The best ice cream sandwich ever
Menu
Peanut Butter and Sugar Cookies Packed with Care
Outside
a person holding a sandwich in their hand
outside
Marley making my Ice Cream sandwich- lemon cookies with Strawberry ice cream
Toppings along the wall
Hubby's Rocky Road
Baked goods
the inside of a doughnut shop
Chocolate chunk vanilla ice cream
Adorable decor and lights change color!
Front door, under a garage door.
As of 1/13/25
Toppings
Small serving!
interior
Toppings menu and cones
food
As of 1/13/25
Ice cream menu
Some flavors
food
Heather T.
Dec 27, 2024
We love this place and come here often. The cookies and brookies are soooooo good, don't sleep on those thinking that ice cream is only way to go. The brookie is basically a brownie and it's moist and rich. Our favorite cookie is the Eldonwhich as choc chips, coconut, nuts (basically everything). The cookies are big and filling and a solid value. All the staff here have been awesome. But Megan is our favorite scooper and is so nice to us every time.What you get for the price here is an amazing value. Highly recommend.
Read More
Nick C.
Dec 12, 2024
The ice cream is amazing here (Thrifty's) and they have a great assortment of flavors. I tried the Eldo Royale cookie for the first time last night and it was INCREDIBLE. Chocolate chip coconut macadamia. Need I say more?Get your self over to the eldo and don't forget dessert at scoop!You can even order it while enjoying yourself or company at the eldo! Awesome.
Read More
Anna L.
Feb 13, 2025
I love coming here for the Thrifty's Ice Cream and cookies. Staff is always so nice. It's a cute set up inside and the main restaurant is next door. Parking can be a challenge sometimes but there is dedicated to go spots for "The Scoop"
Read More
Sandy H.
Jan 30, 2025
Tiny shop next to the Eldo that serves Thrifty ice cream. Staff are patient and friendly. Prices seem to have increased recently as have most things but the scoops are HUGE and the cookies are a good size. I tried the Eldo Royale cookie which basically has a little of everything.
Read More
Edward N.
Aug 15, 2024
Been here several times but always ate what I got before I could snap a picture.We come here for ice cream on the weekends and we love it. There's a good variety of ice cream flavors, cookies, and almost too many toppings to choose from. My partner normally gets a scoop on a waffle cone and I order the Big Trev. It's an ice cream sandwich with ice cream in it. You can mix and match the cookies for the sandwich and mix and match your ice cream flavors as well. The girls working are awesome, super friendly and nice and it's just a cool little spot off the beaten path. Not where you would expect to find good ice cream. Will we be back? Of course!
Read More
Deanne R.
May 26, 2024
Yay thanks to Yelp I finally made it in here. For some reason I thought in order to get ice cream we had to visit eldo. I didn't know it was separate.Small spot but wow the scoops here are HUGE. So glad we made it in. Oh and it's thrifty's ice cream I think we found our new ice cream spot. Service here was great thanks Megan and Kirsten.
Read More
Melissa G.
Jul 31, 2024
Excellent flavors and service and such a cute ambiance. Must try this at work conference
Read More
Greg S.
Aug 30, 2024
Big Trev was awesome! Cookies were delicious, with two large scope of thrifty ice cream in between; it was a behemoth! Definitely to split with two people. I think I nailed the combo with a white chocolate macadamia cookies with chocolate malted crunch ice cream. But I'll try something else next time and see if I can beat it.
Read More
Cindy O.
Jun 9, 2023
After we stuffed ourselves at The Eldo, we came next store to The Scoop. You can't miss it, attached and store front stands out. Apparently this is where the pick-up orders for the restaurant are processed. Under the same owner and operation.Cute place with a lot of baked goodies to select from. Cookies, brownies, cakes slices and of course ice cream! Great place to grab some sweets for later! Ice Cream is Thrifty's, nothing special but we always enjoyed our Thirty's cones we would get from Naples' Rite aid (miss them!) and over at Two Islands General Store (Catalina).Cookies were very good. Ice Cream single scoops were ginormous! Prices were very reasonable!Service was excellent. Very patient and kind young girl scooping, offering taste tests, and packing our goodies with care. Definitely we will be back again and again!
Read More
Michelle D.
Nov 11, 2024
Last couple of time brought home the chocolate cake, it tasted stale and dry.Use to crave this cake, but not anymore.
Read More