Eatalia Pizza

It's a hole in the wall type shop but the food is delicious. We got the BBQ chicken pizza and made our own. Would definitely go back

Pizza time again... and what did I tell you people? There's 5 kinds of pizza: (1) NYC; (2) Neapolitan; (3) Chicago; (4) Sicilian; and (5) Garbage. And to be clear, if it's not one of the first 4, it's garbage.Listen all you pizza joints out there - STOP advertising your pizza as NYC style when it's NOT! GAH! I guarantee 9 out of 10... or more... are garbage!Okay, on with the review. I judge all foods by their basic iteration. And for pizza, it's a slice of cheese pizza. Simple, clean, and where the crust and sauce should come through and shine. Geez, this place is so close, and yet, so far. That sauce was juuuuust under tangy... come on. And the crust? The flavor was good, but DAMN IT... cook that s#!t till it's freaking crispy... GAH! So to circle back - is it NYC style? Mmmm... yeah, and I do mean barely as it qualifies at the lowest minimum. Sure, it's better than garbage pizza, but again, it could/should be better.HOOOO man... it's upsetting when this happens. I wanted to like this pizza more than I did, but HEY... I got what I got... so you get the review I give.Go here? Meh... eh... do what you want...

Our go to pizza so far... right across from our hotel. 2nd time visiting and ordered again from here. Thin crust pizza that taste soo good!! 5 out 5. Wings taste good, my preference will be a little more sauce please! 4 out 5. Price 5 out 5. Location, convenience, friendly 5 out 5.

Horrible. Ordered the food on DoorDash and the food was atrocious. I regret ordering from this place. A total waste of $85 and most of the food was not even edible. The cheese calzone was okay, but the crust was bland and not good. The dough was dry. The shrimp Alfredo was super saucy like a bowl of soup. And the Alfredo sauce was super underwhelming. It tasted like it was straight from a jar of Alfredo sauce. Actually no, store bought Alfredo sauce tastes better than what they made. The fettuccine was disgusting. The fried calamari was appallingly gross. The pieces of calamari were not coated all the way with breading, and the calamari were overcooked. It was chewy and inedible. The clam chowder was an absolute embarrassment. Tasted like some crap from a can. I couldn't even eat it. The cannoli was the only thing that was edible out of the entire order. The mozzarella sticks were gross. What even were those? They don't taste like mozzarella sticks at all. Also inedible along with everything else. So disappointed. And still hungry. I had to place another order for food somewhere else afterwards. The food here is complete garbage!! Calzone1x CheeseRicotta * Small$14.981x Fettuccine AlfredoSingle * Shrimp$14.991x Fried Calamari$13.991x Mozzarella Sticks$10.991x Clam Chowder$7.991x Cannoli$6.991x Ranch$1.50Total$71.43

Okay this is the definition of do not judge a book by its cover. When driving into the parking lot, it will not look like much. It is a very mediocre looking exterior in a gas station parking lot. However then you park and head inside. WOW! The inside is truly remarkable. Insanely clean and filled with a lot of tables to enjoy the pizza at the restaurant. Immediately when I walked in I was greeted with the friendliest hello I have ever received. It also amazed me with how quickly they managed to get the pizza baked and in my hands. Remarkable service! Now the big piece of this pie, how was the pizza? We all come to a pizza place for the food. Well this place serves traditional New York pizza. They offer by the slice, but when I went it was only cheese by the slice. Overall this is a great pizza. It is filled with some great flavors and toppings. Truly everyone needs to try this place! Parking is super easy here and I highly recommend visiting this gem!

I got the front window special one topping with pepperoni and garlic large. When I complained about paying almost 2 bucks for adding crushed garlic he threw it on for free. It was a little small for a medium but solid pizza given how late you can get a decent slice anywhere else that late and with what seemed like hand pressed crust. The crust and or sauce are lacking something that I cannot put my finger on but that would make it a five star taste. It's a small sit and eat with the family kind of place but typical old strip mall style shop with not so comfortable seating.Also got a salad for my daughter that she didn't eat and I ate it two days later. It was still crispy very large portion and delicious. Could be enough for two or three to share even though it came in what looked like a smaller container than expected for a large. It was packed full and tight with Romain, fresh grilled chicken, that had the grill marks on it, and had really good caesar dressing on the side. Even though it was very basic it hit the spot in more ways than one and I'll be back for more of it.Can't say anything really positive or negative about the staff. When pressed for answers to questions about the food, like does the salad have croutons it didn't seem like I was understood but it was late and maybe they were as tired and burned out as I was yet still making some decent food.Giving it four stars for being the best pizza place around open late. Comparing it to other fast food type pizza places it's three.

Late night pizza hangout after Disneyland! We stumbled upon this joint after checking out the liquor store next door. What more could you ask for? A freshly baked medium pepperoni pizza deal!!!! Definitely going here again!!!

The last slice of my pizza had hair. No one in my household has that long and grey colored hair.Calamari was normally priced but was only about 40% full of those small to-go containers. It was also over cooked, like rubber. Pizza was good, unfortunately, I didn't get to eat my last slice because of the hair.I picked this up to go, so service and ambiance means nothing to me.

Whoever made the lasagna that I ordered dumped a ton of salt in the food. It was unbearable! I had to throw it away. EASE UP ON THE SALT!

We ordered this while visiting the Disney parks. Important to know that this place is open late, S of the writing of this review. I used their website to place our order. I got a large pepperoni, Medium Hawaiian and double order of spaghetti with meatballs. The large pizza was huge, while the medium is more the regular pizza parlor large size. We had leftovers of both but they were great on flavor. The spaghetti also had flavor but is a tomato based sauce without meat. The meatballs were also good. When we ordered this, it was about. Midnight. The food arrived, delivered to the hotel, just before 1am. The delivery driver was very friendly and greeted me properly. I would recommend this place.