food
Menu
First Mate sandwich
menus and prices on the wall
menus on the wall above the counter
Natalie H.
Nov 2, 2024
Friendly fast counter service, daily special on separate board. Today $11 for piece of fish, sandwich bread, 2 fried green tomatoes, a hush puppy. Drinks extra.
Read More
Virtual C.
Mar 11, 2024
The greens had zero seasonings or flavor. The young kid at the counter was picking his nose at a furious rate.
Read More
Danielle B.
Dec 19, 2023
Stop taking them away the best fish and onion rings are to die for and don't forget the rye bread and tarter sauce
Read More
Marty W.
Nov 26, 2022
Overpriced and extremely immature rude service. Inside seating still closed.Not your best option..
Read More
Barbara F.
Apr 11, 2022
I love this place. The fish always tastes fresh, the fried mushrooms are good, and the shrimp are a nice size. You can't go wrong with a fish box for two, plus you can substitute onion rings for fries. Frankly, my spouse and I often create our own platters by adding ala carte shrimp and clams to our fish box order when we want to have a feast. We pick up food here at least twice a month if not more often.
Read More
Don W.
Dec 17, 2019
Probably the best fish sandwich in Louisville KY, always has been. Zero complaints about the food. The service? Well let's say today o walked in and the person behind the counter just stared at me blankly, I told her what I wanted and she could not have been less interested. She clearly did not want to be here and was loathing every second of it.
Read More
Tamika J.
Aug 17, 2019
I have always loved this restaurant. I ordered the First Mate. It's one piece of fish, fries and hush puppies. It's a no frills type of place, just good seafood. I gave them 4 stars because I didn't receive all my condiments. I asked for ketchup, tarter sauce and spicy ranch. I only received tarter sauce. I asked if my condiments were in the bag and I was told yes. It's disappointing because my food was good. I think customer service can make or break a business. Small things mean a lot.
Read More
Bill R.
Oct 21, 2019
Stopped in to grab a quick fish sandwich. One piece sandwich, fries, hush puppies and a drink $9.19. Stopped in at 11:55 place is deserted. Fish was hot , crispy and tasty. Got one large piece and a smaller fish strip. Fries are warm gummy and tasty less.
Read More
Cheri S.
Aug 2, 2024
Best, freshest fish in town. Dont sleep on it. I hadn't been here in years til tonight. I will be back. Huge pieces of fish, onion rings of deliciousness, hush puppies with that fresh cornmeal. Everyone working in here is hustling and they saved me about $9.00 !!!Yep I said it 2024 and they helped me save $$ not spend more. Best fish fry going --more than just fish. Friendliest people in town.
Read More
Bryan M.
Feb 5, 2023
Best fish sandwich in the city. Breading is perfect. Fried perfectly. Fluffy with no grease. I love this particular Moby dick, I have never had a weird piece of fish here. I love the tartar sauce so much I get a jar every time I go. The big hush puppies are my favorite in the city.
Read More