Hometown Pizza - Crestwood

Something is different about their pizza and I like it! The crust is crispy around the edges and reminiscent of the old school pizza hut pizzas. Very good! I would really like for the to go orders to be stored on a heated rack. My only complaint is that when I pick it up, it's close to room temp. (I usually get there within 20 min of ordering). But hey, I like my pizza so hot that it almost scalds the roof of my mouth.

I love Hometown Pizza. I have now decided it's my favorite. You have to get the cheese sticks, and their pizza is amazing. What makes both the cheese sticks and pizza amazing is the crust. I don't know how they do it, maybe they bake it in like a cast iron pan, because it has a nice crisp to it, and it's clearly infused with some butter, because it's buttery melt in your mouth. I've only gotten the thick crust, haven't had thin, but I'm sure it's just as good. They are generous with the toppings. We got a build your own with pepperoni, mushrooms, black olives, and red onions. The flavor of their marinara sauce is well balanced (not sweet but also not too tart or spicy). The garlic butter we got to dip our cheese sticks in was heaven. Staff is very friendly and personable. Place is always clean. It's a highly recommend if you're asking about best pizza in town

Our FAVORITE! Order ahead and get the carry out every time! Better than papa John's or dominos for sure.

I really like hometown pizza and when I was at my dads this weekend he wanted to order some hometown pizza. Maybe a pizza fanatic I said sure I'll get it on that. I never have the Crestwood location before so when they came back with the pizza we got a meat lovers a cheese and pepperoni and sausage. The meat lovers for sure is where it was that very flavorful had extra sauce on it it was on point. My daughters like their cheese pizza. And sausage and pepperoni seem to be able to get to. So over all this is excellent establishment that I recommend recommend

Basic but excellent pizza. The buffet is excellent and affordable. Baked spaghetti is good too! Nice atmosphere and down-to-earth service. Worth the money.

The best pizza in Louisville. While in town for the night we ordered cheesy breadsticks, a Hometown Special (think Supreme) pizza , and a Sausage pizza for carryout. Service was quick and attentive to our needs. Pizza and stix surpassed even my very high standards. We will order again when back in Louisville next year.

Cheesy, warm, and delicious! The perfect combo for the perfect pizza! I am definitely making this the main place I go to from now on. :)

(Originally 1 star) Edit: Owners responded saying that policy doesn't exist considering that they change it I would give this place 4 stars.This place... Never in my years (And I am an old man) have I ever been to a restaurant that would not allow you to move tables together. We came as a group of 11 and had to sit at different tables even though every single table in the room was open. On top of that our waitress was passive aggressive with everyone. Pizza was the only good part, got the buffalo chicken. I would not recommend dining in at this restaurant until 'no moving tables' policy is removed.

I have eaten at this place for years and i have never had a bad experience until today. Usually we would've gotten greeted with a "hello" "how can we help you?" Instead, the best we got was "name?".. Me and my grandma were excited to enjoy our annual Super Bowl meal, but instead we were greatly disappointed.. My grandmas chicken wings were so cold that anyone would've thought that they were in the refrigerator before and put in the box. I was shocked at first because we've never had problems from this location, but when i bit into one, i was appalled. Our cheese sticks were cold as well. I thought at first that it was just because they told me that the wait time was 1 hour, so i knew that the food wasn't going to be piping hot, but i also didn't think that the food would be refrigerator cold. What's even more interesting is that when i got there, there was barely any cars in the parking lot and hardly anyone inside. The old lady with black hair was extremely rude when they were trying to find my order, not professional at all and was on her phone the entire time.. When they found my order they sat at it down on the counter and walked away. They made me feel as if i was bothering them for doing their job. Needless to say, there needs to be better customer service and management for this specific location, because for being a paying customer nobody should ever have horrible customer service and cold food!

The last time we ordered all but one pizza was wrong. That order had several pizzas, a sandwich, and breadsticks. It had been awhile and thought let's try it again. Well again a big NO! Someone else went and picked it up and got home we did not have the sandwich and extra sauce. Had to drive back up to get the sandwich which was on the rack ( now cold) and by the time I got back home the pizza and breadsticks were cold! The girl behind the register did not say sorry or nothing! DO NOT GO THERE IF YOU WANT YOUR ORDER CORRECT AND HOT! You are better off driving to Bearno's Pizza!