Prime Time Pub and Grill

Staying in town on my way to work, I decided to see what was available. This was a great surprise!While it looks like a strip mall esque chain, it's local and is very inviting once you arrive. Couple that with being ULTRA clean and you have a great first impression. The staff were very pleasant, helpful, and quick. I sat at the bar and the service was extraordinary. As for the prime rib; ABSOLUTELY amazing. Perfectly cooked to my specifications, complimented by a baked potato with basic accoutrements at my request, this was the perfect meal!Highly recommend going past the chains and get here as quick as you can.

We rented out the room next door to the restaurant for a work event, which Prime Time catered. The room was brightly lit, and we played corn hole. The server was quick and attentive, and the food was tasty.

We were looking for a nice place to have dinner and drinks before a football game and Prime Time did not disappoint. My husband was able to watch the Hoosiers on multiple TV's... as well as other sports networks. Of course I was excited that they had Michelob Ultra on tap and it was perfectly chilled. My husband ordered the old fashion and was pleased with the taste. We were especially excited that they served us pub chips while we waited. Our food was served quickly and our first bite was the French onion soup. It was good, but the taste was a little different. It had a smoky flavor that my husband liked... but it probably wasn't a highlight for me. The prime rib with au jus and horseradish was delicious... perfectly cooked! Our service was definitely worth 5 stars! Derek, Devin and Ben were fantastic and quick to deliver and clean up!* we came back after the game and we were greeted by name! WOW!! Thank you for such amazing service!

Mondays are half price burgers. And they are big and juicy. They start you off with homemade chips which are crispy and tasty. They have drink specials also. Live entertainment on their patio is a plus for an evening. Always had friendly and prompt service whether in the dining room, bar or on the patio. I recommend this place for food, service and ambiance.

My wife and I were cordially invited out for an honorary evening and while we were in the Newburgh area we decided that we would go out to eat afterwards. We decided upon this place after a little debate on trying something new and eating Indian food. As you can tell I lost the debate and we settled for a truly American style restaurant. I have never been here before and was thoroughly pleased with my wife's selection. We entered the restaurant and only stood there maybe two minutes before being seated. The booth was nice and the ambiance was great for an evening meal for two. The table was sticky though. From what I gathered it was the paint and would be willing to bet that every table was sticky. We were served water without asking for it and also some house made chips were brought in a moderately sized bowl. I was the first to try the chips and the water. I later gleaned my wife's take on them both. The water was absolutely tap water. No filter. The chlorine after taste was superb. The chips were certainly very crunchy but felt almost stale, albeit they did have a good flavor and I was hungry and ate most of the bowl assuming the texture was supposed to be as it was. We were also offered more water before our chlorinated pitcher was empty so I was obliged to say of course. Then our waiter came by and took our order. She didn't come back but to deliver the bill and receive payment. Our food was delivered accurately and seemingly promptly. The food was wonderful. I had the prime burger. I mainly chose this because the menu wishes you luck in the description? My wife ordered the prime dip with onions and peppers, for a little extra $$. It was served with a Au jus sauce and some horseradish sauce. The prime burger was great. When I ordered it I was asked "Red or no red" . I said no red. The burger had the patty, bacon, and bbq on it and it was really good. The fries were good too! Especially dipped in the horseradish sauce. I tried the prime dip as well. It was really good too. And it reheated well in the microwave as a leftover. The place was nice and I had a good time with my wife for a night on the town. Thanks Prime Time.

Really impressed by Prime Time!! Both my husband and I got the Mac Daddy burger and it was GREAT! Good service and fries were decent too. Overall, we were very happy we chose Prime Time for our date night dinner.

When we arrived we were seated immediately. It was 1pm on Saturday. A bowl of complimentary homemade chips were served. They were cold and overcooked. Some were almost burned. We ordered onion straws as an appetizer. They were limp and left a greasy taste in our mouths. Served with a smoky Ranch dip that did not work for me.My wife and i ordered the Prime Dip sandwich. I added peppers and onions to mine. My wife did not. The large bun was split in half with thin sliced beef piled over the bun with melted cheese and onion straws heaped on top. It was so much there was no way to fold it to dip it in the au jus. After she started eating her sandwich, she found hers had been made with peppers and onions too. She just pulled them out because she didn't want to wait for a new sandwich to be made. Service was okay but only around four or five tables had customers. When our server came to ask if our food was okay, my wife hadn't found the onions and peppers yet and our server never returned to see if we needed anything. The restaurant was nice. The food just left a lot to be desired. Plus the check before tip was $51.05 for sandwiches for lunch on a Saturday!

My kids took me to prime time Newburgh June 14 for Father's day. Our took our orders and came around a second time to make sure he had everything right. 5 of the six of us ordered salads and asked they be served before our entree's. I ordered a 12 ounce ribeye medium rare and a baked potato. Our entree's came out followed by our salads. It isn't very often I say the salad was the better part of my meal. But it was. My baked potato could have passed for one fixed the day before. My steak was closer to well done than medium rare. I should have sent it back but didn't want to be there all night. I brought it home and tried to make a sandwich with it. A LOST CAUSE. Food is usually pretty good but not this time.

I drove two hours away to come here for dinner, and overall I'm let down and disappointed. Service was excellent. The waiter, Brandon, was very attentive, patient, and kind. The tots with pulled pork tasted good with extra bbq sauce ordered on the side. However, the ribeye was very bland, and overcooked, which thankfully I ordered rare, because it was medium rare, with only a slightly red center. My GF ordered the blackened salmon, with the bourbon glaze, which was hard and dry, blatantly overcooked. Not sure how that made it out of the kitchen. The mashed potatoes were... horrible. The cheese on them was cold, and they tasted like air. The drinks are okay I guess. Would not come back unless I was being paid to.

Our 1st time here. Really liked it. Great service, cool place, good food ( we liked everything we ordered including kids meals except onion soup. I was not really impressed by onion soup), great beer selection and cocktails.