Maddy’s Diner 23

I first visited Maddy's Diner 23 five or 6 years ago when helping deliver donations to the pike County Food Pantry. This was my first time back in this part of the state since then and I told my wife we needed to stop here for lunch. This is strictly a breakfast/lunch place and it closes around 2-3p in the afternoon. We arrived around 1pm and "seated ourselves". A waitress greeted us almost immediately and took our drink orders. She returned promptly to take our food orders. Now this is NOT a fast food place and it takes a couple of minutes for your food to come out but it's worth the wait.The food was as good as I recalled from my last visit in 2018. My wife is impressed that I can always find places like this - i.e. the stainless stell look and feel of a classic old diner that also serves great food.If your travels take you to Pike County, check out Maddy's Diner 23 - you won't be disappointed.

The food was pretty good. I got country steak and the steak was okay, but not the best. Onion tanglers were great and all the other food was good. The service was good but refills were kinda slow but she was nice. The ambiance is very casual and old timey.

Typical "old style diner" ---- Tasty food, great service, reasonably priced. Sit and have fun with the locals.

We frequent this little place as often as we can. We love the neighborly feel of the place. Our little girl loves sitting at the tables with a mirror. The food is always good.

Great old-fashioned diner. Food was on point. The owners were super friendly and shared their story.

One of the best burgers in Ohio. Your basic 1/3rd pound burger, nicely seasoned, with cheese and very fresh lettuce, tomato, onion, and great pickles. The onion straws are a great complement. Fast and friendly service, too!

We went there for a family birthday celebration, they were very accommodating. The food was very good, the service was superb. It is a classic 50's diner style, clean and nostalgic.

Food, was over cooked , mash potatoes not warm tasted old. 8 usually don't do reviews but , my experience with the food was bad, the waitress was good and sweet. I won't go back.and I am a local that tries to support local businesses.

Very slow service. Basically everyone that works here has a very unappreciative disposition

We were visiting my daughter and her husband in Waverly from out of state and my mother wanted to try this old timey diner so we did. I ordered biscuits and gravy and after waiting 45 minutes for our food the waitress delivered my b & g to another table that came in after us (regulars) then came to tell me they were out of biscuits and gravy and weren't making anymore and I had to order something else. I was so upset that they would give my food to someone else and make me order something else. I'll NEVER go back. EVER!