New York Pizzeria

The pizzeria inside the New York Hotel on the Vegas strip is a convenient spot for a post-night-out meal, staying open late to accommodate your late-night cravings. Just a heads up that this spot is a bit pricy, where 2 slices and 2 garlic rolls were over $20. The pizza, also, isn't true New York style due to its thicker crust. Some letdowns were that the pizza was VERY greasy, had a hard crust, and minimal meat toppings, with only about three small pepperonis per slice, but it wasn't the worst pizza overall. Despite these drawbacks, the convenience and late hours make it an ok choice for a quick bite after a night out.

We stopped at this little pizzeria in the New York New York Casino for a quick snack.The slice of pepperoni pizza was just aiight. Nothing to write home about. Not bad, but not great.

I got the chicken and broccoli stromboli. They took it off the display and heated it up before packing it up in a to go box. It came with a cup of marinara sauce, fork, and knife. It was cheesy and easy to bite into.

After a disappointing pizza experience at NYNY, I walked across the bridge to the MGM and tried the NY Pizzeria located at the bottom of the escalators. I ordered one slice of peperoni with sausage and one slice combo. They put both slices into the oven and brought to my table when ready. Although just warm, the taste was good. I asked them to put one slice back in so I can eat it hot. They grabbed me a new slice without issue. I like my cheese melted and stringy. The tastes were spot on though. 2 min in the oven seems to have done it. Thank you to the young lady that served me. This place has the typical pay by the slice look. Bright and clean but open to self seating.

The Stromboli was awesome! It was cheesy and pretty tasty, but 3 stars bc they have such little options. You can't order a slice of what you want. You can order a whole pizza of what you like, but if you want to be fast, then you're limited to their options. Cheese, pepperoni, and maybe one or 2 veggies pizza. It also looks so thin and dry.I'm highly sad that they looked from afar they had choices, but really, there are only two pizzas out there you can choose from. It's good they at least had the bread sticks/balls thing and the Stromboli. But for 17$ Stromboli, it's def not worth it. But then again, it's vegas.

I decided to get the pepperoni and jalapeno slice. I wish there was an even amount of toppings as the slice was very jalapeno heavy. There's not much pep on there at all. To me, it seemed a little thicker than the usual NY style slice. I found it interesting that the paper plate had the logo for Bonanno's New York Pizza (which I've had in the past in Downtown Summerlin). I don't know how it's connected with this pizza joint in the NY NY casino. For almost $11 a slice, it's still good but expensive.

We got two slices of pizza for $20 plus a drink so $20 something. Way overpriced for the quality and slice. It was a good pizza but just a bit overboard on the price but we were hungry. Once was pepperoni and the other Hawaiian.

It's a simple concept that's in every Las Vegas casino, and this is the third one I tried this week. The pizza here was good, not outstanding. It certainly hit the spot for those hunger pains. I am just so amazed that a slice of pizza costs $12.

TL;DR: decent food. Counter service. Will repeat. It is a bit on the pricey side. That is to be expected being inside the mandalay bay food court. I got the Stromboli + beer combo for $30. Stromboli was served warmed and tasted good and the beer (can) was cold. Service was fast and efficient. The food court was clean and modern with charging ports and power outlets at each table!

The worst pizza I've ever had. It was dripping with grease with every bite and the texture was awful. The crust was so hard to chew. Never again.