Old School NY Pizza

There is a reason that old school is a regular spot for many of us in the neighborhood...Aside from the great food, it's the people that make the business! For example, yesterday while we were getting pelted with snowmageddon 2025 , Old School opened and stayed open and the place was packed...A huge thank you to Chris and Natalie for being open, our regular favorites, Brooke and MacKenzie, thank you both for being there for all of us!!If you haven't been you should and I recommend the Brooklyn pizza, their cheeseburger pizza is awesome, and they make a killer Philly steak and cheese.The sandwiches and salad are also top-notch, you can't go along with any choices that you make!See you there!Cheers!!!

We love this neighborhood gem!! We can get pizza any where but always come here because it's delicious! When we dine-in we sit at the bar and Brooke is fantastic! Her service is attentive and she's simply a kind soul! Pepperoni pizza is our go-to because well...it's a classic! Pepperonis are perfectly crispy and it's just the right amount of YUM! The crust is my favorite part - you can taste the freshness! If you crave pizza and a beer - make a stop here!

If I could've picked 3 1/2 stars that's probably the score for New York pizza. Ordered carryout, service fast and friendly. Looked like a decent place to sit down and watch the game and have a beer. Pizza was just OK (would ask for it well done next time) I wouldn't really call it New York style pizza (crust to thick) more of a football style pizza, but a solid pizza for game day. 6.5 out of 10

We tried the PBR (potato bacon ranch) and pepperoni pizza. Crust was good, not too thin and had a nice crunch but not burnt. The ratio of sauce to toppings was spot on. The flavors really didn't wow me, reminded me a bit of frozen pizza. It was good but not anything special. Nice patio area, friendly staff, and the pizza came out relatively quickly.

Old school is a great spot to get good pizza, sandwiches, etc. always a friendly staff and great service. I'm a regular here because it's so consistent.

If this was my first time, I'd never come back! Awful service from the kitchen! Ordered a pizza and pepperoni knots to go...knew it was busy and would be a while. But... pizza came out nearly 30 minutes before the knots and they put in a warming bag... unacceptable to not have them ready closer to same time! Need to be better Old School!!!

Typical NY Style Pie but nothing to write home about (I prefer Goodfellas for NY style). Good experience with service both times but I came 2:30 pm on the weekend so it wasn't busy. I got the $9.25 special both times I came and the slices were reheated nice considering I bought by the slice and during the end of the special. I recommend the Ford Truck Plant Pie! Ambiance was fine but I didn't love the house flies...

Pizza was OK, I'm a Detroit style pizza lover and this proved it. The staff was great and pleasant. We ordered take out and it was rather quick. I'd say it rates a little better than Spinelli's Pizza but really greasy.

This place is crazy busy with families, and bar flies alike. My take out pizza was ready when promised. The hostess, was friendly and efficient while juggling two or three things at one time.

Old School Norton Commons has amazing pizza and other menu items but most importantly the owners and staff are amazingly attentive to their customers! It's my go to for pizza.