Sully’s In The Valley

Nice restaurant with indoor and covered outdoor seating. Friendly staff and quick service. We both had Cheeseburgers and shared an order of tater tots. The food was very good and decent sized portions. We will definitely stop here again the next time we are in the area.

When Sully's opened we were excited about the prospect of a "wood fire" pizza, sadly the first experience was lack luster and a let down, but since it was their first couple of weeks we gave them a pass. Six months later, we once again tried the pizza, and again were disappointed, the pizza was mediocre at best, still no "wood fired" taste to it. A third try (late November 2023) and last. The pizza is and never has been what was taught all the time leading up to opening and currently. A waste of an investment for an oven such as this if you're not going to utilize it or quality crust/ingredients. We did have a few sandwiches over time and they were adequate. I guess we'll still be driving to Jackson or Waverly for pizza as the other pizza in Beaver has gone down hill also.

Nice little place with good food and good people. We will definitely be back. I had the italian sub and it was fantastic. You should check it out.

Wow what a great place. Friendly, clean and the food is fantastic!!! Will definately be a return customer. Coming next to get some brick oven pizza. Frosted mug rootbeer is the topper.

Heard about this place few weeks ago and decided to take a trip over to eat some Friday night pizza. Located right off the Main Street in Beaver. Sully's is truly a gem of the village, great food and the ambiance is nostalgic. The owner was friendly and greeted us during our wait and checked back in with us to ensure our visit was a great experience. The staff was pleasant and helpful in providing details about their food items. Pizza crust and sauce is made locally. Will definitely visit again for some Friday night pizza or potato skins!

I've been to Sully's several times, and each visit was a positive experience. Prices are a bit high, but the food is good, with generous portions. I love that they play Oldies music from the 1950s and 1960s.