Tony's Pizza

First off, I gotta say: IF YOU HAVEN'T TRIED TONY's pizza, DROP WHAT YOURE DOING AND GET DOWN HERE!!!First time here and my mind is blown!!!This place is the real deal!! It has all the hits and coziness of a new York Pizzeria!The decor is spot on, the smells and sights even better!!!Jacob assisted me today and man! Does that guy have customer service!!!He was super nice, very knowledgeable about their pies and even made some helpful suggestions!!THANKS JACOB AND TONY'S PIZZA FOR MAKING A GLOOMY DAY BRIGHT!!I highly recommend this place, you won't be let down!!!

Well the Pizza use to be 110%Now it seems they've changed the sauce or are using a different brand of pepperoni. We recently ordered a few pizzas and they were salty. I'll try them again maybe this day was a fluke.

Ordered through door dash.Mozzarella sticks were ok.The sauce was sadly very watery and a little flavorless. We ended up buying some sauce from an Italian restaurant to dip it in, and it helped a lot. The good thing was, it came with a lot of pieces.The pizza is ok too. This is our first time eating cannoli, and it was our favorite of the night! The breading is nice n crunchy and the filling was sweet and soft.

First time eating at Tony's pizza located inside the Whittwood Mall. We ordered individual slices - cheese and pepperoni. We learned that if you order two slices, you get a free drink. That was a plus! The total for the 2 slices was approximately $8. The pizza slices were huge. They slices were hot - they had reheated the pizza. The service was great. We. Immediately got greeted by the staff, and our order was given to us within 3 min. We came in around 2ish, so they were not busy. The inside also had cool ambiance with a low light feel and lots of pictures on the walls. They had some xtmas lights around the windows. We will be returning to try other pizzas.

They seem very busy with online orders and pickups. Which is a good sign. You can order by the slice or a whole pizza which is what I did. The vibe is very New York. Come to find out that the owner is Italian. I saw him walk out as I was waiting and when I walked out heard him speaking in Italian with customers who were dining outside. I did enjoyed my food.

TL;DR: Suffers from a consistency issue, but when the pizza is made with love, it's good! Sadly, it just isn't always prepared with care anymore.Yearning for more? 1/2When they are having a good day, my favorites from here are: Lasagna Pizza, The Gourmet and the Bianca. Delicious! The issue is that the food is no longer made with as much attention to detail as it used to. The consistency of this once beloved spot is no more. I'm no longer a fan of their calzone. All the cheese was on one side and the veggies spread on the other. Very bland. Pepperoni was somewhat evenly distributed. Sucks because I remember their calzone being completely different in terms of preparation and flavor. On our last visit, the pizzas both tasted like they had been made already and they re-heated them. Sadly the quality has gone down, but the prices have gone up. The last time we dined here was such a let down we haven't returned since. We'll be back at some point, just kind of bummed after our last experience.Expenses: 0/1The last time we were here our order was ~50 for two large pizzas, which is somewhat standard for gourmet pizzas, but our food was not made fresh and it showed. It's only been worth the price on about half of our last 4 visits. We were able to pay via debit card. Location: 1/1The location is easily accessible with plenty of parking spaces available in a huge lot. The staff is friendly and the location is clean. Possibility of a Future Visit & Recommendation: 1/1I'll be back at some point and I recommend checking this spot out if you're around, but I would think twice about making a long trip out to try this spot as it has not been delivering a good product consistently. Hate to rate one of my previous favorite pizza spots a 3 but, I don't want to be biased and that's what I think is fair now.

My second favorite pizza.Haven't been here in a few but in the area so got to get my grub on.Still looked clean and festive. By the slice or full pizza, always love the multi choices you get. The lunch special is always the greatest. Wait staff always been friendly and today is no different smile and friendly as well as attentive.If your shopping this is the place to grub. A lot of new improvements new menu sign. New POS system.They even got garb you can by advertising Tony's Always love the pictures on the wall. Always a conversation piece while you ate eating in. They Hold a,"A" which is great.Had the lunch special and the pizza as always is Bomb! Flavors so well mixed pizza worth the trip Always feel at home when I come in to eat. So glad I stopped in. On my top 3 favorite pizza joints this is my second.I highly recommend this establishment

I used to love Tony's when I was in highschool. I came the other day and Honestly I'll never be back. I don't recommend going. You're better off going to La crusta or something. The Tony's Pizza was just okay, they had no drink options (2 if your lucky) drinks taste like crap, no ice in the machines and the worst part is that the soda machine is clearly grimy, crusty and had yellow crusted water deposits all over it. If you go into the store right now and walk to the machine you would 100% agree with me. Those machines are not cleaned and it's obvious because you can taste it IN THE DRINK that something in the machine is not right. That could get you sick. This place needs a good inspection high and low. There was a female worker there she was clearly so rude about me not liking the drink. And said it was just "flat". She had barely even taken a sip with a new cup and instantly poured it out. She tried the other flavor and did the same thing. She said "it's just flat." No... the tubes in those machines have mold or build up in them cause I could taste it. Anybody would agree. That machine should be replaced. Looks like the same machine from when I was in highschool in 2009. And nothing much was done when I asked them if there was maybe canned soda since I paid for it. They just said no. I don't like to leave bad reviews but I hate wasting my money and it going to a business that does not care about the quality of their not so clean machines. Sorry but I don't recommend.

Been my go-to spot since I was a kid. Seating both inside and outside, great pizza, and the staff remembers us from a while back.

Best New York style pizza in the area. A Great selection to choose from.Very good C/S.Nice Ambiance.