got The Goodfellow (pictured) and it was f'ing great! It's basically every topping thrown on one pizza. Sauce was great, crust was great, and I'll definitely be back for more take-out pizza and maybe try some of their subs. The place itself just is not my kind of place. Sports bar look and feel. Figured they'd only have 3 beer selections, Bud, Bud Light, and Miller Lite. I was wrong though! They had decent tap selection and very adequate can selection even for a beer snob(like me). The few songs that played while I waited for my pizza, "The Lady in Red," and Kenny Loggins' "Danger Zone" played, amongst other late '80s "rock" songs played, so I'd say it's not a music snob(like me)'s cup of tea. So, look, feel, and sound of this place are all red flags for my snobbery, but it's beer selection and pizza quality can not be argued with. So get over any misconceptions you may have about strip-mall sports-bar pizza, and pay them money!

Kyle, not only hires but trains the best and as a result, the service is always top 2% but it's the consistency of the product and the classic flavors of Italian culture that come through and make this place so fun to hang everybody hangs here cause I love to hang here with not just their friends and neighbors, but because of the good service and product

Good Fellows has been operating in the Anderson Towne Center since 2004. I'm in the area at least one a month and often pass by but had never walked inside until my family and I were in the area at lunch time. It always looked so dark from the outside I assumed it was more of a bar than a restaurant. But it turns out they are open for dinner every day of the week and lunch on the weekends.We were seated near one of the front windows and there was actually a surprising amount of natural light entering the space. I think that the red walls and dark ceiling make it look much darker from the outside than it truly feels inside.After placing our orders, we found a few games between our table and the entrance to help pass the time. A couple of arcade games were available, but the Foosball table proved to be the most fun!One of our kids is a pretty picky eater and unfortunately decided he didn't want pizza. We ended up with the Italian cheese stix with the sauce on the side ($5.99). I would have preferred one of other appetizers such as the pepperoni balls or the veggie skins, but these weren't bad.My wife and I decided to try a couple of the signature pizza offerings but splitting the pizza in half. Louis's love features olive oil, fresh garlic, artichoke hearts, banana peppers, black olives, and goat cheese. While the BBQ Grippo is topped with BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onion, cheese, and BBQ Grippos chips. Both were $10.49 for a 10 inch all the way up to $20.99 for 16 inches.I love BBQ Grippos and that half was an easy decision for us. I thought the Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce complimented the spicier chip topping really well. This is a must try! Louis's love was much different, a more traditional pizza combination and was also good. Good Fellows has a couple of other unique signature pizzas include lemon pepper chicken and chicken fajita. Overall the food was good, service was quick and friendly, and the value was just right.

Absolutely love their food specifically the wings and pizza!! I am so happy to have a great place like this to watch sports and have good food!

Easily the best pizza and calzone I've ever had in the Cincinnati area! 100% will go again!

Horrible pizza and wine order again from them because it's bad. I'm from a place where pizza is great. I miss it here in ohio